×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

MV Motor damage but VCB not trip

MV Motor damage but VCB not trip

MV Motor damage but VCB not trip

(OP)
any guru,

I am facing the problem that

MV (6.6 kV) motor (1250 kVA) of compressor broken but VCB didn't trip.
The VCB was opened by operator when they hear big noise and vibration.


our Setting is

Motor start time = 9 s

Lock rotor relay;
= 300% In
t= 9s

50 Relay;
I=8.5 In
t=15 ms

49 TOL;
I=250
t=1.3 s

Unbalance relay

How about setting of 51LR lock rotor relay (REF 542+)?
Is it too lond time for 9s?
What is normal practic for 51LR setting?
Why VCB didn't trip before motor damaged ?


Thanks for your answer

young eng.

RE: MV Motor damage but VCB not trip

Did the noise occur upon start?  How long after start?   Was the machine observed to rotate during start?

What was found upon investigation after shutting the machine down?

Any electrical problems.  megger test results sat?  winding resistance equal?  Visual inspection of end turns?  

Mechanical checks:  machine rotates smoothly by hand?  What type of bearings?

What is it that you meant by "motor damage"?

We don't really know enough to have a clue yet but it is certainly possible you have a mechanical problem that did not yet progress to an electrical problem.  The machine may have come up to speed drawing normal current but just making a lot of noise.

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: MV Motor damage but VCB not trip

Did you have any "targets" on any relays?

RE: MV Motor damage but VCB not trip

JED057- please elaborate more on sequence of events leading to damage, attach pictures. etc. and explain in detail what was the damage i.e. mechanical-bearing failure, or motor winding short-failure. Has the motor been checked for forensics?

Assuming all the settings are correct: If compressor motor experienced overheat(overload)Device 49 should have picked up to protectct. If single-phasing was the issue, unbalnce relay would pickup.  Main breaker would pickup on instantanious or short circuit fault. But, none of them did. I'm wondering if this motor had experienced any other issues in the past!!!was it equipped with phase-winding RTD's for motor protection? how is the quaility of incoming service? was there winding failure on one phase or all 3-phase.

 

Providing power quality solutions that empowers you!!!

RE: MV Motor damage but VCB not trip

I think the first thing to figure out is , did the breaker not trip when a relay told it to or not. Either a breaker issue or a relay issue.  

RE: MV Motor damage but VCB not trip

I had already ASSumed no relay trip, otherwise why would he be asking about relay settings?
Guess we'll all have to wait and let him figure out what's the first thing to figure out winky smile
 

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: MV Motor damage but VCB not trip

I'd start looking into the relay operation and the connections first.  Did you test the relay to verify that it operates properly?  Did you test the relay connection to the breaker to verify it in fact trips the machine?  I can think of several instances where somebody forgot to reconnect the trip command after testing a relay.

------------------------------------------------------------------------
If it is broken, fix it.  If it isn't broken, I'll soon fix that.

RE: MV Motor damage but VCB not trip

What exactly was 'broken' in the motor ?

Muthu
www.edison.co.in

RE: MV Motor damage but VCB not trip

Quote:

What exactly was 'broken' in the motor?

It could very well be the driven load as well and the motor is just fine. That's pretty typical behavior in my workshop sad   

RE: MV Motor damage but VCB not trip

Over current is not the only reason or effect when a motor fails. Motor can fail due to mechanical reasons too.

These type of events can only be correctly analyzed by having someone experienced/knowledgeable on site.

 

Rafiq Bulsara
http://www.srengineersct.com

RE: MV Motor damage but VCB not trip

"MV (6.6 kV) motor (1250 kVA) of compressor broken but VCB didn't trip.
The VCB was opened by operator when they hear big noise and vibration."

It may NOT be the motor at all.  I've made a lot of good money over the years determining that the motor and breaker were okay but there were problems with the mechanical stuff people insist on hanging off the end of the motor shaft.

If possible, disconnect the motor and turn the shaft by hand.  It should be possible with this size motor.  That will give you some idea about loud noise and vibration.  If the motor turns freely, you might want to get your mechanical folks to check your mechanical load.

If the shaft will turn by hand, then do some simple electrical tests on the motor to eliminate possible insulation failures.

If you've had previous correct operation of the protective relays, you might want to do a start with the motor uncoupled.  If you suspect incorrect operation of the protection and controls, this is a good time to test these things thoroughly, then test run.

old field guy

RE: MV Motor damage but VCB not trip

Quote:

It may NOT be the motor at all.  I've made a lot of good money over the years determining that the motor and breaker were okay but there were problems with the mechanical stuff people insist on hanging off the end of the motor shaft.
If we could just stop people from connecting mechanical stuff to our motors, they'd all run just fine. winky smile

RE: MV Motor damage but VCB not trip

PHovnanian--

That's pretty much my take on the situation, but I'd be just as happy if they'd just be able to have an equipment failure where I don't have to out there and prove beyond a shadow of a doubt that it's NOT electrical.

Case in point:  Production supervisor calls me.  His blower is tripping off on overload.  It had previously been in service twenty years with no problems.  Now it's tripping on overload.  

My first question:  Has there been any work done on the blower recently.  His answer:  Yes, just came back from rework.

I told him that motors don't suddenly develop a 25% overload and that he needed to make sure the shop hadn't installed a larger impeller.  The names and insinuations I received for suggesting such a thing weren't nice.

I did the complete battery of tests:  Insulation, winding resistance, test runs for current balance and voltage problems, monitored real and reactive power.  Everything pointed to a normal motor with a bit too much mechanical load.  I wrote up the report and let them have it.  No motor problem.

A month or so later I asked one of the mechanical people about the blower.  "You didn't hear? " he said?  "The shop put the wrong impeller in it when they rebuilt it.  They took it back and fixed it."

And the guy who was happy to tell me **I** needed to stick with electrical stuff and let HIM take care of the process equipment has yet to tell me that he was wrong.

So to the original poster of this thread, take heed.  You need to look at the whole system.

old field guy

RE: MV Motor damage but VCB not trip

Pretty hard to beat a man at his own game, huh!  When you are wrong they are always quick to let you know, but when you are ocassionally right, you don't hear anything.

Alan

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources