×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?
12

taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

(OP)
Pals

Will a set of cables, parallel to a simple roof, work just like purlins to support a flexible roof material?

For a cable to work I think I need a profile with a sag, so that no further sag can occur under load

But the architect says no sag.

Anyway around this. Seems impossible to me.

respects
ijr

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

You can pretension the cables to not have any sag.

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

Yes - But once loaded up - the cable tension force will skyrocket

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

the architect is being an architect ... of course there'll be some sag in any real cable in the real world.

but you say "flexible roof" ... like a tent ?

 

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

as Mikey aludes to... the tension forces can be very high... and shouldn't be taken lightly.  If you have an end slope of 1:100, a 100 lb vertical force is transferred as a 10000 lb tension...

Dik

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

If you take a cable that is theoretically straight across and apply a load to it, you will get some sag, even if that load is only the self-weight of the cable.  Adding another load just increases the amount of sag.  You can build things like that, whether it's economical is a different issue.

You might also consider how you know what that initial tension is.  Telling a construction worker to "tighten that nut until that cable is straight" could lead to highly variable results.

Temperature effects would also affect cable tension.

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

And I suppose this guy thinks that there is no "sag" with wood or steel purlins under load too?  He is being totally unrealistic.  

If he wants no sag, tell him to outlaw gravity.  (Obvious God complex, so let him do it).  You can't do that.

Structural Engineers are from Reality, Architects from Fantasia.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
Motto:  KISS
Motivation:  Don't ask

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

See the attachment.  This is the La Villita Assembly Hall in San Antonio, designed by W. E. Simpson Co. it is a "flat" cable roof structure of sorts.  The center tension ring was pulled down, concrete planks placed on the cables, and then when the ring was released the roof sprung upward, putting the planks into compression.

 

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

(OP)
rb1957 and paddington

yes, a tensile fabric will be hung on cables that act as simple purlins(same way you put purlins on an industrial one story building frame)

paddington, I am not after the equations really, I am after some experience on these issues. I appreciate your immediate response howeve and will appreciate more.


 

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

(OP)
JAE

I found that article is inspiring. As usual JAE, you inspire. Can't thank enough

My application involves a cable flat in the sense that it is parallel to the ground with loads suspended on it, and even a small load brings about 10kips(5metric tons) tension and a huge sag.

It hints sensitivity to loading. No temperature analysis yet.

respects  

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

just reading that post, not seeing any calcs, it doesn't sound quite right to me ... a huge tension would indicate (typically) a small deflection.  if you've got a huge area loading the cable, maybe the flexible roofing will tear away before the cable breaks ?

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

IJR, your OP asked if you could use a cable system with no sag, I posted the link as a quick , "No" that included the reason.

The only possibility I can think of is somewhat awkward, it is to used a sagging cable, supporting at intervals, another almost straight cable or pipe, much like a suspension bridge. It is awkward because of the number of penetrations for the supports.

Other than that, I think the architect needs to ask the Great Architect of the Universe to change the laws of physics.

Michael.
Timing has a lot to do with the outcome of a rain dance.

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

A cable with low sag forms a catenary which may be approximated by a parabola.  If it has load per unit length w, span L and height h, the tension in the cable is wL2/8h.  If h = 0, the cable is straight and the tension is infinite.

BA

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

2
IJR:

Paddington and BA are just being killjoys, they always want to bring equations and the laws of physics into the discussion.  They don't know that your arch. is on a first name basis with the Great Architect of the Universe.  I can just hear him/her saying "and there shalt be no G.. Damn sag in the cable."   JAE's picture is a special case, quite clever, but I didn't see much article.  They initially stretched the radial cables btwn. an exterior compression ring and the center tension ring structure and then tensioned them to some predetermined level.  They pulled the tension ring down, thus prestressing and stretching the cables further, and installed the conc. planks which work in compression when the tension ring is released.  Their trick is to calc. the prestress so that any anticipated live loads cause the tension ring to move, up and down, vertically within an acceptable range.  This is not 'no deflection' due to added load, but you don't see the deflection in terms of significant added cable sag.  This is easier to do in a circular form (tension and compression rings) than in a rectangular building form.  Their system is attractive because the reacting force systems make up the roof, are shaped well to do this, and are internal to the roof system, and not an external tie off.

Let's see if I have the right picture: flat roof structure; beams spaced at X; cables (like purlins) spaced at Y, on top of the beams; flexible fabric stretched over the cables; none of these have any deflection or is it just sag in the cables which must be zero.  You'll want to patent this because it will be a first.  Your first gut feeling about cable sag was right on the money, except more vert. load will produce more sag and higher cable stresses; later you say the cables seem sensitive to loading, right again; and you say you haven't considered temperature effects yet.  Don't forget to consider the rain filled swimming pools, each X long and Y wide, which will form on this roof system.

The arch. seems to have missed the 'gravity and loads thing' in school.  You must explain this to him/her because you can't overcome it.  Part of the architectural sex appeal of these tension structures is their deflected shape, and you can't ignore it.  You must consider cable and fabric stretch, ponding, load accumulation, drainage of any low spots, etc.

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

(OP)
dhengr and fellows

Thanks for the detailed posts. I dont want to extend this more than worth your time.

But isnt it true that no amount of prestressing can make a cable flat. Since h=0 means infinite horizontal force, doesnt the contrary mean no sag-free cable is possible? A sag of a half inch(roughly 12mm) would reduce the force significantly

So here is what I am goint to do. I am goint to provide my X cables(X is parallel to roof slope) and then provide stiff Y purlins. This way the two will interact and I will have a safety margin, while pleasing the architect(Sorry I seem to have no real alternative).

respects
ijr

 

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

IJR,
You may indeed be sorry if you take that option.  Why is pleasing the architect your prime concern?

BA

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

(OP)
BAretired

You are right I will be sorry. But I have to ensure safety to the level of my knowledge, which simply says cable takes transverse load only if it can take a shape different from a straight line between the ends.

However this architect, a nice man too, insists and he is the one who calls all the shots.

think of calling the shots BA

respects
ijr

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

I would suggest that the person who "calls the shots" should be the one accepting responsibility for those shots.

BA

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

Maybe you can talk him into something that _appears_ to be what he wants, but isn't.

E.g. a tubular truss, finished in flat black, with one chord finished bright.

E.g. a cable strung as a catenary, with queenposts holding up the structure, all finished in a way that hides them, and a highly visible, straight, decorative cable, strung where the architect, and the great unwashed, can see it.

 

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

Another alternative is to take a field trip with the architect, get the car stuck in a ditch, and pull it out with a rope stretched across the road to a tree that just happens to be there.  Demonstrate how easy it is to move the car just a little by pushing laterally on a straight rope, and how quickly the lateral force has to go up to keep the car moving.

You can explain the principles once again while you wait for the tow truck.

 

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

IJR:
It's not a matter of your (or our) respecting or disrespecting the arch. or of knowing he calls the shots.  If he has enough money to throw at this roof, you can do almost anything.  You can make it carry the roof load and make it safe, you must.  But you are his consulting engineer, not just his calculating machine.  And,  given the fact that the arch. doesn't seem to understand the physical laws by which we must design and live, you must go on record with him about what he is asking for, and what you are doing to try to accommodate his wishes, and what the results will be in the way of forces, deflections, cable and fabric sag, etc.  Since there is no such thing as laterally loaded cables and fabrics which do not have any sag or deflection.  This should be in the form of a letter and report and calcs. which explains what the final results will be, with proof that he received the letter and understands the report.  Then you may still be sorry because the argument with him continues; but at least you won't be sorry because you ended up in court facing him, because he doesn't understand you (and he by playing arch. and wishing hard enough) can't defy gravity and you can't do the impossible, just because HE says so.  The whole thing may be just a matter of degree.  Does he mean you can't have a cable sag equal to 1/3 of the cable length; and do you think he means you can't have a cable sag of 6" in 30'?

One of your biggest problems may be designing the cable restraint structural system in this rectilineal structure.  My second paragraph, above, still stands, you have just rotated my system by 90° and now claim a sloped flat roof.  You still have the potential of ponding (growing rain filled swimming pools) on the tension fabric skin.
 

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

If you don't get the frequency of this roof in the right range, the roof could experience wind induced vibrations.

And what about deflections of the cable supports?

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

(OP)
Pals

From the posts here I have fully understood that all friends here agree that taut horizontal cables can in no way support gravity loads.

I am going to use good purlins and let cables stand there basically idle. so I wont have a load carrying or a frequency problem

respects
ijr  

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

IMHO that's not what we're saying ... we're saying that  cables will deflect under transverse load ... we're objecting to the architect saying the cables can carry the load without deflection; i suspect he means "without significant deflection" which is of course a whole different thing.

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

Bobber1... if the cable is stretched tight enough... only the dogs will complain! <G>

Dik

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

@Dik (23 Apr 10 12:08)
Just wanted to clarify that for a 100 lb on 1 in 100 slope the tension would be 5000 lb and not 10000 lb?
T = PL/4D or P = W/2 tan θ

We are Virginia Tech
Go HOKIES

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

@slickdeals, I'm not sure I agree, I could be mixing up the symbols though and there is not enough info to be sure.

Let the horizontal component be H. If the total load is W, the span is L, and the sag is D, then:

H=(W/2)(L/2)/D, and the Tension = the square root of the sum of the squares of H and (W/2). The tangent of the instantaneous slope at the support is (W/2)/H.

Once the tension is determined, the intermediate sags can be calculated.

As a check on a program result, I would put that on a spreadsheet to check tensions for various sags.

Michael.
Timing has a lot to do with the outcome of a rain dance.

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

I did not clarify my symbols. My mistake.
P = W/2 tan θ
P = Tension in Cable
W = Point load in the middle
θ = slope

T = PL/4D
T = Tension in the cable
P = Point load in the middle
L = Total length of cable
D = Sag at location of point load

We are Virginia Tech
Go HOKIES

RE: taut flat cable parallel to roof to support a roof?

@slickdeals, gotcha. I was thinking uniform load, that's why I said "instantaneous slope".

Michael.
Timing has a lot to do with the outcome of a rain dance.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources