×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

R.C Base & column with low unacceptable concrete strength

R.C Base & column with low unacceptable concrete strength

R.C Base & column with low unacceptable concrete strength

(OP)
Being design engineer for a 3 storey R.C building, I requested concrete cores to be tested for base and column upon suspecting column quality from ground to first floor level. Results were surprising, getting only 50% of specified strength. 2 floors have been built supported by this colum & base.

What procedure can I use for remedial work?

RE: R.C Base & column with low unacceptable concrete strength

First of - can you please give us details such as what the specified strength was to be?  Also, were your cores tested as per ASTM test methods - i.e., core preparation before testing?  What was the cylinder strength of the concrete - from normal QC testing - and strengths at various dates after casting?  Were there any voids in the QC cylinders (or cubes?) - or the cores??  How many cores did you take; should take three for one set.  To be acceptable average of the three are to be 85% of the specified strength and no single core less than 75%; how many days after concrete placement were they tested. Did the cores cut into or across any deformed rebar? Why did you ask that cores be taken anyway . . . were the QC tests low?  Did you use fly ash?  Sorry for all the questions - and somewhat disjointed - but the more data you can give, the better replies you can expect. cheers

RE: R.C Base & column with low unacceptable concrete strength

(OP)
Specified strength 25MPa. Cores were tested as per SABS Codes(Similar to british standard) No fly ash used.

28 day strenth for the project are fine but concrete for structural elements in question might not have been sampled. I suspect concrete not ment for structural elements was just used by General construction staff without consulting their supervisors.

Horizontal cracks developed on the column, concrete is weak, you can cheap it easily using 20mm reinforcement bar. Contractor's staff are not well skilled in building works.

Requesting cores to be tested was just a formality to to justify need for remedial work.        

RE: R.C Base & column with low unacceptable concrete strength

Why was such low strength concrete on the job?  Intended for blinding layer under footings?  If so, I think this concrete has to be removed and replaced.  Big job.

RE: R.C Base & column with low unacceptable concrete strength

(OP)
The issue to be addressed is construction sequence/procedure to be adopted for removal of affected column.
Should we remove column first lift only (affected part) or remove column full lenth casted ( up to second floor level.
 

RE: R.C Base & column with low unacceptable concrete strength

How where the columns formed. I had a contractor put polystyrene inside a circular column form with the intent of creating a square column. They removed the forms to find that the polystyrene had moved inside the form and boney concrete resulted towards the base.

If possible, can you post a photo.

hokie

I have been using 25MPa concrete for footing beams and 10MPa concrete for blinding layers.

RE: R.C Base & column with low unacceptable concrete strength

prostruct,
I see no reason to remove concrete other than the low strength portion.

As to the procedure, the hard part is supporting the structure above without overstressing it.  In order to remove the footing and column, your ground supports and props will need to be a substantial distance away from the column, yet the beams supporting the structure will need to be close to the column to avoid loading it in an unintended manner.  I would preload the supporting beams with jacks to take the full dead load before chipping away the defective concrete.

asixth,
Yes, that is common practice, and I was suggesting the 10 MPa found its way into the footing and column in question.

RE: R.C Base & column with low unacceptable concrete strength

Have you run an analysis with the "low" values to see if the design is still safe?? Might be an idea before you go out and start playing wrecking ball.  What will the strength of the concrete be, in say another couple of months; does this improve your safety factor?  Have you tried to take more cores?  Was the steel installed correctly and all you have to worry about is the concrete?  Have you taken into account the confinement on the strength of the concrete.

RE: R.C Base & column with low unacceptable concrete strength

For existing old buildings, BigH's approach is often used if structural elements are judged to have sufficient durability as well as strength for another design life period.  But for a building under construction, the building should comply with current practice.  The codes I am aware of have a lower limit on concrete strength in order for the code provisions to even be applicable.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources