Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
(OP)
Hi,
I'm trying to select a packaged diesel fire pump to provide flow to a hydrant on a site. The facility is connected to the city's fire water line, but does not have enough pressure. If a fire hydrant is required to have 1500 gpm at 20 psig, does one select a pump for 1000 gpm or 1500 gpm?
I think NFPA 20 mentions something about the fire pump being able to handle 150% of its rated capacity. Can I say that my pump "rated capacity" is 1000 gpm, and therefore, 150% of my rated capacity is 1500 gpm, and would meet the fire hydrant flow requirement? Or do I select a pump for 1500 gpm + 50% = 2250 gpm?
If the facility has a fire hydrant (1500 gpm) and 2 buildings (bldg A: 225 gpm and bldg B: 300 gpm) that require fire sprinkler system. Does one size the fire pump for a fire hydrant + bldg B = 1800 gpm, or just the worst case (1500 gpm)?
Thanks.
I'm trying to select a packaged diesel fire pump to provide flow to a hydrant on a site. The facility is connected to the city's fire water line, but does not have enough pressure. If a fire hydrant is required to have 1500 gpm at 20 psig, does one select a pump for 1000 gpm or 1500 gpm?
I think NFPA 20 mentions something about the fire pump being able to handle 150% of its rated capacity. Can I say that my pump "rated capacity" is 1000 gpm, and therefore, 150% of my rated capacity is 1500 gpm, and would meet the fire hydrant flow requirement? Or do I select a pump for 1500 gpm + 50% = 2250 gpm?
If the facility has a fire hydrant (1500 gpm) and 2 buildings (bldg A: 225 gpm and bldg B: 300 gpm) that require fire sprinkler system. Does one size the fire pump for a fire hydrant + bldg B = 1800 gpm, or just the worst case (1500 gpm)?
Thanks.





RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
Example: you may only need 20 psi at 1500 gpm for the hydrant, but you need 300 gpm @ 65 psi for the sprinkler system.
You could probably get by with a 1000 gpm @ 65 psi pump, maybe even slightly less psi.
Travis Mack
MFP Design, LLC
www.mfpdesign.com
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
The 1000 gpm for fire pump selection, is that up to the engineer then to decide what he/she wants to use? Does NFPA allow that? Any ideas what the 150% of rated capacity is meant for?
I understand what you are saying about fire hydrant flow and sprinkler system demand. So it is not a combined flow, but rather use the higher flow and make sure pressures are adequate. Does NFPA mention about using the higher flow in the code somewhere?
Thanks.
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
In my opinion you should contact the AHJ to ensure that the Hydrant will be the only suppression device that will be required to meet the required water flow. If there is a sprinkler system in that building you should suggest to the client to purchase a pump package that will meet both.
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
Or, is less expensive to install a larger diameter fire line - or - is it more reliable to install a larger diameter fire line and offset the cost with the increased reliability?
I'm just asking.
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
The facility is required to have both fire sprinkler systems in the buildings and fire hydrants on site, and is connected to city water, which provides enough flow, but not enough pressure due to the difference in elevation. So fire pump is needed.
NJ1,
I just wanted to see how this 1000 gpm is determined and if NFPA has any requirements. Given enough flow, but not enough pressure at the site and that a fire pump is needed, why would one select a pump for 1000 gpm when a fire hydrant requires 1500 gpm? and in doing so, does that still comply with NFPA 20? Or maybe NFPA doesn't care as long as you can get 1500 gpm out of the fire hydrant?
The requirements here is that I have to meet NFPA 13 and 20. The problem with my facility is the pressure due to elevation difference (~100' higher than point of connection). There is enough flow. Whether the fire pump will work depends on what flow is used. If my rated flow is 1000 gpm, then per my calculations, the suction pressure at the fire pump is positive (NFPA 5.14.3.1). This works!! But if my rated flow is 1500 gpm, then I'm getting a negative suction pressure at the fire pump. So hence my question... does using 1000 gpm meet NFPA requirements, if any?
Hope that makes sense.
Reference
NFPA 20-5.14.3.1 - Unless the requirements of 5.14.3.2 are met, the size of the suction pipe for a single pump or of the suction header pipe for multiple pumps (operating together) shall be such that, with all pumps operating at 150 percent of rated capacity, the gauge pressure at the pump suction flanges shall be 0 psi (0 bar) or higher.
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
You will have to be able to test the fire pump at 1500 gpm. If you are getting negative suction pressures at 1500 gpm, then you are going to be looking at a storage tank, or putting the pump lower on the facility if possible.
Travis Mack
MFP Design, LLC
www.mfpdesign.com
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
Now only if I can convince my other engineers to use the fire hydrant flow and not use combined flows of hydrant and building. You wouldn't happen to know where this verbiage is in NFPA would you?
Thanks.
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
They are just simply independent systems when calculating. It was explained to me a long time ago that if you have a car fire in the parking lot and are using the hydrants, then you would not need to figure the fire sprinklers flowing. If you have a fire in the building, the sprinklers are going and you just have supplemental help from the fire dept, so you don't need to figure the full site fire flow adding to the sprinkler system. That explanation may be entirely wrong, but it at least made sense at the time.
Travis Mack
MFP Design, LLC
www.mfpdesign.com
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
If the pump is drawing from a potable water main, make sure the pressure in the underground suction piping supplying 1500 gpm (1000 gpm pump @ 150%) does not drop below 20 psig. NFPA 20 will let it go down to 0 psig, but the environmental/AWWA regs just about anywhere in the US prohibit that. If it is less than 20 psig make darn sure you do an exhaustive code search for this location and confer with the AHJ.
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
Travis Mack
MFP Design, LLC
www.mfpdesign.com
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
Is this 20 psig pressure to ensure that the pump won't cavitate or is this to ensure that the underground piping won't get crushed?
Thanks.
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
"Fire suppression is a failure in prevention"
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
So what does one do when we don't have the required minimum 20 psig? Install a storage tank in the suction piping? I noticed NFPA calls this a "Break Tank". It's going to be 15 minutes x 1500 gpm = 22,500 gallons.
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
I would try putting the backflow preventor underground as far upstream as possible.. in a pit if it has to be... And then run the calcs to show that the piping upstream of the BFP is >20 psig..
Downstream of the BFP it can be any pressure at all, as long as the suction of the pump is at 0 psig or above. In other words I think you can go negative.. but more than likely your pump will be higher than the UG line so it will always be positive.
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
On another topic, just found out yesterday that heat tape will be allowed under NFPA 2010 edition. Guess I can start specifying wet pipe system.
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
h
The city of Augusta will allow 15 psi but not sure how that squares with the state EPA.
http://g
Page 11 "3. Booster pumps installed on the service line to or within any premises, must be approved and permitted by the City of Augusta, Georgia Utilities Department. Such permitted pumps shall be equipped with a low pressure cut- off device designed to shut off the booster pump when the pressure in the suction line of the service side of the pump drops to 15 psi or below. It shall be the duty of the water consumer to maintain the low-pressure cut-off device in proper working order at all times and to certify to the City of Augusta, Georgia Utilities Department, at least once per year that the device is operable."
I do know the State Fire Marshal absolutely requires 20 psi with the pump operating at 150% measured at the pump suction downstream any backflow prevention assemblies.
From experience I know Ohio and Kentucky have the 20 psi @ 150% requirements.
I've found minimum suction pressure is nearly always addressed somewhere... it may be the state fire marshal but more likely it could be the state EPA so serious research is indicated.
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
Read the listing for heat tape it's really not the answer. Be careful with this!
Heat tape works for very small runs line passing through an unheated space but not intended to heat entire system.
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
Really? Going through Tyco (Raychem), it seems that it would be ok as long as your circuit breaker and transformer is sized for it.
How do you guys deal with piping (domestic water and fire sprinkler) installed in the attic where insulation is at the ceiling and your design temperature is in the 20's F ... or even in the 30's? Dry-pipe or glycol system?
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
madvb,
I've been reviewing other people's submitted plans for about 1 year, and have yet to see a glycol system. The typical method is a dry riser off the lead-in, or could even be off a wet feed or cross main, even a branch, as allowed by code, but this would put the compressor somewhere else in the building..
I believe I read somewhere that with the cost of dry pipe systems now they are the preferred method, but I don't know much about the cost side of things yet, only engineering/code side.
That is a good question though, I hope you get some good answers.. I'd like to know too.
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
Travis Mack
MFP Design, LLC
www.mfpdesign.com
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
spkreng, CET
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
Thanks, I didn't know that until now.
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
"Fire suppression is a failure in prevention"
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
The proposal is to not permit solutions in excess of 50% [7.6.1] and that factory pre-mix solutions will be permitted [7.6.1.1] based on UL document and FPRF report.
"Fire suppression is a failure in prevention"
RE: Fire Pump selection for a fire hydrant
spkreng, CET