×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Moment Connection to Concrete Wall???

Moment Connection to Concrete Wall???

Moment Connection to Concrete Wall???

(OP)
Working on a project using Insulated Concrete Forms for the exterior wall system. Steel framing will be used at the building interior.

We have conditions where horizontal beams are framed to (as well as bearing) the ICF walls and are considered moment frames.

I'm thinking a moment connection could work where an embedded, vertical plate with headed studs is cast into the concrete wall, and then top and bottom plates are bolted to the wide flange beam. These top and bottom plates can then be welded to the embedded plate, similar to a typical moment connection.

Any thoughts on a moment connection where the beam bears on the concrete wall (bearing required due to the magnitude of the gravity load)? There will not be any concrete above the beam's top flange for any sort of connection.

Our concrete wall thickness is 6.25".

Thank you.

RE: Moment Connection to Concrete Wall???

I would not recommend bolted paddle plates to an embed plate.  Embeds and concrete walls are rarely located exactly, so the connection needs field adjustment.  I don't recommend welding to the embed in the field, because this can generate a lot of heat.  

I am not aware of any bearing connection that can transfer moment through the bottom flange only.  

I hope the moments are very small.  Because the embeds must be designed for moment with tension in the anchors.  6.25" wall thickness may be a little thin, especially if the embeds are located near an edge.

Sorry for the lack of suggestions.  We rarely see concrete walls included in moment frames.  Typically moment frames are contained within the steel structure.  Concrete shear walls maybe used orthogonally, but the moment connections will stop at the last steel column.  Beams connections to the concrete wall are for shear only.   

http://www.FerrellEngineering.com

RE: Moment Connection to Concrete Wall???

iponom
Nice detail

But, a mentor once told me "a moment is not smart enough to turn a corner".  Therefore, I always look for the couple forces and transfer the moments as axial forces in a single plane.

Will the tension in the top flange translate to the vertical end plate?  And then vertically through the bearing plate?

And the results, is a lot of forces that concrete does not like.  Tension, moment, shear...
 

http://www.FerrellEngineering.com

RE: Moment Connection to Concrete Wall???

Well, I assumed the wall was designed for moment bending.
As to a corner.. I think the moments are smart enough to turn a corner.. at least that's what I've been taught in school with simple moment frame design...

In this case I see the couple distributed along the ~6.25" (wall thickness) lever arm... no?

 

RE: Moment Connection to Concrete Wall???

That's a tough one.. wonder what shuff213 will come up with in the end.. :)

RE: Moment Connection to Concrete Wall???

Connectegr,

I think I might have applied to work within your company couple months ago... How are you guys doing in this economy, are you hiring or firing? :)

RE: Moment Connection to Concrete Wall???

iponom,

Your moment connection is feasible but keep this in mind...the stiffness of your wide flange vs. a 6" wall is drastically different such that the beam will almost certainly behave as a simply supported beam no matter what you do at the end.

If you fix your very stiff beam to a wet noodle, it still behaves as a simple end.

The wall will crack so your stiffness will be more like a percentage of the Igross of the wall for a fairly limited width (4t wide?).

Why spend all that money for no gain?

 

RE: Moment Connection to Concrete Wall???

JAE,

Well I am not sure what you mean when you talk about stiffness differences. What failure mode do you have in mind?

What I was thinking about is restraining the rotation at the end of the beam.





 

RE: Moment Connection to Concrete Wall???

Restraining it with what?  The wall is only 6 inches thick - it has very little stiffness to restrain the beam at all.

Force follows stiffness.  Per my analogy above - if the wall was a flexural wet noodle, the moment in the wall would be ZERO.

In your case, the wall is only a 6" thick, cracked wall with a transformed, cracked, effective I = 20 in^4 compared with your beam with perhaps an Ix = 2200 in^4.

 

RE: Moment Connection to Concrete Wall???

Restraint for really really really really small moments :)

I agree 6in is nothing - but who know what kind of beams and moments we are dealing with here....

RE: Moment Connection to Concrete Wall???

why even bother connecting it, maybe just have the beam cantilever over it...with a beam pocket and leave it at that...

RE: Moment Connection to Concrete Wall???

Yes.   I agree:  why restrain it?  

And you (in your first post) seemed to indicate that the wall/beam connections were part of a moment frame.  This may not be stable if all you have are 6.25" walls with essentially "pinned" connections.

 

RE: Moment Connection to Concrete Wall???

iponom,
My comment concerning the moment "turning a corner" was intended as a connection design concern.  

Regarding our workload...
I think it is slow everywhere.  We have work, but primarily because of the number of clients we service.  We have not seen any big projects in a while, mostly small projects and miscellaneous.  We are not hiring at this time, but luckily we are not firing either.

http://www.FerrellEngineering.com

RE: Moment Connection to Concrete Wall???

Well I didn't start the topic.. and in my original post I assumed that the wall was stiffer than your typical 6in wall...

I've never seen steel moment connections to 6in conc. walls, but I do think there are some to 4ft thick conc. walls out there...

aren't there monolithic concrete frames that sustain moments- maybe replacing the steel beam with series of concrete beams would work out better, more costly?


 

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources