×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Working for a contract service
4

Working for a contract service

Working for a contract service

(OP)
A contract engineering company has a position I'm interested in. I've interviewed with the placement service, and am interviewing with the actual company next week. They provide vacation based on hours worked, and paid holidays, but insurance is optional, and the employee pays all of it, although thru a groupl plan, which isn't as bad as going out on my own and getting it. The wage they are offering is barely enough to break even to what i make now (less than I'd like also) once I have to pay my families own health insurance. It's also a bit further to drive into the city, versus away from the city. I'm pretty sure once I interview, I'll get the offer. My question is, in your experience, how much room do these service leave for negotiation? A couple more dollars an hour would be enough for me. Are they willing to take a little less off the top in order to get the person placed that the company wants? Another thought is the company could "buy me out" and hire me as a permenant employee. They have "want" ads on their website, so evidently are hiring on their own also.
I really want this job, as I think there's more of a future there than where I am now.
Any advice folks?

David

RE: Working for a contract service

Before you take insurance through your contract agency, go to an insurance agent and get quotes for your own.  You'll have the advantage of staying insured if you continue to contract through other agencies.

I went through my personal agent and got a major medical policy for my family for less than $350/month.  High deductible ($5k/person, $10K max family per year), but with some good options.  Included a HSA (Health Savings Account), which means tax-deductible deposits which are available forever until spent.  Also, policy covered 100% of everything after deductible (it's the 80-20 that can break you if you lose a leg or get a tumor).

RE: Working for a contract service

I negotiated up a few dollars when I was working for a contract service in 05/06.  However, this was at least in part because the guy that would be my manager at the company really wanted me so basically told the contract place to increase my rate.

As Tick says, double check on the private insurance thing, it's not always as bad as you think.  We looked into it a few years ago and were surprised.

Posting guidelines FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies http://eng-tips.com/market.cfm? (probably not aimed specifically at you)
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?

RE: Working for a contract service

David,

People generally choose "job shopping" because of significantly higher income. Earning 20% - 40% more as a job shopper is very common and the only reason to do it. So if you crunched the numbers and aren't impressed, don't take the job! (Keep in mind that frequently places that are hiring job shoppers have a ton of short term work. You're highly likely to get overtime.)

If you want more money, ask for it. The contract house will then ask the company for more money. The decision will lie with the company you'll be working for rather than the contract house.


 

RE: Working for a contract service

Like a lot of financial decisions, also consider risk/reward.  If you don't get a significant increase in take home pay from a contract, it is rarely worth it unless there is some special experience you intend to obtain while on the contract.

The risk you always have to keep in mind is any hiccup in the company cash flow or financial numbers and you are on your way out the door.

Also remember that being shown the door as a contractor rarely is a personal thing but is almost always an impersonal business decision.  So if you take the risk and they let you go much more quickly than you were led to believe, it is still not likely that you were deficient but the company financial picture changed.  (Unless of course you are an incompetent jerk and they only discovered this after you reported in :) Joking...)

The bottom line for me (I did contract engineering for ten years at various locations) was if I was going to take the risk such as move to unfamiliar area, pay my own insurance, accept that at any time I could instantly be shown the door, then I expected to do a lot better than just break even before I signed on.

I hope this helps...  

RE: Working for a contract service

When I went from salaried to contract (self employed using a 1099), I took a 50% pay increase from my equivalent salaried hourly rate. Anything less than that and it really would not have been worth my while. As it stands I went back to salaried at yet another company when the bottom fell out of the oil market, but I only took a 22% hit in pay.

Quickest way to move up is to move  

Always remember, free advice is worth exactly what you pay for it!   

RE: Working for a contract service

When I left a direct position after I got my degree (and the company I worked for had a hiring and promotion freeze), I more than doubled my hourly rate. That was in the late 80's though and included some effect due to the degree. Breaking even, I would not consider it unless you had a good sense you would be made a good offer as a direct (at least what you are making now plus something for the additional time and stress of commuting. I would definatly ask for the amount you need to pay for the insureance at least.

Peter Stockhausen
Senior Design Analyst (Checker)
Infotech Aerospace Services
www.infotechpr.net

RE: Working for a contract service

Go for the interview.

If you really do wow the guy and get an offer you will be in a position to negotiate from a position of relative strength.

If you don't like the numbers, don't take the job.

Alternately, if they really are hiring direct, apply direct - BEFORE you interview through the contract company.  The hiring company probably has some limitations on direct hiring candidates that the contract company presents.

RE: Working for a contract service

Just check on if the contract agency submitted you before you try on your own for a direct job. I lost out on one job I was interested where that occured, as the company was not sure what I wanted. I wanted a direct job, but I was not working and would have taken it either way. At times, just the floating of your name by the contract agency can keep you from getting in direct, or thru a different agency.

Peter Stockhausen
Senior Design Analyst (Checker)
Infotech Aerospace Services
www.infotechpr.net

RE: Working for a contract service

(OP)
Thanks for all the advice. I'm shopping around for insurance, and will most likely "Wow" the employer, so probably will ask for a little more money also.
This site is great.

David

RE: Working for a contract service

Be very careful with Mints suggestion, it may depend on what, if any, agreement you already have in place with the agency and what agreement the agency has in place with the company.  However, typcially once an agency is involved, they want their pound of flest.

Posting guidelines FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies http://eng-tips.com/market.cfm? (probably not aimed specifically at you)
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?

RE: Working for a contract service

I agree with KENAT.  If you got the lead through the contract agency, they will want their cut, and will usually fight to get it.  The client may also take their side on the issue.

"Good to know you got shoes to wear when you find the floor." - Robert Hunter
 

RE: Working for a contract service

Best bet if you get an offer that is contract to direct is to assume it is just a contract. Only take the job if it is worth leaving the one you have. Include in that calculation a month or two (bare minimum in this economy) without work at the end of the contract. This means that to make it worth while it should pay a good deal more than you are making now. A couple of bucks an hour is not enough in my opinion. Unless you are unhappy where you are.

Peter Stockhausen
Senior Design Analyst (Checker)
Infotech Aerospace Services
www.infotechpr.net

RE: Working for a contract service

(OP)
So, my interview is today. They agreed to meet me after hours, which I think is a good thing. Shows they show more than a passing interest in me. I think I will "Wow" them, as the product they produce is very similar to what I have experience with. I've got a kick-butt portfolio with me. I'll take all of your suggestions to heart. Thanks!

David

RE: Working for a contract service

(OP)
Interview went well. I've got all the skills and experience he is looking for. Looking forward to hearing from the contract service today. Noticed when looking back at the initial email it said they were wanting to pay in the $xx.xx RANGE. I'm betting that's the low end of the range. I think I'll likely get the $$ I want, and maybe even try for a week paid for my kids spring break.
He also indicated he is looking for a full time employee, but used the service to weed thru the hundreds of resumes for him. It'll be 3 months contract, then permenent if it goes well.

David

RE: Working for a contract service

(OP)
Well, I got the offer this morning, and made my counteroffer quoting her word "payrange". She wasn't happy, but said she'd talk to her client. Haven't heard back from her, and I'm sure she's gone home for the day by now. The client was leaving town today, so hopefully, she's just having trouble getting hold of him. Kindof nervous. I've always job hunted because I was out of work, so this is a new experience for me.

David

RE: Working for a contract service

(OP)
Well, I lost out... They gave the position to someone else. Kicking myself now.

David

RE: Working for a contract service

(OP)
I'm going to call the employer direct Monday. I think some things got lost in translation with the staffing company. I expected a call giving more specifics of how long the contract was expected to last, benefits and such of the company, etc... Am pretty upset about how everything ended up going down.

David

RE: Working for a contract service

while not fully aware of the communications involved . . .

naw . . . do not dwell on the matter further . . . i would not recommend calling.  it is a risk that is taken when requesting for more $.

are you sure they selected another individual?

believe me, there are other opportunities out there and you need not dwell on your decisions . . . only learn from them.

lastly, listen & trust your instincts!  they will benefit you greatly with future decisions.

good luck!
-pmover

RE: Working for a contract service

I really don't see the point in going back to them.

If they wanted you enough, they would have paid what you wanted.

If you wanted the job enough, you would have taken their offer.

That is how negotiations work.
 

RE: Working for a contract service

(OP)
But yea, You guys are probably right about not calling them.
I shouldv'e handled it differently. I'm not, however, a professional job hunter. I listened to the experts, and it backfired. I at least was expecting a counter-offer, or a "No... This is all we can pay" though, with maybe something in writing as to what I'll get if hired full time in the future.
I think the ol' "never take the first offer" motto doesn't apply in todays job market. It's an employers market.
Anyone reading this, heed my warning. Be ready for the rejection if asking for more money!

David

RE: Working for a contract service

David I feel you have been incredibly naive here thinking that everything would be on your terms in the current economic climate and being surprised that asking for more money might result in rejection.

Not sure what "experts" you listened too but they do not seem that smart to me.
 

RE: Working for a contract service

(OP)
ajack1... Yea... Like I said. Every other time I've been job hunting it's been out of necessity because I was unemployed, so took what they offered. I guess I was too optimistic thinking I could get just a little more.

David

RE: Working for a contract service

Unfortunatly you also had the Contract Service lady in the middle adding her own "spin" I assume.

My experience with this type of company has not been too pleasant, basically they are about one small step above used car salesmen, Wall Street Bankers, and lawyers.

this message has been approved for citizen to elect kepharda 2008

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources