×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

O-ring groove design for non-circular groove
4

O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

(OP)
Hi,

I am designing a static seal with an o-ring.
The particularity is that the groove is non-circular. It has an oval-like shape (see picture in link below).
I am wondering how to calculate groove dimensions.

The medium is compressed air of 10 bar.
Pressure is on the inside, so the o-ring is pressed to the outermost groove wall.

I was thinking to calculate the groove the standard way as if the o-ring was placed in a circular groove, using some online calculator or the Parker Handbook.
Then, I would calculate my oval groove so that the outside wall ('outside circumference') of the oval groove has the same length as the outside wall of the circular groove.
Groove width and depth according to the standard calculations.
Would this be an acceptable calculation method?

Kind regards
Ray

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

Yes.

Ted

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

Sounds good except that I would use the centerline of the oval groove and the centerline of the circular groove instead of the outside wall.

Dan

www.eltronresearch.com
Dan's Blog

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

In the past if I needed a custom made oring, I would allow the manufacture of the oring to design the groove, provide dims and tolerances, etc. Just my 2 cents.

Petrotrim Services

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

Hi just my opinion here, I have made numerious Oring grooves - albeit for ultrahigh vaccum applications.

Its a static application (flanged faced) so simple square / rectangular groove design.

I would design the groove and oring so that it hugs the inside circumfrence of the groove with a small % stretch compression. This is purely paractical for assembly disassemble and retention etc..

Height of the groove approx 2/3rds of the O ring O.D.
Width of the groove will be a function of the area left required to give the appropriate compression percentage  & area for the oring to deform into.

Work in terms of oring compression percentage most manufacturers data can range from 18 - 22 % oring compression (personally i have used 25% for ultrahigh vaccumm systems using viton orings)

Hope this can help

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

c0rd0bes ...

I use very similar for our static HV and UHV Viton/Kalrez O-ring grooves;
1/3 compression.
Cross-sectional area of groove 5%< or = cross-sectional area of O-ring, to ensure the O-ring completely fills the groove.

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

I would urge some caution in approaching 95..100 pct fill of the groove with the o-ring.  

O-ring dimensional tolerances are rather large relative to typical groove tolerances.
Most o-rings arrive toward the low side of the tolerance range, because manufacturers still buy material by weight.
Once in a while, you'll get an o-ring that comes in near the large end of the tolerance range for dimensions, and hence volume.  Put that in a groove designed for nominal size o-rings, and you can't close the joint, or you'll fracture something while trying.

 

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

Mike ... I always check the O-ring diameter before using.

And I forgot to mention that, where possible, the grooves inner perimeter is sized such that the O-ring is slightly stretched when inserted.

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

Alternatively, it works if the outside of the groove is smaller than the OD of the o-ring requiring a squeeze to install the o-ring.  Leave excess gland volume so that the o-ring does not completely fill the gland when the joint is closed.

Ted

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

ISTR there is a slight increase in service life of typical compounds with circumferential compression as hydtools describes.

 

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

(OP)
@cOrdObes,  
"Height of the groove approx 2/3rds of the O ring O.D."
--- I assume you mean 2/3 of the o-ring cross section diameter?

@CorBlimeyLimey (whatever happened to simple usernames like Joe or José ..?  winky smile)
"Cross-sectional area of groove 5%< or = cross-sectional area of O-ring"
--- So you mean a negative groove fill ? (groove section smaller than o-ring section?)

@hydtools,
"it works if the outside of the groove is smaller than the OD of the o-ring requiring a squeeze to install the o-ring.  Leave excess gland volume "
--- I was planning to do just that. What I haven't told you is that this particular application requires that the seal is often 'opened'.
The groove is in the 'ceiling' of the application, so I want that the o-ring is compressed into the groove to prevent it from falling out when the seal is opened.
The inside circumference needs to be sufficiently small to provide space for the o-ring to be squeezed. In other words, the groove needs to be sufficiently wide for the o-ring to expand.

 

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

RayJ2 ... Yes, except the 5% was a typo ... should have been 2%.

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

2
RayJ2

As a developer of high pressure systems for up to 20000 psi (~700 atm), for aerospace systems, for the last 30 years, I can assure you that your logic it correct. Since the pressure comes from the inside it tends to stretch the o-ring until it will touch the outer side of the oval. This  stretch will degrade, crack or tear the o-ring with time. Therefore, Eltron's suggestion to use the center line is wrong and sc0rd0bes's suggestion to hug the inside is even worst (the maximum air pressure difference in vacuum systems is only 14.7 psi (~1 atm) which is quite small compared to your case. However, sc0rd0bes's is right in case of vacuum systems where the outer pressure is larger than the inner pressure. Regarding to assembly, if you make the outer length of the oval a little bit smaller than the outer length of the o-ring it will not fall when you push it into the grove. Regarding fill percentage, it should always be smaller than 100% to allow the o-sing to deflect sideways as a result of the squeeze. O-rings designed to seal only on three surfaces/sides. In your case: the flange, the bottom of the groove and the outer side of the groove. The inner side of the groove should not touch the squeezed o-ring to allow a free passage of the gas to apply pressure on the inner side of the o-ring thereby, to press it simultaneously to the flange, the bottom of the groove and the outer side of the oval.

Regarding the squeeze, for small pressure as in your case, there is no need to go to more than 10-15%. 25% and above are intended for really high pressure systems. However, in such high squeeze rates the o-ring needs to be replaced if it was disassembled, because such high squeeze may create too much permanent set of the o-ring thickness. See o-ring manufacturer data regarding the minimum squeeze, compressions set, etc, with respect to pressure, o-ring type of material and hardness.

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

Sorry, 20000 psi is 1360 atm.

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

for rayj2
  
"Height of the groove approx 2/3rds of the O ring O.D."
--- I assume you mean 2/3 of the o-ring cross section diameter?

yes,  Cross section diameter to use the correct nomenclature in this case.


Israelkk - great points thanks for correcting the obvious difference.  

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

rayj2,

Your working pressure (10 bar) is relatively low so the amount of o-ring compression (ie. groove depth) is not critical.  With low pressures, I prefer to reduce the amount of o-ring compression so that it requires less clamping force and also so that the o-ring elastomer is less likely to take a compression set.

With an oval shaped face seal like yours, I would also size the o-ring so that it fits snugly around the inner wall of the groove.  This makes things easier during assembly because the o-ring won't fall out of the groove when turned upside down.  If the o-ring sags out of the groove during assembly, it is easy to pinch or cut the o-ring when the cover is clamped tight.

Hope that helps.
Terry

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

(OP)
Thanks everyone, for your contributions!
The compression % is definitely something I need to give some attention to. Especially because the seal is often opened and closed. If compression is too high, there might be some compression set which is not good if you need to open and close all the time.

Kind regards
Ray
 

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

Given the duty cycle, you might want to bias the seal toward the outer lip to get some circumferential compression, and give that lip a reverse taper to help retain the seal.

 

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

A little grease will also help retain the o-ring.

Ted

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

(OP)
@Mike,
I milled a groove in a little test part where the o-ring was compressed against the outer circumference. It seemed to stay fairly well in place. Tapering the groove wall will ofcourse help a lot. But it will also increase production cost. The actual setup will have 80 of these o-ring seals.

@hydtools,
Yes, adding some grease will help. But in this particular application, the seals will undergo temperature cycles from -50°C to +150°C (-58°F to +302°F). So probably the grease will quickly dry out. Perhaps a few drops of cyanoacrylate glue ('superglue') might also help.


 

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

Do not use cyanoacrylate glue!! If the o-ring is not a silicone rubber you can use a silicon grease (-70C to 400C if I remember correctly). But to my opinion grease is not necessary. A grease is mostly used when the o-ring is installed in pistons and cylinder and rubs against the cylinder wall during installation to lower installation friction forces but is not needed is a face seal.

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

I do nothave any question on the o-ring and its compression in the groove.
However there are certain surface quality is required for the o-ring grooves. In your case, I guess, there are some machining problems for the oval shape to meet the surface quality required. Are you sure that you can obtain the required surface quality with the oval shape? What kind of tool do you consider to manufacture this shape? Discuss it with your manufacturer to make sure you are on the right way.

Ibrahim Demir

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

(OP)
@Ibrahim,
That is a good remark.
According to o-ring suppliers specifications, surface roughness for grooves should range from 0.8 to 1.6 um Ra (micrometer Ra).
That can be achieved with milling.

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

Timely post.  Good information above.  Thank you.

---...---...

Related problem, different job.  

I've got a oil-to-water heat exchanger here in Spain ( no 1/4 inch O-rings available) on a crit path job with no assembly drawings for the heat exchanger or maintenance spec's.  Low pressure (40 - 60 psi) on both sides.

Only available O-ring kit has 6.0 mm tubing.   (We believe the grove is designed for 6.5 mm (1/4 inch nominal) O-ring (3/16 deep x 9/32 wide).  

O-ring groove measures at 4.5 mm deep by 7.5 mm wide.  


Compression of a 6 mm O-ring = 6/4.5 = 33%  (Good, based on comments above)

Area of 6 ring   = 28.26 mm2
Area of 6.5 ring = 33.16 mm2
Area of 7 ring   = 38.46 mm2
Area of groove   = 33.75
It appears a 7 mm o-ring is too large.  

Do I approve the 6 mm O-ring?   

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

racookpe1978,

As long as your o-ring elastomer compound is of average hardness (60 or 70 durometer) then 1.5mm compression of a 6.0mm nominal section o-ring cord is more than adequate for sealing a deltaP of 60 psi.  Most manufacturers recommend a maximum compression value of 35% for most situations.  A static face seal type o-ring seals against the groove at the top and bottom points of contact.  If you calculate the amount of friction force holding the o-ring in place, created by compressing the o-ring over its linear length, you'll be surprised at how much pressure differential it would actually take to push the o-ring out against one side of the groove.

Also, you mention that your o-ring is sealing an interface between oil and water.  Take care to ensure that the elastomer you use is compatible with both fluids.

Good luck.
Terry

The 6.0mm o-ring x-section area is about 84% of your groove x-section area.  This is a little bit more than optimum for a low pressure seal, but still should be OK.

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

Understand, thank you very much.   Will write it up that way for dayshift lead engineer to approve.  

About 45 minutes from now.   8<)

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

For info:  Air tests on both the oil coolers passed sat.

Thank you.

RE: O-ring groove design for non-circular groove

Thanks for the feedback.

Ted

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources