×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Flat Spiral spring design

Flat Spiral spring design

Flat Spiral spring design

(OP)
Hi, I want to make a flat circular spiral spring which will be laser cut from sheet stainless steel and I need the spring constant to be the same horizontally as vertically.  It is supporting a mass of about 1.25kg for a deflection of around 3 to 5mm.  I also need to know about linearity and whether this would behave like a Belville spring or be more linear than that.  The spiral doesn't need to be like a clock spring and I envisage four or so links from the perimeter to the centre.  Thanks in advance.

RE: Flat Spiral spring design

A sketch might help.  When you say vertically, do you mean perpendicular to the plane of the sheet?  Is horizontal the same as parallel to the plane of the sheet?  4 links from rim to center - each of these is a continuous spiral?

RE: Flat Spiral spring design

(OP)
"do you mean perpendicular to the plane of the sheet?"  Yes, thanks, that is what I should have written.  And therefore the same for the horizontal, too.

I don't quite have a mental image of the plan of the spring as viewed from above.  It will probably have four fixing holes on the rim, each with a spiral going to a single centre, load bearing, fixing hole.  The question is probably whether these go round (concentrically) a half turn, one turn or two turns or maybe more.  I just haven't seen any literature beyond looking at them as leaf springs that describes the horizontal motion.  Part of me thinks that there may need to be three or so parallel springs on each arm in order to avoid twisting in the horizontal plane - particularly if there is a pre load deflection.

Incidentally, my starting point for thickness was likely to be about 1.6mm (or an old-fashioned 1/16th).



 

RE: Flat Spiral spring design

I guess I'd try using a FEA program.  Standard coil spring design criteria could get you close, but only if +/- 25% for the horizontal load case "spring constant" is close enough.  And the conversion from coiled wire springs to rectangular sections is non-trivial, thus my first recommendation.

RE: Flat Spiral spring design

(OP)
"Conversion to rectangular section is non-trivial."  Oh dear.  I was going to go assume it was easier, though I did have some doubts about, say, an identical vertical and horizontal displacement adding up to root two, especially with it working across the hypotenuse of the section.

Is your instinct to use a proper spring?  It won't look quite as pretty but if it is going to be difficult - and linearity is also an issue because the dynamic behaviour is paramount - then I am quite happy to accept that this a task that is beyond my expertise (or at least the expertise needed to do it neatly).Thanks for your help so far.

RE: Flat Spiral spring design

No, I think you can get there, but you'll need to do the number crunching, or get somebody with FEA capabilities to do it for you.

RE: Flat Spiral spring design

(OP)
Thanks Megabill.  That looks a really useful site but probably  for another time as I'm trying to do a spring out of a sheet (probably now carbon rather than s/s).  It is a spiral, though I'm still no further ahead on it.

Best

Christian Thomas

RE: Flat Spiral spring design

ChristianThomas

What you are looking for is probably impossible with the four/three link arranged from the center disk to the outer disk. This kind of spring is usually for out of the plane movement. Those springs are linear as long as the deflection is small. Radial deflection is a problem because the opposite links are "fighting". One link is tensioned and the opposite link is compressed. More than that, the radial rate will be different for different orientation with respect to the links.

What are your space restrictions?

RE: Flat Spiral spring design

(OP)
The discs are almost certainly going to be 1.6mm carbon plate with a diameter of 60mm and a static deflection of about 5mm for a force of 12.5N.  It should be quite well damped so I wouldn't expect dynamic displacement of more than 3mm or so.

There are actually two of these springs with an annulus in between.

Thanks for your points.  I hadn't actually noted that radially the springs would effectively be in parallel (or fighting).  Would the radial rate vary with orientation or does the trigonometry take care of that?

Christian

RE: Flat Spiral spring design

Hi ChristianThomas

I think you would be better if you could provide a sketch, you can see clearly what you want but its more difficult for us to imagine.
What I will say is you can't just pick a diameter and thickness of spring and then expect it to deflect 3mm under a 12.5N load without doing calculations, otherwise as israelkk says it won't work.

desertfox

RE: Flat Spiral spring design

(OP)
Hi Erwin and others

Here is a very rough sketch of what it might look like.  The spirals could go round further, or more than once, but this is the basic outline (and the easiest to draw).

As to just picking a thickness the structure would seem to be the dominant factor here.  The deflection as a solid disc would be about a tenth of what I'm after and as a plain single spiral (Ie fairly normal spring) one could easily make it extend four or five times the 3mm.  Where one may need to optimise the thickness, towards the end, is in lateral displacement.

RE: Flat Spiral spring design

Hi ChristianThomas

Can you make a pdf of your uploaded file its a dxf at present which makes it difficult to open.

desertfox

RE: Flat Spiral spring design

(OP)
Hi desertfox

I can't do that at home for some reason, but I can do it when I get into work tomorrow.

RE: Flat Spiral spring design

Hi ChristianThomas

Thanks for the pdf, I have never seen a spring like that before, what does it look like in the other plane?
I can't honestly see how your sketch would work like a spring.

desertfox

RE: Flat Spiral spring design

(OP)
It's not fantastically clear and one has to imagine an annulus at the centre and at the rim onto which each of the curved ribs attaches.  It was very quickly drawn and I couldn't easily get the compound curve that I ideally wanted.

By way of explanation in this instance it is effectively 8 leaves.  Lateral compliance (not much in this drawing but one can extrapolate) comes from the thinner sections of the leaves.

The other plane is just a 1.6mm plate.

Christian

RE: Flat Spiral spring design

So when its loaded it extends downward in the plane of the 1.6mm plate I assume, but how do the leaves move relative to each other? I assume one leaf overlaps the adjacent one.
Truthfully I have no idea how to analyise your sketch and I am not sure its a practical proposition, have you spoken to any springmakers because that I feel would be your best bet.

desertfox

RE: Flat Spiral spring design

I think megabill should rescind his statement about FEA not being applicable to YOUR spring form.  I think it's your only way forward.  You might be able to analyse it using Roark's formulas for curved beams, but by the time you get about halfway thru that tangled web, you will be looking hard for some FEA capability.

RE: Flat Spiral spring design

I am going to have to back you up a step - do you need this spring to also resist torsional moments (i.e. rocking of the part about an axis parallel to the plane of the sheet)?

RE: Flat Spiral spring design

This is not a common spring for spring makers. It is basically a solid one piece disk made of thin strip with reliefs that creates the leaves. The leaves are all connected in the center of the disk and the outer of the disk. This is commonly called flexure (disc) spring. They are mainly used to support free vibrating pistons in such applications as in Stirling mini cryocoolers. The disks function as flexure bearings to support and guide the piston on both sides to make it friction-free and at the same time they are used as loading/damping springs. They are usually manufactured by chemically etching. Such spring are mainly designed using FEA.

See fig. 5 in the following document http://www.waset.org/journals/waset/v56/v56-50.pdf

or

http://mydocs.epri.com/docs/public/000000000001007317.pdf fig. A-16 Stirling Technology Company – Flexural Bearings on page A-54 (page 128 of the document)

RE: Flat Spiral spring design

Hi israelkk

Good document, I understand the spring in the document you reference however I cannot see how the OP's sketch fits in with it.
The OP sketch appears to have overlapping leaves and not just a single piece of material chemically etched out or have I misunderstood.

regards

desertfox

RE: Flat Spiral spring design

(OP)
Hi all,

Israel has it right, and the leaves don't overlap.  The idea is to create a cheap (ie. with water jet cutting or laser cut) and compact spring which is internally well damped.  A spring in steel with a nominal resonance with the supported mass of about 10Hz would have self resonances in the 120Hz region.  Here the hope is that if one can push that self resonance up high enough (and nominally it should double being 1/4 of the mass) then the damping of the matrix should keep it controlled.

The spring in the strimmer handle could be equally practical - and a lot easier to draw.

That could also address the torsion question.  Although I don't foresee any direct torsional loads - this is part of an isolation mechanism - it is not beyond the realms of possibility that some sort of couple could arise.  My shape of cuts wouldn't probably be very good at this without some deformation.

It would also seem to point to a greater thickness and more cuts.

Christian

RE: Flat Spiral spring design

(OP)
I see on Jacob's stirling engine that they use this design in order to *avoid* radial movement.  I, of course, want it.  I can see how it serves their purpose with the wide leaves.  It seems it may have to get more complicated.

C

RE: Flat Spiral spring design

Okay Christian

I misread your sketch, but the spring israelkk posted acts as a spring in the radial plane, your talking about it acting as a spring at 90 degrees to its 1.6mm thickness unless I have misunderstood.
I doubt you will get 3 to 5mm deflection of your spring by cutting leaves in a flat plate as you yourself have said a solid disc as only about one tenth this deflection.
I think you need to get it FEA programme on this to get any meaningful answer as indicated by others.

desertfox

RE: Flat Spiral spring design

(OP)
Yes, FEA is probably the only way.  Another concern is linearity, meaning that to some extent it is like a Belville spring and, if one isn't careful - or lucky - one will start to tug along the length of the material.  Ie run out of things to flex.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources