×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

(OP)
Hi,

Does anyone know the purpose of the conical shaped device located between the generator and the silencer?

Thanks.

RE: Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

not offhand... what's it connected to above?  Is it actually exchanging gases with a duct (the way it looks in the picture)?
 

RE: Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

(OP)
It is not connected to anything.  The duct is several feet above the exhaust piping.

What you see at the top is some sort of cap, about the size of a garden hose.

RE: Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

maybe it's an exhaust take-off for a (disconnected) EGR system?  do you see any provisions on the inlet side of the engine for connecting similar-size tubes (sized like the plug on top)?

RE: Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

(OP)
I didn't notice.  I'll have to check during my next visit.

Thanks for your help!

RE: Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

Maybe some plumber ran out of pipe and these "just fit"..

RE: Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

It looks to me like a crude attempt at a vacuum type jet.  But I can't imagine what someone would have wanted to pull into the exhaust stream at this point.

rmw

RE: Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

It looks like a venturi design. Perhaps intended for mixing air or water into the exhaust to cool it. Something like that might be used for marine applications.

RE: Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

venturi setup that i have seen used to pull crankcase fumes/pressure and dispose of as to not fume up the building/enclosure it is in

RE: Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

venturis are also used with some inlet air filtration schemes (separators) to dispose of the collected dirt, especially in dusty environments...

but if this thing is supposed to be a venturi, it doesn't look like one that would work very well.  I'm not liking the step change in diameter upstream of it, and unless the side tube curves inside the device to get to the throat, it's not getting the suction.
  

RE: Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

Which might explain the cap.  Somebody built what he thought would be a venturi (for use in one or more of the above schemes), but fubbed it, and the darn thing blew smoke in his face when he fired up the motor.  So, he cut the pipe and capped it, and walked away red-faced.

RE: Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

Another thought, my original one, was that the tap was intended to be upstream of the restriction, and the tapped exhaust was going to be passed through a heat exchanger for a co-gen application (thought that was what the adjacent duct was).

RE: Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

I agree with the "home-made/jury-rigger/jerry-rigged/redneck" set of parts (trying) to make a venturi at the end.

The first "step reducer" is actually a spoolpiece hand-made after original de-construction  to replace a removed valve or fitting or adapter/tee/pipe section.  This removed pipe section would have fit between the first large flange on the right and the same size flange on the venturi inlet.     

RE: Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

Is the direction of flow from right to left?   

Pipe diameters keep getting smaller !!! if start from the right and go left, but you'd want your exhaust to get bigger (or stay the same at least) to improve efficiency of the flow.  

Sudden start/stops, changes in diameter for no (now) good reason, sharp bends and decreasing pipe sizes screw up flow big time.

Replace the whole thing, starting at the reducing street elbow at the first bend.  Use long radius elbow, as big a NEW pipe as you can afford, and as straight a run as possible.    

RE: Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

(OP)
Yes, the direction of flow is from right to left.  The facilities people haven't a clue regarding its purpose.

Thanks to all for your help.

We are replacing all the exhaust piping and silencer.  2" for each manifold. 4" silencer and main to roof.

I was just curious what it was, never saw one before.

Thanks again.

RE: Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

At your connection between the two 2" lines, try for a Y rather than a Tee going into the 4 inch line.  Not essential, but try.

Alt: Use a 2 x 2 x 4 Tee

RE: Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

It would be interesting to see the inside if and when you replace that section of exhaust.  

RE: Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

If right to left flow, why would you want to increase the velocity of the gas through the silencer.  Looks like a screw-up.  Could also be some bastardized pressure relieve valving set up.  Take it out and see what happens!

RE: Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

well, if you note the diameters going into the gizmo and into the muffler, you'll see that velocity should be about the same before and after (if not for losses).
 

RE: Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

I could swear that it's a commercial _something_, that I have seen before, not a homebrew something ... but I can't remember what it is.

  

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

Mike, it could be a pump priming system - but it would have to go after the muffler.

RE: Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

Ain't it fun to keep re-designing some other guy's rusted-out, busted-up, jerry-rigged junk old hardware?   8<)

On his budget no less!  

PS.  Merry Christmas to all.   Robt

RE: Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

MikeHalloran (Mechanical)      
24 Dec 09 23:34
I could swear that it's a commercial _something_, that I have seen before, not a homebrew something ... but I can't remember what it is.

Mike:  

I have worked with oil system check valves that are built similar to this cone + flange setup: The flapper is mounted on a central flat plate ( same size as the pipe flange) mounted between a cone and the inlet pipe flange.  The flapper swings out into the space provided by the cone, swinging on two mounts at the top.    

RE: Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

The ONLY reason I could see in using that, would be if for some un-godly reason, the system needed a little bit of backpressure. The sudden change would restrict flow causing some backpressure.
 Just a suggestion, still not sure what the purpose of the backpressure would be.
 

RE: Natural Gas-Driven Emergency Generator Exhaust

I feel like this is the "What Is It" portion of Ask This Old House.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources