Transformer energization harmonics
Transformer energization harmonics
(OP)
I have a customer asking us to directly connect a 11kV 5MVAR capacitor bank with filter reactor tuned to 4.8pu to a 20MVA transformer breaker. The transformer is feeding a submerged arc furnace. The capacitor bank will therefore energize at the same time as the transformer.
They don't want to fork out the extra money for the additional capacitor bank breaker and control. I have a feeling the transformer energization harmonics will cause the tuned filter to amplify the harmonics below the 5th to a point where they damage the capacitors.
I have suggested another breaker so when the transformer is switched on the cap bank only comes in after 1 min to negate the first few cycles harmonics on the Tx, but as stated before money is a problem.
Has anyone had any experience with this sort of problem and can anyone tell me what the expected harmonic magnitudes are on transformer magnetization?
They don't want to fork out the extra money for the additional capacitor bank breaker and control. I have a feeling the transformer energization harmonics will cause the tuned filter to amplify the harmonics below the 5th to a point where they damage the capacitors.
I have suggested another breaker so when the transformer is switched on the cap bank only comes in after 1 min to negate the first few cycles harmonics on the Tx, but as stated before money is a problem.
Has anyone had any experience with this sort of problem and can anyone tell me what the expected harmonic magnitudes are on transformer magnetization?






RE: Transformer energization harmonics
Alan
"The engineer's first problem in any design situation is to discover what the problem really is." Unk.
RE: Transformer energization harmonics
Transformer inrush consists of high second harmonics and a high dc component. They probably won't cause a problem with a filter tuned to 4.8 times fundamental.
The inrush is on the primary, so if the capacitor is on the secondary, there will be no problem.
Arc furnaces have very high 2nd and 3rd harmonics, so the filter tuned to 4.8 may not be that effective. The 3rd harmonics will not be blocked by delta windings, because the phases are not balanced.
RE: Transformer energization harmonics
Alan
"The engineer's first problem in any design situation is to discover what the problem really is." Unk.
RE: Transformer energization harmonics
The capacitor bank is on the primary of the transformer. Have being trying to model with Etap and LT spice but done have enough info regarding the inrush harmonics to transformers
RE: Transformer energization harmonics
Is not seems good, direct connection of capacitor bank on the transformer primary.
From my point of view, is unpossible provide model of harmonics of transformer inrush current. Is depend on the constraction of this transfromer too.
Best Regards.
Slava
RE: Transformer energization harmonics
If you have so called "single tuned" filter, and looks like you do, it will actually amplify harmonics of order lower than filter's tuned frequency (during inrush or later), because of capacitive nature of filter on that frequencies. Filter needs to be tuned at the lowest harmonic in load spectrum. So, it looks to me that you have at least two problems, transformer inrush with cap connected, and incorrectly tuned filter.
RE: Transformer energization harmonics
I would at least provide fuses in cap circuit and then it will be safe to try it out.
Rafiq Bulsara
http://www.srengineersct.com
RE: Transformer energization harmonics
Depending on how many breaker operations the transformer is expected to go through in a lifetime, you will likely not need to add any attachments. The blade and arcing horn of an airswitch can take a fair amount of abuse so the arcing will only be a problem if it is going to be operated multiple times a year.
Also, you wouldn't need a separate cap or breaker control, since the airswitch takes several seconds to close and open. If directly connected to the local trip and close of the breaker, the airswitch would engage the capacitor bank after the harmonics have smoothed out and would open after the breaker has already cleared the cicuit.
If there is a concern regarding recloser switching, the might not be an option.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
If it is broken, fix it. If it isn't broken, I'll soon fix that.
RE: Transformer energization harmonics
dc - 378A
fundamental - 352A
2nd harm - 166A
3rd harm - 86A
5th harm - 59A
7th harm - 46A
Horizontal scale on the graph is cycles from start of the record.
Hope this helps.
RE: Transformer energization harmonics
We don't seem to have any problems when the breaker closes, but there are significant currents and voltages when the breaker opens. The filter's capacitors seem to discharge through the delta windings of the isolation transformer creating voltage surges on the secondary that damaged the drive input surge arrestors and SCR's. We have recorded surges to 1.9 p.u. Volts RMS lasting about 20 cycles. (We haven't been able to capture the peak or instantaneous voltage spikes.)
The solution is to add more surge arrestors and a contactor to disconnect the filter before the breaker opens.
RE: Transformer energization harmonics
jghrist, thanks your graph is going to help me develop a Etap model to fully test the system before we advise the client. I have a feeling that we are going to play it safe and tell the client it is not advisable to install without any form of contactor or air switch to delay the switching on and off of the bank.
RE: Transformer energization harmonics
One of the solution to avoid switching transients (harmonics, overvoltages, etc) is to use controlled switching. So, we can "kill" the inrush current just closing the circuit breaker at the right point on voltage wave and, also, open the breaker at the right point.
To do that, it is necessary to study and understand exactly the phenomena involved, and use a device (that is commertially available) to control the instant of breaker closing/openning.
Best regards,
H. Bronzeado
RE: Transformer energization harmonics
Theoretically this sounds plausible, but I can imagine many practical difficulties. Do you know of a control system that can accomplish this?
Alan
"The engineer's first problem in any design situation is to discover what the problem really is." Unk.
RE: Transformer energization harmonics
Yes, there are some devices that can accomplish this.
I have used one of them to mitigate the inrush current of a 100 MVA, 230/138 kV and I have been successful. I will attach a paper of my experience on that.
Regarding the issue raised by KJLRSA, if the transformer inrush current is killed (or significantly reduced), part of the problem will be solved. Of course, as you said, there will be some practical difficulties but nothing that engineering could not solve.
Best regards,
Herivelto Bronzeado
RE: Transformer energization harmonics
I'd be worried about OV, after the energizing, if transformer is unloaded.
RE: Transformer energization harmonics
Please, have a look in the paper "Harmonic Analysis of Transient Currents During Sympathetic Interaction", 1996 IEEE PES Winter Meeting, paper 96 WM 288-1 PWRS, Baltimore, USA, Jan. 1996.
By BRONZEADO H. S., BROGAN P. and YACAMINI R.
Best regards,
Herivelto
RE: Transformer energization harmonics
Yes, it is necessary to measure the residual flux in the transformer to see what is the better instant to close the breaker. This is done just integrating the decaying voltage when the transformer is deenergized.
Then, we have to adjust the exact time to send the order to close the breaker, taking into account the arc time and breaker pole time delays.
Best regards,
H. Bronzeado
RE: Transformer energization harmonics
Alan
"The engineer's first problem in any design situation is to discover what the problem really is." Unk.
RE: Transformer energization harmonics
http://elcon.se/Breaker_testing/Switchsync.htm
And from ABB, go here and download the attachment.
http://s
Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter
RE: Transformer energization harmonics
I'm not sure that this technology can be applied to a standard 3-pole breaker that has one operating mechanism for all three phases. It also was quite expensive in technician time to get all the settings correct.
RE: Transformer energization harmonics
In the case of a standard 3-pole breaker that has just one operating mechanism for all three phases, I think it will be possible to adjust it, mechanically, to "simulate" a single phase mechanism, giving the necessary closing delay.
best regards,
Herivelto Bronzeado