×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Prius Mileage
2

Prius Mileage

Prius Mileage

(OP)
Just had my 60000 mile service about a month ago and my mileage has dropped significantly from around 52 to 42 now.  I do not think that it's all the cold weather and gas additives, but I know that plays a large part.  

Last year in similar weather I was getting 47 mpg.  I think I'm going to take it in and see if the adjustments were properly made during that service.  I'm suspicious.

Any other thoughts or recommendations?  ponder

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
Motto:  KISS
Motivation:  Don't ask

RE: Prius Mileage

hmmm...  that's a big drop.  how are you determining your mileage?   

RE: Prius Mileage

(OP)
By the averaqe mileage seen on the screen - computer generated.  It roughly checks woth the mileage driven and the fuel consumed when I calculate it too.  

I also reset the mileage computer at the last gas fill, so the computer average reading for the last 100 miles or so is very accurate.

It's disconcerting to say the least.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
Motto:  KISS
Motivation:  Don't ask

RE: Prius Mileage

msquared48 ,
There are a few Prius owners groups on the internet and perhaps one may hold the answer you are chasing.

This is the leading item according to Google:
http://www.priusownersgroup.com/

I have to agree that is a significant drop.
Wheel alignment alterations possibly?

Pete.

RE: Prius Mileage

I assume Prius' have adaptive computer software;  did they by any chance disconnect the battery?  In other words, is the software re-learning?

RE: Prius Mileage

The computer should have re-learned anything it needs within a 100 miles or so... nothing it would be learning for any extended period of time would cause that sort of drop.

Make sure they didn't "upgrade" your ECUs firmware with any "fixes" from Toyota while you were in there.  If they replaced the sparkplugs, did they gap them correctly?  tire pressure within acceptable range?  Quite a few things would have to add up to lose 20% of your gas mileage.
 

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: Prius Mileage

It roughly checks woth the mileage driven and the fuel consumed when I calculate it too.

I've logged my fuel mileage in each of my recent vehicles over the entire period I've owned them.  My experience has been that tank-to-tank variation in when the fillup stops contributes significantly to errors in a one-tank calculation (so use 3-tank averages), and that the computer estimate is only within 15% of the actual fuel economy when it gets lucky.  The computers always seem to guess high - must be a marketing influence.

All that said, if the computer is saying mileage has changed, then something must have changed in its inputs, which don't include tank-to-tank shutoff variation.  If they did upgrade the ECU, perhaps they have an adjusted algorithm for estimating fuel economy.  Maybe you have an electrical circuit which stays on overnight, leaving you with a charge deficit in the morning?  Would have to be a big one...

Are you still driving to work on the same route each day, or have you recently spent some time driving a different route?  
 

RE: Prius Mileage

2
Try posting your question here.. http://priuschat.com/forums/ There's a specific forum dealing with fuel mileage and factors affecting.

Any changes in your driving route, frequency of driving coincident with the dealer visit?

While I suspect the following is not your root cause, it is something you probably would like to know about.

I've noticed (and one of the root mechanisms was documented by Oak Ridge National Labs engineering analysis of the Prius design) that short trips spaced out by greater than 1 day intervals can knock the mileage down noticeably e.g. from 52 mpg averages to about 46 over the same routes). The 1 day+ cycle is bounded by the characteristics of the coolant heat recovery system in Gen II design, 2010 Gen IIIs use a different mechanism there mainly to meet PZEV requirements.

While the 2nd gen Prius has a coolant heat recovery /insulated storage system (with a good +24hr cycle, infrequent trips result in initial start up energy loss to become noticeable i.e. back to back initial start up energy losses during the first 5 minutes of operation.. In addition to the energy just to heat the mass of the system, per ORNL studies, the oil windage losses in the spray mist cooling system inside the HSD drive goes up significantly until oil temperature comes up.  

These losses would be characteristic in all vehicles but not as noticeable in less efficient vehicles.  

 

RE: Prius Mileage

(OP)
I am familiar with the Priuschat forum and have been a member for a couple or years.  I wanted opinions other than the standard answers Toyota gives.  

I am going to make a run of 100 miles or so today to the airport on the freeway.  I'll see what happens, and if it stays the same, I'm going back to the service dealer as something is wrong.

Thanks for the information guys.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
Motto:  KISS
Motivation:  Don't ask

RE: Prius Mileage

Have you changed where you buy your gas?
  I have heard a few stories around work, with warnings about some stations.
  I have never watched it that close but some of these guys at work are fanatic even about the time of the day that they buy gas.

Just a thought.

I don't know anything but the people that do.

RE: Prius Mileage

(OP)
Just got back from the airport and now it's just over 48.  That's acceptable, but I will continue to monitor.   

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
Motto:  KISS
Motivation:  Don't ask

RE: Prius Mileage

Firstly, over 100 miles the difference between 47 expected  and 42 actual is about 1 pint of fuel. I'm not necessarily convinced that that is enough of a difference to trust. Does Prius use a returnless fuel system?

Secondly, won't you see a hit in mpg for whatever shuffling around was done at the garage?

Thridly did you top up at your usual staion. If not and there was a bit more ethanol than usual, that could be a few % straight off the bat.

Alternatively since you are coming into winter they may have switched to a more volatile brew, which may have a lower calorific value and higher octane.


Basically not enough data!

Cheers

Greg Locock

I rarely exceed 1.79 x 10^12 furlongs per fortnight

RE: Prius Mileage

(OP)
I always use the same local station for filling, exception is long trips of course, but that's not the case here.

I always top off too, generally adding an extra gallon or so after the automatic shutoff happens.  Never been a problem.  I also record the miles and amount put into the tank at each filling, and have since I bought the car in late Jan of 2007.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
Motto:  KISS
Motivation:  Don't ask

RE: Prius Mileage

They should actually have been on the better blend since October or so.  Southern California usually runs the poorer blend between May and November, if I recall correctly.  Not sure what they do elsewhere; but we always wind up with price spikes when they switch over.

TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies

RE: Prius Mileage

I also record the miles and amount put into the tank at each filling, and have since I bought the car in late Jan of 2007

Well then plot the single-tank figures, and add a 3-tank moving average line over the top, and look to see whether the recent "change" looks important in the grand scheme of things.

RE: Prius Mileage

(OP)
I can do that, but why did you chose those figures.  Statistically, why the three tank variation?   

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
Motto:  KISS
Motivation:  Don't ask

RE: Prius Mileage

Quote (msquared48):

I always top off too, generally adding an extra gallon or so after the automatic shutoff happens.
Aren't you defeating the one of the purposes of a "green" car if you chance killing the evap system by overfilling?

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: Prius Mileage

three tank moving average, not three tank "variation."

Three tanks smooths the result, but not so much that it obscures month-to-month trends.  Two tanks gives a choppy line.  A three-tank moving average is, of course, going to give a more accurate representation of average fuel economy over the period in question, but it takes longer to get (about 30 days for 3 tankfuls, in my case).

 

RE: Prius Mileage

"Aren't you defeating the one of the purposes of a "green" car if you chance killing the evap system by overfilling?"

There have been some cases of the fuel cell system being damaged by forced overfilling on Gen II Prius.  

The Gen II does not have a conventional fuel evap system design but instead uses a fuel bladder inside a steel tank such that there is no gas fume saturated air to be expelled during filling as occurs with conventional car tanks with a gasoline/air/fume mix in the tank.

The bladder expands and contracts as fuel levels vary. An unusual visible aspect of this system is that when the fueling station gas nozzle is inserted into the filler, the nozzle makes an air tight seal with the fill pipe.

The Gen III (2010 models)uses a different system I understand without the bladder.

RE: Prius Mileage

For what it is worth - I talked to a buddy who owns one.  He said the following can affect mpg by 5+/- mpg rather easily

1.  Using tires not specified
2.  Wrong tire inflation - presumably too low
3.  Cold weather

Good luck

RE: Prius Mileage

Interesting... now I wonder why more cars don't use the bladder system to remove the need for an evap system.  Could it be the small tank size of the hybrids compared to a conventional vehicle?

I've only ridden in a hybrid once (it was a Prius, I believe).  Surprising amount of pickup, so much so that I thought it was as good as any typical $15-$20k car engine.

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: Prius Mileage

so much so that I thought it was as good as any typical $15-$20k car engine
Not bad for a car that only costs $22-$28k, eh?
 

RE: Prius Mileage

I know little about the Prius but I'm surprised that no one has suggested that the battery may be losing its storage capacity. Batteries have a finite life and performance can change suddenly. I would guess, though, that battery capacity is something that the car's computer should be measuring.

RE: Prius Mileage

I wouldn't think the storage capacity itself is necessarily an issue, since the battery energy outflow is alway made up by the charger.

That said, there are other potential issues with the batteries, i.e., do they retain the same charging efficiency over time?  How well are any energy recovery systems working over time?

Given that a normal car battery has a mean life of about 3 yrs, it wouldn't surprise me at all if the charging efficiency has dropped over the time that you've owned the car, particularly since the battery in a hybrid potentially works much harder than a car battery.

TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies

RE: Prius Mileage

There's been some interesting observations on the effect of decreasing battery capacity on mpg. Turns out, not so much.

The reason is that unless you play silly biggers a new Prius keeps the battery in a 20% band for SoC, so possibly as capacity decreases it widens this band or the reduced capacity is still enough.

The calibrators are very careful to avoid putting too much into the battery, as they are well aware that the 'round trip' efficiency of that is only 60%. Much better to avoid generating that power until you need it.

Cheers

Greg Locock

I rarely exceed 1.79 x 10^12 furlongs per fortnight

RE: Prius Mileage

My late father in law bought a Prius and had similar concerns about disappointing gas mileage. He cured the fault by buying a BMW 1 series diesel. Big improvement.

RE: Prius Mileage

Gosh, did going from 40 mpg to 50 mpg really make a big difference to his lifestyle? That 1 oz of fuel per mile must be a very important one.

/Sarcasm mode off/ Small changes in fuel consumption have a tiny effect on running costs, in no way compensating for the financial (or even environmental) inefficiency involved in buying a different car. There is very little overall gain in getting a Prius driver to upgrade to a 60 mpg car, the big savings in oil are getting the 12-17 mpg SUV driver into a 35 mpg car.

 

Cheers

Greg Locock

I rarely exceed 1.79 x 10^12 furlongs per fortnight

RE: Prius Mileage

Sarcasm is a prime ingredient in life and, life is good...

I found THE fuel (automotive expense) saving device...RETIREMENT! <snicker>

My 'automotive expense' (ins., fuel, maintenance, finance chgs. and payments, etc.) has dropped from <$1400/mnth in the 1990's to $338 last month !!!!!!!!!!!

Rod

RE: Prius Mileage

(OP)
OK...

After 5000 miles, I'm going in for the next service today and the average mileage is just under 45 mpg, three to four mpg lower than the two previous winters, and we have had a very mild January here.  Should be higher.

I'll post what they say.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
Motto:  KISS
Motivation:  Don't ask

RE: Prius Mileage

(OP)
Well, the mechanic said that they have been receiving a lot of mileage complaints recently, and they attribute it to the gas mixture changes.  Said it had nothing to do with the 60,000 mile service.  Hard for me to believe.

Nevertheless, if this is so, then we are all getting cheaper gas under the guise of reduced emissions, and paying more for it in both the short and the long run.  Seems to me, over the last three years, that the percentage of ethanol additive is directly related to the percentage decrease in mileage.  Having to drive the same number of miles, I fail to see the emissions benefit to the environment.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
Motto:  KISS
Motivation:  Don't ask

RE: Prius Mileage

The corn growing agri-businesses love it.  It has nothing to do with emissions.  

RE: Prius Mileage

I think theoretically via energy content calculations, 10% ethanol equals 3% less energy per unit of volume at the pump so if thermal efficiency remains constant you could get a 3% drop in fuel economy.

I get anecdotal evidence that refutes this, but anecdotal is not really reliable and it is quite possible that different engines and especially different FI systems respond differently to the change and I would think you could expect anything from no change to about 5% increase in fuel used for 10% ethanol.

Regards
Pat
See FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on use of eng-tips by professional engineers &
http://eng-tips.com/market.cfm
for site rules
 

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources