×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

(OP)
What is the best method to pour concrete on slopes up to a 2:1 that is reinforced.  This appliation would be for a liquid tight lagoon.  Some as large as an acre in size.  The concrete is reinforced with steel for crack control.  Has anyone heard of "glacial" pouring?  I have done it and Contractors like it because you just let the concrete flow down the side slope while workers are striking it off and leveling it.  it keeps labor costs down.  What is your opinion of this method?  Thanks.

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

Depends on the concrete travel distance down the slope. I would utilize chute or conveying hose to gain better control to avoid aggregate seperation, which may lower the quality of the concrete and cause honeycombs, if not vibrate properly.

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

(OP)
We pour sometimes up to a 60' length.  No vibration on the slope.  strike it flat and roller buggy it.  Some areas we may encounter honeycombing because the roller buggy won't get it smooth.  Do believe this method is acceptable for the intended use of a liner?  It will not have any equipment loading.  We currently have not had any problems with this method but it kind of goes against ACI for placement methods.  This is a unique application however so I am not sure how to specify the placement.

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

Get about 3 or 4 buggies and create a chain of filling and dumping.  Screed and finish. Its about the only way to do it.  Very gruesome. Keep slump about a 5 inch max.

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

For a big pour, I'd try a creter-crane (a conveyor mounted on a hydraulic rough terrain crane) or a pump truck.

www.PeirceEngineering.com

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

(OP)
We have done it with a conveyor and a pump also as "PEinc" stated.  using buggies is out of the question.  these are several hundred yard pours.  the glacial pouring method consists of approx. 5' strips down the slope.  The concrete truck continues to dump the concrete from the top of the slope as the concrete flows down the 5' wide strip to the bottom.  workers stike it and roller bugger it.  We have not found much evidence of segregation doing it this method.  Contractors like it because is keeps the cost down.  I was wondering what your opinions are on this method.

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

Not on my watch. Good luck.

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

We do this quite often for reservoir bottoms.  We require the contractor to pour upward (start at the bottom) and push the concrete up the slope with a rotating screed.  I'm not sure if a rotating screed is something that can be purchased but the contractors that work our projects rig one up.  It has a chain driven drum and is supported by guides of some kind. Make sure there are plenty of laborers available.  We usually limit the pours to 30 ft. wide between construction joints and I've seen about 20 workers there to finish the concrete, fill in low spots, etc.
We've had poor experiences with anything done from the top down.

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

(OP)
could you share what poor experiences you have had?  I would be curious to see if these problems would be related with our concerns.  I would appreciate it.   

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

arh13p:

The contractor is paid to do the work sticking to the standard practices, which have been used for years with proven track record. You may have succeed in using your method in the past many times, however, the owner, and potentially you/your employer, likely to bear higher chances to suffer from the poor result, because so many things could go wrong have indeed went wrong.

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

(OP)
Ltwine:
I agree with you 100%.  I am on a team to change a construction specification for concrete.  We currently only allow the placement from the bottom up, consistent with current industry practice.  However, we are getting overwhelming request to consider this method(glacial pouring) with possible additional precautions.  The main concern was the chance of having void space on the downstream end of the steel.  However after testing cores from this method and methods that were pumped from the bottom up, we didn't find any substantial evidence supporting one method was better then the other.  On a 2.5:1 slope, gravity will slump the concrete after placement anyways therefore having the same chance of a void.  Many responded they wouldn't do it this method.  Why?

What would the main concerns be with the glacial pour method vs. pouring from the bottom up?

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

Without special treatment, which I have no clue, 3 ingredients are likely to lost/stick to the bottom after free rolling down a long slope - water, cement, fine sand.
Maybe you can verify it by taking samples at the toe, waist (mid height), and one at the point of concrete discharge (no rolling). I would be surprised that there is not much difference among the samples.

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

Our company designs a lot of hopper bottom reservoirs.  I can't say exactly why we pour from the bottom up, but it was emphasized in such a way that I didn't want to be the one who changed it.  I suspect the concrete is more susceptable to horizontal cracks due the tension forces created when the gravity pulls the concrete down the slope.
There might be more than one or ten ways to skin a cat, but we don't have problems with the sloped walls leaking.   

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

Cranes are quite expensive.   

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

Have seen quite a bit of 4 sack/reinforced concrete placed on 2:1 slopes.  No lagoon, just scour control under bridge slopes. -NON STRUCTURAL-
Always started at the top (1"-2" slump) and placed coming down the slope. I would hate to see folks having to work it from the bottom up. Gravity would not be your friend.

Usually set temp. 1" by 1" headers at grade up and down the slope to screed board (mag.stright edge) off of and control grade.

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

Riprap will do the same if not better.

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

This is Rip Rap.

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

Reinforced concrete riprap? I think riprap consists of stone only.

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

I beg to differ sir.  
Rip Rap can be either stone or concrete. Most of the bridges I have been involved with have been constructed with the 4"-5" concrete with either #3's on 18" c-c or WWF.

I hate the rock Rip Rap.... simply because its really tough and dangerous to walk on.  

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

Could be my ignorance.

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

Riprap can be stone or rubbilized concrete. Concrete paving is slope armor.

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

I've always seen rip rap as individual stones, about 6" to much larger.  On a few jobs, the rip rap was placed and then covered with thick grout.   

www.PeirceEngineering.com

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

I think Drumchaser was covering the river bank riprap with reinforced concrete, which is quite common at bridge abutment - a perfect homeless shelter:)

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

Some time ago all slopes under bridge abutments (and wrapped around to Apex of slope adjacent too) was almost exclusively placed as concrete as I have described above.

My feeble memory recalls that we have changed in this region to a greater percentage of projects utilizing the Stone Rip Rap because of aesthetics. I could be wrong.

The fact that it is harder to graffiti it up could be another reason.

I think in a cost comparison of the proximity of quarries, haul distance to project vs. the recent additional cost increases of ready-mix concrete may have made the Rock Rip Rap more affordable.

Again, I could be wrong.

My favorite Rip Rap (slope armoring next to waterway) was articulated block mat. Little pillows pumped full of grout that were made from a parachute type material all woven together. This was labor intensive, but it really looked nice when completed.
 

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

Sounds like Fabriform mats by Intrusion Prepakt.  Matter of opinion as to whether they look good.  But I wouldn't call that method "riprap".

RE: Pouring concrete on a steep slope?

Potato/potauto......I do not have a pic. of the A.B.M.  ..but it is still in place over 20 years later....about 8 miles of it.

 

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources