Enclosure heat losses
Enclosure heat losses
(OP)
I have (7) enclosures going to a site in Kentucky along the Ohio river. The enclosures are 36"D x 72"W x 72"H and are fabricated aluminum skinned enclosures with an open bottom. We will have water pipes inside which are critical so we need to place a heater in each enclosure. I am trying to accurately calculate what I can expect for required heat.
The bottom of the enclosures which are bolted to a concrete slab will have and open bottom (30" x 60") which may radiant some ground temperature into the box. The enclosures are insulated with 1" thick sheet insulation boards.
Can anyone suggest a calculation or a website that offers calcs to figure this out.
I know that good design will consist of a large safety factor and cycling the heater. I had an engineer tell me today that it would take 500W continuously at 0F outdoors to maintain 32F inside the enclosure. I think this is a bit extreme. I was estimating about 150-200W.
Thanks,
The bottom of the enclosures which are bolted to a concrete slab will have and open bottom (30" x 60") which may radiant some ground temperature into the box. The enclosures are insulated with 1" thick sheet insulation boards.
Can anyone suggest a calculation or a website that offers calcs to figure this out.
I know that good design will consist of a large safety factor and cycling the heater. I had an engineer tell me today that it would take 500W continuously at 0F outdoors to maintain 32F inside the enclosure. I think this is a bit extreme. I was estimating about 150-200W.
Thanks,





RE: Enclosure heat losses
TTFN
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
RE: Enclosure heat losses
RE: Enclosure heat losses
RE: Enclosure heat losses
Thanks,
RE: Enclosure heat losses
Q=UAdT
Q=0.44W/m2K x 11.7m2 x 17.8K
Q~90W
Your insulation value seemed high so I threw in one of my own. Probably a couple hundred w the base and losses.
RE: Enclosure heat losses
total area = 11.7m^2, assuming/ignoring open bottom
thk = 1 in
assume still air htc = 2.5 W/m^2-K
solve:
dT1 + dT2 = 42°F
htc*area*dt1 = tc*area*dT2/thk
dT1 = 14.4°F dT2 = 27.6°F
Q = htc*area*dT1 = 234 W
I specifically chose a net dT of 42°F, but that's still marginal if the objective is to prevent condensation or icing, since your original target of 32°F is just at freezing. There are inherent errors in thermistors/thermocouples, unknown moisture content, ignored thermal radiation losses, etc.
Nonetheless, we can see that anything below 234W is on the hairy edge of being insufficient.
A semi worst-case estimate of radiation to the night sky puts it at about 246 W, so 500 W is pretty much spot on:
radiation area.rad = top +0.2*sides = 2.68 m^2
sigma*area.rad*[(275K)^4-(253K)^4] = 246 W
246W + 234W = 480 W, with dT1 = 1.77°F and dT2 = 40.2°F
TTFN
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies