×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

High stiffness plastic or composite for glass replacement
2

High stiffness plastic or composite for glass replacement

High stiffness plastic or composite for glass replacement

(OP)
Hi,

I'm looking for a suitable material, composite or layered sheet for replacing an LCD overlay, currently made of glass, with the ultimate goal of significant weight reduction.

Normally, a hard coated PMMA sheet would do the job in most applications and the weight would be cut in half. However, in this particular product, I need extra stiffness to prevent (or minimize) external factors bending the sheet and reaching the LCD, possibly damaging it.

Glass is about 10-20 times stiffer than any plastic I know of and I'm not expecting to even come close to that. Worst scenario is ending up with the aforementioned PMMA; however, I'd like to know that at least I'm using "the best" there is. Cost is not an issue.

Any suggestions? Thank you!

RE: High stiffness plastic or composite for glass replacement

So you need the stiffest possible, optically clear plastic?

The optical clarity part will preclude fillers.

SAN, Acrylic, and styrene have the highest modulus of optically clear plastics, though there is a castable polyester listed with higher modulus in one of my references (dunno how clear this will be though).  Clear nylon and polycarbonate are tougher than any of these, at slightly lower stiffness.

 

RE: High stiffness plastic or composite for glass replacement

(OP)
A tiny bit of tint (not cloudy) shouldn't be a problem; after all, we're looking at a sheet just over 1 mm (3/64") thick.

As for toughness, put it like this: the LCD and probably the entire device would be destroyed beyond recognition before any plastic would even think about breaking. So really, stiffness is the #1 characteristic I'm looking for.

RE: High stiffness plastic or composite for glass replacement

SAN (3.7 GPa) has the highest followed by polystyrene (3.3 GPa) They are both really cheap. Pick SAN if you need chemical resistance, it's  better than PS for that.

You can search polymers by modulus at www.matweb.com (free)

Chris DeArmitt PhD FRSC CChem

www.phantomplastics.com
Consultant to the plastics industry

RE: High stiffness plastic or composite for glass replacement

(OP)
I did a quick search on matweb and it looks like 3-4 GPa is pretty much the most to expect.

I was thinking however that maybe I could find some kind of sheets reinforced with fibers of a matching refractive index, with minor effect on clarity. Am I out of luck?

RE: High stiffness plastic or composite for glass replacement

Refractive index matching does work, in fact I developed a new type of thermoplastic that has switchable transparency based on matching.

However, it's not so easy, you need to match the refractive index of the filler and polymer to within 0.003

Chris DeArmitt PhD FRSC CChem

www.phantomplastics.com
Consultant to the plastics industry

RE: High stiffness plastic or composite for glass replacement

(OP)
That composite of yours is obviously not what I need here but it's very interesting, nevertheless! Is anybody making it yet?

On the other hand, are you saying that what I'm looking for is not realistic, as it would definitely need to stay transparent over a relatively wide range of temperatures?

RE: High stiffness plastic or composite for glass replacement

Hello,

Thanks for the interest! I get calls all the time about it and I'm in the process of commercialising it. You can read all about ThermoShift here:

http://www.phantomplastics.com/ThermoShift_Smart_Plastic.php

That includes info on mechanical properties and so on.

Chris DeArmitt PhD FRSC CChem

www.phantomplastics.com
Consultant to the plastics industry

RE: High stiffness plastic or composite for glass replacement

I have an idea how to make you a super high modulus transparent plastic. I'll do some checking to see whether the numbers pan out.

Chris DeArmitt PhD FRSC CChem

www.phantomplastics.com
Consultant to the plastics industry

RE: High stiffness plastic or composite for glass replacement

I checked and it should work. Modulus of 6-9GPa should be possible.

All the best,

Chris

Chris DeArmitt PhD FRSC CChem

www.phantomplastics.com
Consultant to the plastics industry

RE: High stiffness plastic or composite for glass replacement

Have you investigated Gorilla Glass? I know you said you want plastic, but if you haven't researched all available options in glass, you may be shortchanging yourself.  That stuff is tough, and quite a few PDA and smart phone manufacturers are using it (Motorola being one off the top of my head).

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: High stiffness plastic or composite for glass replacement

Chris,

After you get it patented and start making your second billion, please do spill the beans here - making a high modulus transparent plastic doesn't sound easy!

RE: High stiffness plastic or composite for glass replacement

Hi btrueblood!

Still hunting for the first million although I do have some prospects. I am almost positive that I can make that plastic with very high modulus and transparent. You're right, it's not that easy unless you know a trick or two. Who wants it? What do you see as applications? Who will develop it with me? I'm a one man show.

Chris

Chris DeArmitt PhD FRSC CChem

www.phantomplastics.com
Consultant to the plastics industry

RE: High stiffness plastic or composite for glass replacement

Hmmm.  "Who wants it" is the big one, and I dunno.

What would the cost of the new plastic be (about equal to PC?), and do you expect you could make the material as tough as polycarbonate?  It might make good eyewear lens material.

RE: High stiffness plastic or composite for glass replacement

Cost would be close to PC. However, impact would be poor in the base form although it is possible to improve that and retain transparency. Modulus and strength would be very good though. Chemical resistance would be good.

Chris DeArmitt PhD FRSC CChem

www.phantomplastics.com
Consultant to the plastics industry

RE: High stiffness plastic or composite for glass replacement

Chris,

Some niche ideas, maybe they'll spark some thoughts for you.

Chemical and process flow meters - the rotameter type - many for higher pressures currently use glass.  A plastic window, with some reduction in fragility would be helpful.

Dive cases and/or lenses for underwater photography.



 

RE: High stiffness plastic or composite for glass replacement

(OP)
@btrueblood: I think you are referring mostly to "strength" throughout your posts; at least that's how it appears to me. In that case, plain PC is the material of choice and you can't go wrong with it. If I'd lock you in a polycarbonate cage and give you a sledgehammer, you'll still be there a couple of days later. Exhausted and frustrated.
A higher modulus doesn't necessarily mean a tougher material, in fact, the opposite is true in most cases. Take glass, for example: its modulus is much higher than, say, acrylic (60-90 GPa vs 3-4 GPa) yet it can't bear a load nearly as high as the acrylic would.

@MacGyverS2000: I looked up the Gorilla Glass brand and it seems to be a good material. The "only" bad thing about it is that it's... glass. They list its density at 2.44 grams (typical for glass), whereas PMMA weighs in at roughly 1.2 - less than half. Here's how that translates into my application: with glass, a 23cm x 18cm x 1.2mm slab adds up to about 125g, whereas the same slab in acrylic would be just 60g. Considering that the whole device is 450g, those 60 grams mean quite a difference.

@Chris: When I posted on the board, I was hoping to find some references to an existing products that others might know about. However, if nothing is currently produced, I'll go with PMMA, at least for the time being.
If you're actually wondering what the potential market is for a clear, rigid composite and who would ever need it... then I guess you spend too much time in the lab, LOL smile
As for who will develop it with you - I really don't have a clue since I'm not connected to the "world of plastics". Would you be able to have at least some sample quantities made?

RE: High stiffness plastic or composite for glass replacement

If you go here and click the file thermoplastics performance versus cost you will see a plot of modulus and cost for all common thermoplastics. You will find SAN is stiffer and cheaper than PMMA. The prices there are from 2003. I am just finished a new version with the latest pricing.

http://www.phantomplastics.com/Downloads.php

Chris DeArmitt PhD FRSC CChem

www.phantomplastics.com
Consultant to the plastics industry

RE: High stiffness plastic or composite for glass replacement

Flix,

No, I am talking modulus as in "E" or Young's modulus.  Having a "lens" (or even an optical flat) with high stiffness is only important (that I can see)(pun hugely intended) where you must have a clear view of what's on the other side with no distortion.  Or, as in your case, where what must be visible is susceptible to contact stresses.  But, no matter, Chris will never point you wrong.

RE: High stiffness plastic or composite for glass replacement

I have one more idea. What happens if you apply the glass layer to both sides of your PMMA sheet instead of just one as you would normally do?

The reason I ask is that adding thin stiff layers in a sandwich structure like that can give a very high flexural modulus because flex modulus depends a lot on the stiffness of the surface material, in this case glass.

So, my adapting your existing process, PMMA with glass on one side only, you may have a solution that's easy to implement using existing equipment.

Chris DeArmitt PhD FRSC CChem

www.phantomplastics.com
Consultant to the plastics industry

RE: High stiffness plastic or composite for glass replacement

Sure... assuming the LCD puts out far-UV light, and the user can read the info in 40 femtosecond windows of opportunity winky smile

But who can't?

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources