×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Better Solutions than PDM Works?

Better Solutions than PDM Works?

Better Solutions than PDM Works?

(OP)
I was wondering if anyone has found or heard of a better solution than PDM Works?  We have the Enterprise version and it is overall a waste of time with all the issues and bugs.  I have tried DBWorks in the past and it was just as bad with its own set of issues.  There must be a better alternative out there.

Thanks,
BB

RE: Better Solutions than PDM Works?

BB,
You're the first one I heard of commented that Enterprise PDM is a waste. We're on Workgroup PDM and would love to jump to Enterprise. What is your main complaint sir?

Colin Fitzpatrick (aka Macduff)
Mechanical Designer
Solidworks 2009 SP 4.1
Dell 490 XP Pro SP 2
Xeon CPU 3.00 GHz 3.00 GB of RAM
nVida Quadro FX 3450 512 MB
3D Connexion-SpaceExplorer

RE: Better Solutions than PDM Works?

I'm okay with SolidWorks Workgroup PDM.  As far as I'm concerned, the alternative is nothing - which is not satisfactory at all.  But you said DBWorks is comparable, so maybe I don't understand your question.

RE: Better Solutions than PDM Works?

I too am curious to know your issues with Enterprise.

Several years ago my company decided to utilize PTC Windchill as their Enterprise pdm.  They were told it worked with SolidWorks.  Flashforward... I am still cursing that decision.  Though we are in the process of upgrading to the latest version (2 versions newer than our current) of Windchill and the testing I have done is very promising.

So for what its worth... yes, PTC Windchill works.  Is it better, I assumed not.  Though your post makes me question that assertion.

As far as Windchill as a whole.  It has its quirks, but is pretty powerful for rev control, configuration control, change notices, workflows, and general data managing needs.

-Dustin
Professional Engineer
Certified SolidWorks Professional
Certified COSMOSWorks Designer Specialist
Certified SolidWorks Advanced Sheet Metal Specialist
 

RE: Better Solutions than PDM Works?

(OP)
We have many issues with different people in the department that have the "latest version" of a drawing/part but the part is different from one desk to another.  The data cards are a mess and we have had an "expert" here from our VAR and still can not seem to get them to work properly.  Also the PDM search function will say you have part/assy/dwg checked out in your name when you have nothing checked out at all.  PDM crashes for everyone here at least a few times a day.  Revision control is not controled, bugs regarding quantities on drawings, etc.....It would be easier to mention what does work that what does not.  In fact, even our VAR feels that PDMWorks is not worth the effort for all of the outstanding issues but they continue to sell it regardless.

RE: Better Solutions than PDM Works?

Wow, you're VAR said that? Please do not disclose the VAR you have, he'll probably get fired. BB, you keep on saying PDMWorks. When you say that, I thinking you have Workgroup, but you said Enterprise, correct? I'm sorry you're having problems, but did you have an implementation plan before installing it? Was everyone trained properly?

Colin Fitzpatrick (aka Macduff)
Mechanical Designer
Solidworks 2009 SP 4.1
Dell 490 XP Pro SP 2
Xeon CPU 3.00 GHz 3.00 GB of RAM
nVida Quadro FX 3450 512 MB
3D Connexion-SpaceExplorer

RE: Better Solutions than PDM Works?

There's a lot of options, but all are more costly than E!PDM and certainly more costly than Workgroup.

SmarTeam (possibly dying now)
Keytech (independent)
Enovia (V6 is new path for DS and SolidWorks, but costs are issue)

Also, look up gold partners in the PDM section.  There's actually quite a few choices.

Matt Lorono
Lorono's SolidWorks Resources & SolidWorks Legion

&

RE: Better Solutions than PDM Works?

fcsuper,

What makes you say that SmarTeam is possibly dying?  We're in the midst of evaluating EPDM / PLM solutions and SmarTeam is one of the options.  I'd obviously rather not select a package that's on its last legs.

RE: Better Solutions than PDM Works?

Ok, it looks like we're all comparing apples to oranges. It sounds like BB is looking for a comparable PDM system to Enterprise. Now we're starting to thrown in PLM a systems, which is a huge cost difference as well as operating capability.

One thing to keep in mind is software versions. SW releases both CAD software and PDM software at the same time which is really nice. Smarteam for example........If you're on SW 2009 and want to upgrade to 2010....you might have to wait because Smarteam might not be compatible with the new SW version. Smarteam will need to upgrade there software first before you can upgrade SW software. PITA from what I heard.........
 

Colin Fitzpatrick (aka Macduff)
Mechanical Designer
Solidworks 2009 SP 4.1
Dell 490 XP Pro SP 2
Xeon CPU 3.00 GHz 3.00 GB of RAM
nVida Quadro FX 3450 512 MB
3D Connexion-SpaceExplorer

RE: Better Solutions than PDM Works?

We are about to implement a program called "Adept". Anyone here with any experiemce with this program?

RE: Better Solutions than PDM Works?

I haven't actually used PDMWorks (workgroup or enterprise), but my company is running DBWorks at the moment.  It's quirky, and there are definitely some things I wish it did better - mostly tied to multi-site database replication, but it's much better than what we had before (nothing).

Most of the problems I see are caused by users (and admins) not knowing how to use the software properly.  Or worse yet, knowingly working around the system.  We would have greatly benefited from a better implementation plan, too.  "Learn as you go" does not work well with these systems.
 

RE: Better Solutions than PDM Works?

"Learn as you go does not work well with these systems"
Agreed.

We generated and followed an extensive implementation plan.  The one general statement that I believe is an issue with our situation is that we seem to be frequently fighting the software.

Not that the software is correct, but the company should have a willingness to be flexible to make best use of the pdm system.  Typically the software is somewhat flexible to facilitate the use by multiple organizations, but we often find that we are doing a lot of extra work that the system doesn't want to do easily... simply to conform to our possibly outdated processes.

-Dustin
Professional Engineer
Certified SolidWorks Professional
Certified COSMOSWorks Designer Specialist
Certified SolidWorks Advanced Sheet Metal Specialist
 

RE: Better Solutions than PDM Works?

There are so many factors involved in setting up a PDM system.
But if I were to pick one I would go with Aras http://www.aras.com/
It's free except for training and support in implimentation.
easy to get to work with other systems and customize to your needs.

-Joe
SolidWorks 2009 x64 SP 5.1 on Windows XP x64
8 GB RAM  -  Nvidia Quadro FX1700

RE: Better Solutions than PDM Works?

BB,

Have any of your issues been submitted to SolidWorks and if so do you have a Service Request number that you can post?  I will then look into this for you.

 

RE: Better Solutions than PDM Works?

About SmarTeam:

Paraphrase from CEO of DS: we are not V5 and SolidWorks, we are V6.

SmarTeam is V5 (and will never be V6).  It's already been handed off to a spin off company.  The supply chain now being formed at DS is for Enovia V6.

Matt Lorono
Lorono's SolidWorks Resources & SolidWorks Legion

&

RE: Better Solutions than PDM Works?

BodyBagger,

Have you received a SolidWorks Service Request number for any of your issues from your VAR?  If so please reply with the number and I will look into it for you.

RE: Better Solutions than PDM Works?

fcsuper,

Thanks for the follow-up.  I'd heard the bit about the spinoff in the time between your posts.  Where can I learn more about this?  Not doubting you, just performing due diligence in my evaluation process...

RE: Better Solutions than PDM Works?

fcsuper,

Never mind.  I'd searched for information on what was transpiring with SmarTeam but never had any luck.  Tried again today (different search terms) and somehow ended up at www.fcsuper.com reading an article about the artizone spinoff.  Many more links to follow, but I'm good for now.

Thanks again for the information.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources