×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

How do I calculate force required to generate grip?
2

How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

(OP)
Hi guys, hopefully someone here knows how to tackle this. I've been trying to work it out for a while.

We have a machine which moves heavy plates with a spinning wheel. The wheel presses the plate from under then spins to drive the plate onto a rack. Sometimes the wheel doesn't have enough grip on the plates and just spins without moving them. So I'm trying to calculate the amount of force required to generate enough grip (without lifting the plate!).

I thought I could just use a rolling resistance equation, F= (f.W)/r .

F = force
f = resistance
W = weight
r = radius of wheel

Where usually this is done to work out the force required to overcome the rolling resistance, I have a given force (the torque of the motor driving the wheel) and could work out W which would be the minimum force. ie less than this and it would overcome rolling resistance and slip. But this method isn't producing a sensible answer.

I can upload a picture or FBD to make it more clear.

Any ideas? Sorry if something like this has come up before, I did try the search fucntion but couldn't find anything.

 

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

My first intuition, not seeing the details of the geometry, would be to increase the coefficient of static friction.

What materials are slipping?
Can you change materials?
Can you change the surface finish of one or both of the materials (roughen them up)?
Can you use a coating, or skateboard tape, to increase friction without damaging the product?
 

--Scott
http://wertel.eng.pro

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

Hi mechengjohn

Yes lets have a picture or sketch with some dimensions on and we should be able to help you further.

regards

desertfox

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

(OP)
Thanks for the reply.

The wheel is made of a patterned rubber, like a car tyre. The plate is steel. I can't do anything to the plate but could change the wheel tyre, however I don't know if that would be much help.

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

Assuming that you are driving the wheel with an electric motor you DO NOT HAVE A KNOWN DRIVING FORCE.

The torque that may be written on the name plate of the motor is the rated torque of the motor.  Connect the motor to a load that requires more torque than than and you'll kill the motor.  Otherwise, the torque that the motor produces will be proportional to the load it is driving.

The maximum amount of force that the wheel can impart on the plate is simply the coefficient of adhesion x the normal force on on the wheel.  Unless the entire weight of the plate is balanced on the wheel the normal force will be less than the weight of the plate.

The forces resisting movement are the remaining weight of the plate x the coefficient of friction against whatever it is resting on and its inertia.
 

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

The equation you have there, I believe, is for rolling resistance on a moving object.  The F term would not be torque but would be the force resisting forward motion.  The f term would be a coefficient of rolling resistance in length units (normally given as b).  Then you are right about the W being weight (technically the normal force N).

You would likely be better off using an analysis of the point of contact using the standard static friction analysis.  F = mu * N, Look up tyre on metal and that will give you the amount of friction you are generating.

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

The problem may be 2 fold
1) there is some mechanical resistance other than inertia
2) more likely:the acceleration of the wheel is too great to sustain a static friction force and thus it goes into sliding or slipping and gets worse as the interface heats up.
This is readily explained with the startup equation which states that to sustain static friction you must have

u*W>W/g*a
where
u= static friction
W plate weight
g gravity
a acceleration of the wheel periphery
So solving for a
a<u/g


 

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

Error
As usual.The necessary wheel periphery acceleration should be
a<u*g

  

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

Your easiest fix may be to add a roller on the top surface of the plate.  With a roller above the plate, the normal force can be increased until your problem is solved.  As it is the normal force can only ever be a fraction of the plates weight, without moving the plate.

Does the wheel only start spinning once it is in contact with the surface?  If it is constantly spinning the force is going to be reduced (it will be kenetic friction rather than static).

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

In simplest terms, slipping is due to friction.
Friction Force = (Normal Force) * (Coefficient of Friction)

If we can't lift the plate, then we can add any more Normal Force (F=ma + mg) which means we have to change the coefficient of friction.

I have to double check if distributed loading would make a difference on the normal force.  For example, make your wheel smaller to get a higher pressure.  The resultant force is the same, but the local force per area is higher (pressure) and may increase the systems "sticking power."

--Scott
http://wertel.eng.pro

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

Also my bad.  Got distracted while typing and didn't see the attachment or other posts.

For some reason, I've been picturing a spinning disc although you've clearly stated a wheel.

--Scott
http://wertel.eng.pro

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

(OP)
Thanks for all the replies folks.

The wheel is only activated after contact is made. A roller on the top is tricky for various other reasons.

Am I right in thinking that a solution would have to account for contact area of the wheel? As surely a wider tyre would have more grip.

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

Wider tyre would increase the coefficient of friction.  Additionally lowering the tyre pressure would help increase this coefficient, and wouldnt need a redesign.

Like swertel said, you will either need to increase the coefficient of fiction if you cant increase the normal force, or you will need to slow down the wheel.  As was said you have a system where m * a = mu * N, so if you keep the friction force part (mu * N) the same but decrease the acceleration on the wheel/plate then you may be able to avoid slipping out and move your plate.  Is your process dependant on the current speed or can you try lowering the wheels acceleration?

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

(OP)
What I was actually aiming for was to increase the normal force. ie to use a larger cylinder.

I was just looking for a way to determine how much force is required.

I'll try playing with the equations mentioned.

Thanks again.

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

Quote:

As surely a wider tyre would have more grip.

Quote:

Wider tyre would increase the coefficient of friction.

Let's recall the very simplified model of friction force that they taught us in school.

F = mu * N

Force = coefficient of friction * normal force.

Notice that there is no term for area in this equation.

Now in the real world friction isn't this simple.  Friction is often a function of contact pressure, temperature, slip or creep and an bunch of other things.

Contact pressure is obviously a function of area.  However friction does not necessarily always increase with increasing contact pressure.  Also, to further complicate things non-uniform contact pressure will probably result in non-uniform temperatures.

So it's not at all certain that increasing the tire size will increase the available grip.

Quote:

I was actually aiming for was to increase the normal force. ie to use a larger cylinder.

If there is nothing other than gravity holding the plate down the maximum possible normal force is its weight.  Since it seems unlikely that the place will ever be supported solely by the wheel, the normal force will always be less than the weight.   

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

(OP)
Thanks for the input MintJulep.

When I first tried this problem, I converted my motor torque to force. (T = F*r) where r is radius of the wheel.

Then using the equation in the OP with an f value of 0.0077m (which is for hard rubber on steel I believe) worked out the minimum Normal force needed.

As has been stated the maximum Normal force cannot exceed the weight of the plate. So I thought that the ideal Normal force would be anywhere between these two values.

This method still seems correct in my mind, however the values for normal force I was getting were a factor of 30 over what we have been using so I assumed I had made an error in my method somewhere.

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

Mechengjohn,
I believe that if you use the method above, all your answer will tell you is the normal force required to prevent the wheel from slipping under any possible condition.  

If it were me, I would attempt to find out the resistance to movement that the plate has.  That could be difficult to do by analytical means, so an experiment might be the quickest way.  

Then, once I had that force (for the force required to start the plate moving), I would check to make sure my motor could provide that much torque.  Then, I would plug it into the friction equation, and see how much normal force is required on the wheel.  

Finally, I might use the rolling resistance equation with a couple iterations to try to get a more exact value.

You might look in a fluid power handbook.  Some of them have much more detailed rolling resistance equations that take area of contact, normal force, etc. into account

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

How is the wheel accelerated assuming it is at standstill before it hits the plate? If you accelerate it too much, it will spin without moving the plate since the inertia of the plate will prevent it from moving. Once the wheel slips you're into dynamic friction and you have lost the ballgame.

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

Hi mechengjohn

I think your on the right lines with rolling friction, your difficulty will be obtaining a correct coefficient for your situation.
Increasing the normal force will help, but at present the only normal force you have is the weight of the plate sitting on the wheel as stated by others.
You will get some benefit by increasing the width of the tyre or decreasing tyre pressure, because rubber is a compliant material, so its true area of contact is very close to its nominal area of contact, whereas normally the true area of contact is usually much less than the norminal area of contact when two harder materials are placed on one another, which why it is stated that the true area in the latter case is proportional to the normal force pushing them together. See this site scroll down till you see this heading:-
The microscopic origin of friction forces

http://www.engin.brown.edu/courses/en3/Notes/Statics/friction/friction.htm


Also have a look at this site it as loads of information on friction and links to other information on other sites
http://www.roymech.co.uk/Useful_Tables/Tribology/co_of_frict.htm#sliding

goodluck

desertfox

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

Maybe I am not understanding something, but I am still confused as to why you would use the rolling resistance equation, or need to look at torque as cmcbain suggested.  You mentioned that the wheel can move the parts, but it often spins out and does not work.  To me it seems your analysis should revolve around whether the wheel spins out or not, not the rollinh resistance imparted on the wheel.  Like I said before I would look at the force of friction between the plate and the rubber.  I would use:

mu * N = W / g * a

This however neglects the friction of the plate on the surface you have it on so you might want to use:

mu * N = W / g * a + mu * (W - N)

In this the first mu is rubber on steel and the second is steel on whatever your slide is.  The (W-N) term is the normal force between your plate and the slide it is on, assuming that the effective wieght will be the weight of the plate minus the upward force from the wheel.

If the mu * N term is not as great as the W / g * a + mu * (W - N) term, the wheel will spin out.  That I thought was what you wanted.  If the wheel spins out, increase the upward force, there by increasing the friction from the wheel and reducing the friction on the slide, or slow things down by using less torque from your motor to start up, decreasing the inertial term (W/g*a).

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

Afun,
Look at your equation which is a fair representation of the system.
"mu1 * N = W / g * a + mu2 * (W - N)
I took the liberty of making the two coefficients (static) different (mu1>mu2 since rubber to steel>steel to floor)
Isn't it clear that if  "a" (acceleration) gets too large it will slip, and if the overhang weight W-N is too great it will also slip, even if the a is near zero.

So, instead of focusing on increasing weights on the roller, i believe that control of the plate with a measured slow acceleration of the roller could do the job. When it comes to speed, the second term mu2 which is <mu1 to start with, gets even smaller when sliding.



 

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

zekeman,
Yes, I agree that that would be a good solution to the problem, and probably the easiest to achieve as it likely requires no change to the design.  The only issue is if this is part of a process in which the time of the operation is critical.
 

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

BTW, there should be an inequality replacing the equal sign to your equation, namely
mu1 * N >W / g * a + mu2 * (W - N)
which states that the static coefficient, mu1 exceeds the requirement of moving the plate and the actual friction force would be less than mu1*N

 

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

"  The only issue is if this is part of a process in which the time of the operation is critical."

Of course and perhaps  " slow" may also  be hard to control.

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

Are the plates oily?  Cleaning might help.  Or spraying them with something that would increase the coefficient of friction (I don't know what).  

Or, if you really want to get fancy and spend money, make a special wheel with radial ports in it and pull a vacuum through the ports to try and pull the plate down on to the wheel.  

How about a studded wheel?  Hard, short, sharp studs that would dig into the plates.  Of course you'd be left with small indentations in the steel.

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

Hi mechengjohn

On your diagram of the set up the wheel comes up under the plate, but does not appear to be central relative to the plate, that means the plate is lifted off centre and I presume that the plate is supported further to the right of the wheel is that correct?
If that is the case, then the reaction on the wheel from the plate is less then the full mass of the plate, which means the force to overcome friction is reduced,thereby making the situation worse. Is there any control on the position of the wheel relative to say one edge of the plate or its centre, if not the reaction of the plate on the wheel will vary each time,even if the plates have equal mass and size.
Reducing the speed of the wheel would help as others have stated, but I guess your motor is a fixed entity which cannot be changed.

desertfox

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

Couldn't he test his coefficient of friction by actuating the cylinder and fixing the tire (not allowing it to rotate), then by pulling the plate manually, recording the pulling force required to slide the plate across the tire, then he can take the ratio of the pushing force (of cylinder) and how much it took to pull it to determine his coefficient of friction. Now he would have to determine if his surface force of the tire (if the tire was a 1" radius and the torque was 10 in/lbs then that would be 10 lbs of force) is indeed less than its friction, which would be required for it to function properly

Also to prove the other theories mentioned, you can let air out of the tire and judge the difference in the force it takes to slide the plate.
 

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

How about just changing the compound, softer, in the tire itself.
If there is room change the tire diameter to change the angle.

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

(OP)
aafuni / zekeman,

i think you may be right. I will try experimenting with slower acceleration speed to start. Although this may prove tricky with our setup at present.

desert fox - yes the plate is supported by rollers along it's travel path. So you are correct about the reaction being less than the full mass of the plate, however the plate is very heavy and at the moment the wheel is not close to being strong enough to lift the plate. I can increase the force by some margin before it starts to lift.

Thanks to everyone for the responses, all have been helpful.

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

Hi mechengjohn

You need to ensure the wheel takes as much of the weight reaction as possible, but without the wheel lifting the plate above horizontal, if it lifts the plate above horizontal you will lose reaction.

desertfox

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

Hi mechengjohn

One way to slow the wheel down would be to reduce the wheel radius given that

V=W*r

V=linear velocity

r= wheel radius

W= angular velocity in radians/sec

desertfox

RE: How do I calculate force required to generate grip?

Why not support the rest of the plate on steel rollers?

I don't think you'll find a much better material than rubber for your drive wheel, so it seems to me that the knobs you can turn are as follows:
-Increase the force from the hydraulic cylinder - you'll have to keep it under 50% of the weight of the plate so you don't end up lifting it up.
-Decrease the friction between the plate and the supporting structure.
-Decrease the acceleration of the drive wheel (might be able to solve it with the control system).
-Add another drive wheel

Put together a free-body diagram of your steel plate, to include friction forces and inertia forces and solve for the drive force. Compare your required driving force to the slipping force and go from there.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources