×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load
3

Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

(OP)
I am designing a 4 story building with a basement that will be placed on auger cast piles.  The perimeter of the building will be placed on grade beams to support the basement wall as well as a brick facade above.  With the exception of the basement wall, the support structure is steel.  So, any columns will be placed in the center of the grade beam, but the basement wall and facade will placed to the exterior of the grade beam creating a torsional moment.  What is the best way to handle this load?  My initial idea was to ensure a moment connection at all pile/grade beam interfaces so that I can assume the beam fixed against torsion at these locations and then design the piles for the additional moment.  Does anyone have a better suggestion?

Thanks in advance for any help.

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

Do you have a concrete slab?

Arguing with an engineer is like wrestling with a pig in mud. After a while you realize that they like it

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

The basement roof/first floor slab should be able to restrict the free rotation of the perimeter grade beam. Pay attention to floor opening adjacent to grade beam, such as stair well.

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

(OP)
Yes, there will be a floor slab sitting on top of the grade beams.  Thanks for the tip.   

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

2
I don't understand the problem.  Could you kindly explain it again?

BA

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

The basement floor slab, or rectifying grade beams, can be designed to take the bending moments so that the torsion is eliminated.

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

I agree with what has been said.  The couple is easily taken out by a couple at the First Floor slab and the Basement Slab.  This is really no different than the more typical case where the Basement wall is supported on a wall footing.  You wouldn't design the wall footing for the eccentricity--it is taken out in the wall above.

DaveAtkins

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

Oops--of course I meant, "The MOMENT is easily taken out..."

And I try so hard not to make mistakes in this forum cry

DaveAtkins

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

I think a cross section is needed.  I have never seen a grade beam under a basement wall, but if the wall is eccentric to the grade beam, why would there not be torsional moment in the grade beam?   

BA

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

BA:

The flooring will take out the torsion.

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

If I understand the problem correctly, I don't believe its as simple as the floor slab just assuming all of that torsion...  I see the flexural stiffness of the floor slab and the bsmt wall to be paramount.  If the grade beam is stiff enough won't it assume torsion anyway?  

Kinematically speaking the grade beam rotating will induce diaphragm/membrane forces in the slab.  However, if the slab is connected to the grade beam by lying on top with a doweled shear connection, shear friction relies on a tiny bit of initial slip, doesn't it?  I see the critical task to be to limit cracking in the grade beam.  Cracks in non-soil bearing concrete members scare me due to the likliehood of accelerated corrosion of reinforcing.   

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

It has to be designed as structural slab - reinforced.
That is not good idea to have a floating slab (SOG) for the basement anyway.  

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

Ltwine-
Whats wrong with a floating SOG in a basement?
Don't 95% of all basements have this?
 

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

I believe I was misconstrued.  The way its being discussed that the wall and slab effectively negate the torsion altogether ignores distribution of forces based on stiffness of members.  The wall above and the slab aren't rigid supports - they have stiffness (and therefore flexibility).

What I'm getting at is that I wouldn't just check/design the wall and slab for the strength required for the additional flexure - I'd put some consideration into the relative stiffness of those members.

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

Two reasons for this one:

1. To help resist tendency of grade beam rotation.
2. Prevent water infiltration

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

The OP did not say the grade slab is structural.  Ordinarily, it would be a slab on grade with no connection to the wall or grade beam.  In that case, there would be torsion in the grade beam from the eccentric load.   

BA

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

I am the 5% minority, only had done one floating slab for basement.  

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

Ltwine-
I am not trying to be smart here.
I have built many a home with basements.
All had plain old slabs-on-grade.

Am I missing something here or saying something wrong?  

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

..ok....not realyl "grade", since the basement floor is typically 5-6 feet below "grade".
 

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

This is a 4 storey building, presumably not a home.  The moment/torsion generated by the vertical eccentricity can be quite large.  Depending on the ground conditions, it may be feasible to resist the moment by the piles.  If not, the moment must be resisted either in the basement floor system or in the wall, or some combination of both.  If the wall resists the moment and the basement slab is a light slab on ground, there should not be a soft joint between the slab and wall, as the slab is required to provide the reaction for the push-pull moment in the wall.

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

What is happening perpendicular to this section?  Do you have a regular grid where you could tie in perpendicular grade beams at the column locations?  This could take any torsion out of the grade beam shown in the section as a concentrated moment in the perpendicular grade beam.  Then you could use the standard floating slab on grade.  This would add another pile to help resist any lateral load at the base of the wall also.  If you have a narrow building, you could just run the grade beam from wall to wall.

If you're putting moment into the top of the pile, then you would need obviously need hooked steel from the pile into the grade beam.  It wasn't shown on your detail, so I thought I would throw that out there.

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

toadjones:

Above all, I don't do residential, even the exception of my only such design was applied to a light industrial facility with odd pre-existing wall footings buried deep into the soil, not much choice there.

I like the solid feel of reinforced floor, no need to worry about joint details/material, cracks, seepage, running mud after flood, and potential of change of use.

After all, the OP's section might not have much torsion after successful back filling. Torsion could be critical during the stage of wall construction.

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

(OP)
There is a grid perpendicular to this section.  The building is approximately 82' wide and the interior columns are on spread pile cap foundations.  The only grade beams running perpendicular to this section are at the ends of the building.  I would prefer not to add in additional perpendicular grade beams if there is a simpler solution such as structurally connecting the slab to the beam as someone else mentioned above.  Does anyone agree with that solution?

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

What's in the basement?  Heavily loaded?  Typically, do you use an unreinforced floating slab?

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

I would not use the detail shown at all.  It would be better and more economical to provide a pilaster from basement to Main Floor at each column location, i.e. start the steel column just below Main Floor beams.

Delete the grade beam.  The concrete wall is more than adequate to act as a beam on its own.  Instead, use a pile cap at each pile and extend the cage from the pile into the pile cap.  Center each pile under the center of gravity of applied loads to reduce moment in the pile.  The grade slab can be tied laterally to each pile cap but it does not need to resist moment.

Do you really need 16" thick walls?  How is the top of wall tied into the structure?  There is no vertical reinforcement on the inside face of the 10" block where it meets the 16" wall, so it can't span vertically.  If the wall spans horizontally between pilasters, the pilasters must be tied to the Main Floor structure to resist lateral loads.



 

BA

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

(OP)
Actually, this slab will be reinforced with wwf.  Sorry that it wasn't indicated on this particular detail.  The heavier loads on the floor slab are around 150 psf live load.   

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

(OP)
There are pilaster columns in the structure, but this detail only shows the wall section between columns.  The steel columns will be placed at the top of the 16" block and the wall will also be braced at that elevation.  That's the reason why there is no reinforcement on the inside face of the 10" block.   

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

If there are pilasters, there is no issue with torsion.  But why bother with a grade beam at all?  The wall is much stiffer than the beam and will carry its own weight.

BA

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

If you are going to stick to current details, plan well on shoring to take out unbalanced conditions during construction. I sometimes dictate construction sequence and ask for necessary construction support be installed during certain period/stage, or ask the contractor submit his plan for review. The requests do not mean to interfere with the ways and means of how the contractor doing his business, but to identify and find solution for potential catches/problems, early and in a timely manner.

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

The nomenclature on the detail bothers me.  All the reinforcement is shown as "dowels" of one kind or another.  The only ones I would call dowels are the ones at the wall to slab junction called "2-#3 dowels cont", but they are not continuous, and are not desirable as they restrain the slab from shrinking.  I would carry the sand onto the grade beam to further prevent restraint.

I agree that with pilasters, there is no concern with torsion on the grade beam.  I would still use the grade beams, as they give a good platform for the rest of the construction.  The pile reinforcement should at least extend a decent length into the grade beam.

At the top, I assume brick veneer continues above.  The slab should be carried through to support the veneer backup rather than depending on the 6" CMU.  

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

hokie,

I agree that the nomenclature on the drawing is questionable.  It needs to be revised to make the intent of the drawing clearer.

I don't have a problem with using a grade beam, but a 2'-9" by 3'-0" continuous beam is an expensive way to provide  a platform for wall forming.  I would not do it and I don't think you would either.

BA

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

The grade beam does seem to be a big larger than required.  I would probably reduce the depth.  If it were a concrete wall, you could omit it, but with a block wall, you need a footing to start on.

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

(OP)
Thanks for all your suggestions.  I agree that this detail needs to be revised and I'm not sure why the bars are called out as dowels.  I was brought in on this project part way through and this was how the detail had been shown before.   

RE: Grade Beam on Piles with Torsional Load

ltwine-

What difference would it make if the floor were plain concrete or reinforced as far as seepage goes?
Where is this mud coming from ?
We usually pour basement slabs on a layer of 6 mil plastic.
If you can feel the reinforcing in the slab you must have some sensitive toes!!!!!

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources