×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Multiple Motors From Same VFD

Multiple Motors From Same VFD

Multiple Motors From Same VFD

(OP)
I hava an application where I have 6 motors that will never be required to run at the same time.  I would like to use just 1 VFD to save $$$.  Can I use one motor starter and some downstream contactors to pull this off, and is there any code issues I should worry about.  I am a ChE and have some knowledge of industrial control, but I am not an EE or electrician.

RE: Multiple Motors From Same VFD

You can do this as long as two motors are not going to run at the same time and the drive will be ramped down when switching motors. This can be accomplished as you suggested. Are they all the same motor? If not, the drive may have to be set-up different for the different motors. I know of no unusual code issues to worry about, just the basic stuff. I would incorporate some interlocks (electrically or mechanically) to prevent more than one motor running at the same time or starting another motor while one is online. This may or may not be a code requirement but would be a good idea to prevent accidental starting. Good luck.

RE: Multiple Motors From Same VFD

You might want to search this forum - this has been discussed before.  As buzzp says, you can do this provide you have adequate number of isolation contactors and the proper interlocking.

However, unless you are talking about large motors, you may find that it would have been cheaper to buy individual drives.  Operations and maintenance is much simpler with individual drives as well.  

RE: Multiple Motors From Same VFD

hi...
how about the issue of all 6 motors cannot run because of the lone VFD failure?..unless of course you have a spare you can pull out quickly..

dydt

RE: Multiple Motors From Same VFD

(OP)
Thanks everyone for you help.  The issue is I have 19 idenitcal motors.  Only 4 ever need to run at one time.  I will build system with 5 so I have a spare, but 4 vs. 19 is a big cost savings.

RE: Multiple Motors From Same VFD

Older VFD's were typically configured as current sources, which meant that running them without a connected load could possibly damage the VFD.  I'm not sure about the newer models, but you might want to look into that and provide an interlock to prevent running the VFD with no load.

RE: Multiple Motors From Same VFD

All VFDs have watts and ampere ratings, specified by the manufacturer.
Damage can occur to the motor if the running watts exceed the name plate rating of the drive.
Similarly each drive has built in thermal protection. You must check the current you draw from the drive against its name plate rating.
As long as you remain in the limits, thru an electrical interlock, every thing will be OK.

RE: Multiple Motors From Same VFD

Suggestion: If the motors are small, selector switches downstream from VFD can complete the branch circuits. If the motors are larger, e.g. 5A or so, the contactors replacing the selector switches could be used.

RE: Multiple Motors From Same VFD

dpc is right. NEC requirements for short circuit and overload protection of each individual motor may push the cost effectiveness out the window on small HP motors. Keep in mind that not only do you need separate circuits for each motor, the output terminals of the VFD must be isolated at all times from line power feeding back from another of the circuits (you will blow the transistors if not), so the cost of all of the necessary interlocking contactors becomes prohibitive unless the VFD is very expensive. Small (under 10HP) VFDs are now so cheap that it may make sense to use separate units.

That which does not kill me, makes me stronger... and pissed off!

RE: Multiple Motors From Same VFD


Additionally, it seems like horsepower-rated contactor switching may be equally or more expensive compared to dedicated VF controllers.  Typically each motor would use two 3-pole, electrically and mechanically interlocked contactors.  It is possible unit pricing on a quantity of VFDs may be significantly less than the single-lot price.
  

RE: Multiple Motors From Same VFD

Suggestion: By responsible controls, a number of contactors can be reduced down to one per motor branch circuit. A selector switch turning on one contactor and off others appears to be a solution. However, the mechanical interlocks are important in case that any contactor becomes stuck in the close position.

RE: Multiple Motors From Same VFD

You could use electrical type interlocks by monitoring the current in each motor (about $60 US a piece for accurate drive current measurement or buy standard monitor and compensate for the error in the reading). This will verify the motor is indeed off before starting another motor. I am not that familiar with interlock issues with standards and such but I would do it electrically if at all possible, keeping in mind the fail safe strategy with relay contacts.

RE: Multiple Motors From Same VFD

We have been doing this since the '60's on spinning machines where we have up to 32 motors per inverter.  These are synduction or perm magnet motors.  Each motor has a manual starter and fused protection.  1-16 motors can be run at a time.  As expected when we went to IGBT drives we started having problems that were eventually solved by a special filters.  We have hundreds of ~ 1hp motors running this way.  You just have to understand that if you have an inverter problem - they all go down.  Of course they all run at the same speed - but that is what we want.

RE: Multiple Motors From Same VFD

Suggestion: If there is an inverter problem, there has to be another one to provide the inverter redundancy. In case of hundreds of motors, an extra inverter or two is the reasonable redundancy to have.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources