×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Fully Welded Truss

Fully Welded Truss

Fully Welded Truss

(OP)
Folks,
Can a truss with CJP welds between the diagonals and the chords still be analyzed with diagonals being pin-ended members?

For example, the chords are W14 (web-horizontal) and the diagonals are also W14 members with their flanges connected by full penetration welds.

1. Can the truss be analyzed and designed using moment releases at their ends?
2. If the moments at the ends are not released, is it okay to use an effective length factor of 0.65 in their design for compression (assuming a column with fixed ends).

RE: Fully Welded Truss

If you do it both ways I think you'll find there is little difference between fixing the diagonals or pinning them.

RE: Fully Welded Truss

I agree, analyze both ways.

I would not recommend using a K=0.65 since the stiffness of chord may allow too much rotation of the web members. Use K=1.0 for that condition.  

RE: Fully Welded Truss

You might consider increasing the member sizes to something that will yield about 70%-80% of the member capacity and get away from CJP welding... generally less expensive. I try to avoid CJP's like the plague!

Dik

RE: Fully Welded Truss

Slick:
1.    What on earth are you designing here, a new football stadium roof truss, or what?  Does architectural appearance make any difference?  Or, are you analyzing an existing truss?
2.    You should not treat any of the joints as pinned; given the member sizes, joint geometry, and welding you are suggesting, they certainly are not pinned, nor will these heavy members act that way.  We certainly have the computing power to treat this truss like it will really act, and you will need the moments and shears at every joint to design the joint properly.  These are all highly restrained, complex joints, and should be designed that way.  The pinned joint truss has always been a calculation (design) convenience (assumption) which was nice when we were using slide rules or hand held calculators, but you still had to be careful that the truss approximated those assumptions, in action.  These trusses just don't fit that bill.
3.    The top and bot. chords are continuous members in compression and tension with applied moments from the diags.  And the diags. are fixed end members and the magnitude and direction of their end moments leads to the effective length, don't they.  All of these truss members are beam-columns members of one kind or another.
4.    Complete penetration welds are expensive in any case, and doubly so on these skewed joints, thus my question about arch. appearance.  Get your friendly fabricator and welding consultant involved in this early, they will have some ideas about how to make this as practical as possible, without full pen. welds at every web and flange in the joint, many times they are not required, and just lead to problems and extra cost.
5.    Then, what you are talking about probably can't be shipped in one piece either,  so you might end up with some big bolted connections in the t&b chords.
    

RE: Fully Welded Truss

(OP)
Thanks for your responses.
The reason for the question was that I was looking upwards (as I usually do) and in the Miami International Airport, I saw these humongous W14 truss members that were all fully welded and I started wondering how one would have analyzed this truss (using true-pin theory or actual end conditions). Then I started wondering that a truss diagonal with ends fixed might act as a fixed-fixed column warranting the use of a lower K value than the traditional K value of 1.0 for truss members.

RE: Fully Welded Truss

My condolences on being in Miami International Airport!

I analyze "rigid" trusses both ways, but usually stay with the way they are built as to how they will react.  Even multiple bolt connections don't act as pinned, so those have to be analyzed both ways.  This one won't act as a pinned truss as others have said.  I agree with jike...use k=1.0

When you analyze it both ways, the ultimate capacity is close to the same, but individual localized conditions can sometimes vary a lot.

RE: Fully Welded Truss

(OP)
Offer me more condolences for living and working in Miami :)  

RE: Fully Welded Truss

My former employer has an office in Miami, so I've spent plenty of time there.  Was doing a structural inspection once on an elementary school in Liberty City...on the outside of the fence they found a body in the trunk of a car and one was dumped over the fence.  My assistant that day was a young, black Nigerian engineer.  He was scared "s(p)itless".  I pointed out to him that the little kids in the school didn't think anything was abnormal....that didn't give him any comfort.

RE: Fully Welded Truss

i do not know scale of your project, but CJP W14 to W14 sounds like budget of your client is unlimited, may be try (2)C-channels w/equal to W parameters (or many other possibilities) w/ gussets and fillet welding.
classical approach for trusses calculation during good old times was pinned connections, according your explanation about what you have there are no pins just use MC.  
     

RE: Fully Welded Truss

What dhengr said. These are "highly restrained" connections that you describe. These days, ductility at the connection is the thing, especially in LRFD work. See what AISC has to say about highly restrained connections.

Timing has a lot to do with the outcome of a rain dance.

RE: Fully Welded Truss

Ron: Reminds me of the skit by a comedian several years ago. He loves to hang around school yards. He loves to see the children shouting and screaming and running to and fro... They don't know that he's only using blanks!

Dik

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources