×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem
2

Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

(OP)
I have a mathematical problem...

I'm trying to work out what the cross section of a Torus would be once it has been stretched over a shaft. So, for a given temperature the volume of the Torus would be the same no matter what amount of stretch you impart on the inside diameter. So the volume of a Torus is:

V = pi.r^2 x pi.Dmean (where r = Torus cross-section radius and Dmean equals the chord diameter of the Torus)

The problem is that I only know the inside diameter of the shaft that the torus has to be stretched onto and not what the chord diameter that the torus will end up being. If you rearrange for r, you get:

r^2 = v/pi^2.Dmean

The problem is that you only know what the inside diameter of Dmean is. Which is:

Dinside + ((Doutside – Dinside) / 2)

But I don't know what Doutside is...

Can this problem be solved..?
 

RE: Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

Quote:

So, for a given temperature the volume of the Torus would be the same no matter what amount of stretch you impart on the inside diameter

You need to review Poisson's Ratio.

 

RE: Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

Well, my first thought was a rubber O-ring, and for such materials a constant volume is a pretty good approximation.  Of course, the inside surface of the O-ring will tend to flatten, so the "math" problem is more of a mental excersize than anything.

A fast way to get a pretty good approximation is to assume the stretch on the i.d. causes a similar contraction of the diameter at a 1:2 ratio.  But that's from a Taylor expansion, not Poisson.  That Poisson was kinda a fishy guy, if you ask me.

RE: Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

(OP)
Yes it is to work out what the change in section of an o-ring would be when the environment goes cold and it's sealing onto a metal shaft. The o-ring guide lines also state that for approximation it can be assumed, in percentage, to be half the amount of stretch. An elongation of 1% corresponds to a reduction of the cross section (d2) of approx. 0.5% - "Taylor's Expansion". Thank you. That's a good aprox for what i'm doing.

RE: Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

(OP)
The problem is that i still can't work out what the new mean diameter will be... I only know the inside diameter that it has to stretch over.

RE: Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

you need to determine the initial cross-section of an O-ring, so that when you stretch over a shaft of an unknown diameter you get a desired final cross-section ...

sorry, but expressed that way, i don't see any way to solve the problem without knowing the "unknown".

you say you know the ID of the shaft ... then either ...
1) guess the OD, assume a wall thikcness, or
2) ask whoever defined the ID what the OD is ??

 

RE: Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

(OP)
That is the question. What is the new OD?

RE: Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

With decent material properties this is trivial in FEA.  I hope this helps.

Rob Stupplebeen

RE: Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

Trelleborg have what I think you're after in their O-ring guide. Need to register with them to view it.

Cheers

RE: Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

Parker handbook also has that info.

You know original ring i.d., and cross-section diameter.

Assume the i.d. and mean diameter stretch the same amount.  I.e. if 10% stretch is required to make the original i.d. become the new i.d., then assume the entire section stretches 10%.  Calculate the reduction in cross section diameter (5%).  Calculate the new o.d. and mean diameter.

At this point, you are close enough to see if you have a good seal.  If you want to get picky, calculate the stretch in mean diameter from your calculation above, and recalculate the reduction in section diameter, and adjust other values accordingly.  But, I'm willing to bet the deviations from 1st calc. to this second iteration calc. will be less than 1%.

Oh, and all of this is really only valid when the stretch is about 10% or less, beyond 20% stretch the Taylor expansion starts to show errors...

RE: Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

No.  I must politely disagree.

If the O-ring has "any" stretch at all, then its INSIDE diameter = OD of the shaft.  Period.  the O-ring cannot "squish" the shaft, and if the two are inn contact, then the O-ring's ID has been determined.

But, to seal, the O-ring must flatten (at both inside and outside contact surfaces!), so the O ring OD (if - and only if! - its outside surface still touchs the ID of the device) will be the ID of the seal.  

So, your problem consists of determining that the heated and cooled O-ring - with no restrains - overlaps both the OD of the shaft and the ID of the seal.   

So heat it up and measure.  Cool it down and measure.       

RE: Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

racooke,

With what do you disagree?
 

RE: Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

It appears you're overly relying on the theorectical (calculation of theorectical centers of expansion and diameters), rather than the simpler mechanics of a constrained flexible piece of rubber between two pieces of metal.   

If thousandths matter, or tens of thousands, then you need to consider the expansion of the two constraining pieces of steel.   

RE: Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

No, simply relying on the math to give an approximation of the contraction in section due to installed O-ring stretch, which was the OP question.

The actual selection of an O-ring (material and geometry) and groove geometry to give good seal results, in various fluids, at various temperatures...would fill a book.  Like the Parker O-ring Handbook for instance.

RE: Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

For an o-ring, don't you generally assume that the O.D. of the ring is also the O.D. of the shaft, thus stretching the o-ring only by its thickness?  I'm not sure where I heard that, but seems reasonable.

RE: Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

Ron,

Generally you want the o-ring to have slight stretch in the installed condition.  The opposite condition (compression of the O-ring required to seat it in its groove) can result in local buckling (wrinkling) of the ring surface, leading to leakage.  The od of the ring, installed in the groove, should then be standing proud of the surrounding shaft surface (assuming the groove is on the shaft), and when installed in the mating sleeve, the ring will then undergo a slight squeeze, of somewhere between 10 and 30% of its section diameter.  The actual value of squeeze can vary, and how much void is filled as the o-ring is squeezed will vary a bit too (you need to leave more room if the ring will see significant temperature variations, or if the compound used swells when it contacts the fluids to be sealed...).

But, we digress, I believe.   

RE: Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

Wolfram

http://mathworld.wolfram.com/Torus.html

Gives the Volume of a Torus as

V= (1/4)(pi)^2(R+r)(R-r)^2

r = (1/2)(ID)

R = (1/2)(OD)

If the volume is constant you can solve for the new R given a new r.

RE: Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

BTB...thanks. I'm just a structural guy whose only experience with o-rings is changing them in my kitchen faucet and, many years ago, rebuilding the carburetors on my MGB and Pontiac LeMans.

RE: Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

If you believe in conservation of mass and shape for this o-ring,( I don't) then you don't have to solve  a messy cubic.
You just take the logarithmic derivative of sreid's volume equation to get
dR/dr=(R+3r)/(3R+r)

RE: Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

For o-rings, you cna use the following formula to estimate the diameter of the cross section after stretching to a larger diameter:

CI = SQRT (CS^2 * (ID / IDi))

CI = cross section diameter installed
CS = cross section diameter in free state
ID = ID in free state
IDi = ID installed

Yes, there are many other factors in play such as poissons ratio, deflection where it contacts at the ID.  Options are to build one and measure it, conduct an FEA, or use the math problem about to get an estimate.

RE: Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

"If you believe in conservation of mass ...( I don't)"

Zeke, you think cold fusion may occur? ;)

RE: Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

TRue,
Sorry, you know I facetiously meant "conservation of volume". Old  habit. As soon as I write "conservation", the mass thing comes out.

RE: Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

"Luckily, the cubic has a single real root"

What if that root is negative?

I guess instead of taking a vacation this summer one could obtain this closed form solution that could easily be gotten today on any of the plotting hand helds.Must admit that it is a fantastic soution.

BTW, where was this genius when I took algebra eons ago using the likes of DeCarte and Horner for "help".
 

RE: Stretching a Torus - Maths Problem

Actually, the real root is always positive for plausible conditions.  The equation is negative for r=0, and is positive for large r, so there must be a positive root. You can get some oddball answers, like an ID=8, r=134, but r will still be positive.

TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources