×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

typical compressor specifications

typical compressor specifications

typical compressor specifications

(OP)
Where can I find typical specifications like horsepower or efficiencies of different type of gas compressors?  I am trying to evaluate power and maintenance costs with different type of compressors to help with my selection of a gas compressor.

RE: typical compressor specifications

asianx,
That is truly a wide open question.  When I was researching the same thing for a class I'm teaching in Denver next week, it took a LOT of digging, a LOT of reconciling conflicting claims, and a LOT of nonsense to wade through before I had a table that I beleived.  

People use the word "isothermal" when they mean "adiabatic".  People use isentropic constants for polytropic machines.  People use the word "efficiency" without defining it (and the definitions are all over the map--if you are comparing a recip with clearance to a recip without clearance the "efficiency could be over 95%, if you are comparing power input to work output the number is lower, if you are comparing energy content of input fuel to work out the number is much lower still).  People lie.

Maintenance and operating costs are another whole bag of worms.  I had a client ask me to look at his flooded screw compressors because they were costing him $20k/month for replacement oil.  I operated a fleet of flooded screws 15 times the size of this operation and spent closer to $2k/year on replacement oil. He was operating them without understanding them.  So is the number $20k or $2k?

Good luck with this.

David

RE: typical compressor specifications

I agree with zadas.  I have some of my opions and personal rule of thumbs that I use to get started.  If I was an anal guy, I'd make a wall chart of these. having started with compressors when most of us used the charts in the GPSA data book, you get a real good feeling about efficencies of compressors. But her is what I do.

Centrifugal compressors can range from 60% to 75+% polytropic efficency. The approximate valiue is a function of each manufacturers actual design and you won't the exact value without a RFQ.  But generally, the smaller and m ore off theshelf (no custom impellars) run around 68%.  Larger custom machines will be closer to 75%.  This is the values I use in the simulators to get the rough idea.  One of the larger yet noncustom impellar compressors use to let you have their DOS program that gave better eff values.  But you are at the mercy of most of the vendors I know.

recips.  Recips are a little different.  I use polytropic eff in modeling because the thermo efficency is a function of the not only ther estimated approach to isentropis, but adjustments for valve losses and other mechanical losses.  Here, the assumed polytropic eff runs between 75% to 85%.  For higher speed compressors with high mole weights I assume 76% and for low compression ratio low gravity gases I use .81%.  Then I use different vendors programs to get the exact value, well they don't calculate eff, but you get the required Horsepower and then i tweak the polytropic eff in the model to get a matching HP.  The crosss check is the discharge temp, this should also match.

With screws, its similar to recips.  the range is 40% to 70%.  the wide spread is a function of compression ratios.  Compression ratios of 8 will have a 40% and with a ration of 2, the eff is closer to 70%. Again, you run the manufactures program that give the HP required.  You can adjust the models.  The last screw run I saw had adiabatic eff listed.

Maintenance is a little more difficult.  maintenance philosophies can creat wild swings.  Size of units, number on location...  A mid range might look like this
       $/HP-yr
cent   100
screw  120
Recip  150

all with engine drivers

no driver
cent   15
screw  20
Recip  30

I've seen way more and way less.



 

RE: typical compressor specifications

also look into availability of service/parts, there are some real nice units available but if they are not in your area it doesn't do you any good

RE: typical compressor specifications

(OP)
I am required to do some calculations on gas compressor selection.  What are some typical things I would have to calculate?

RE: typical compressor specifications

Actually, the compressor part is the tail, the driver is where the costs are and the issues.

What is there to calculate other than life cycle costs?

RE: typical compressor specifications

on gas engine driver,

maintainance costs, fuel usage, oil usage, etc.

elec. driver is similar

compressor depend a lot on what you are compressing as to the costs associated

RE: typical compressor specifications

One other thing to remember is tha application and its characteristics.  If the loads are relatively steady, i.e., mole weight, flow, suction and discharge pressures won't change much day-to-day or month-to-month, then centrifugal compressors often have an advantage in reliability and/or lower maintenance cost.

But if the loads/conditions varely, the reciprocating compressors may have an advantage as they can be adjusted with pockets and/or driver speeds to meet the changing conditions.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources