×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

mono-grade oil requirement DD two stroke diesels?

mono-grade oil requirement DD two stroke diesels?

mono-grade oil requirement DD two stroke diesels?

(OP)
I'm trying to find out the root reason why Detroit Diesel two stroke engines require, to this day, mono-grade engine oil, normally straight 40 weight.  Empirical evidience, supported by recommendations from DD, is that the engines last longer between rebuilds using straight weight oil in normal service.  I just don't understand why.  what is there about a two stroke application that would make a multi-grade oil, of completely modern and high quality manufacture, less protective in this application?

The "common knowledge" answer seems to be that multi-grades revert to their cold viscosity under the pressure of two stroke compression cycles, that the hydrodynamic layer of oil in the bearings can't recover between power strokes, or that the long-chain molecules used in viscosity modifiers shear and break down.  I just have a hard time lend credence to how a two stroke diesel, with 18:1 compression, running at 2100 rpm is that different from some other high duty engine requirement.

Any ideas?

Thanks for looking,  Brian

RE: mono-grade oil requirement DD two stroke diesels?

Is it possible that this is a requirement developed a long time ago that no one has felt the need to re-visit? If there is little development going on with these engines, there will be little incentive to spend the money testing updated specifications.

RE: mono-grade oil requirement DD two stroke diesels?

I don't mess with any DD's any more, but when I last did about 4 years ago, mono grades and especially 40 wt which was the grade recommended for my climate were getting harder and harder to find.  This was for a bus and you had to take the oil with you because you just couldn't find it in truck stops any more.  And, that meant taking a lot because the beast drank (or blubbered) a gallon every 500 miles (or 10 hrs) which was exactly per the rating in the book.

I did a lot of research and I don't exactly remember what the actual reason was, but the final analysis was that mono grade was the only way to go.

As a personality, I am one that doesn't take no as an answer very well, and I finally threw in the towel on this one.  

I remember one website called "bobistheoilguy" dot com or something like that and there was a Shell site or a site by a Shell technologist, and it was dealt with in both places but alas, mono-grade was the only way to go.

Wish I could offer you some encouragement but I can't.  Sorry.


rmw

RE: mono-grade oil requirement DD two stroke diesels?

A footnote in their "Lubricating Oil, Fuel and Filters" manual allows 15W-40 under certain conditions if it has a HTHS viscosity of at least 3.70 cP.  Sounds like they are concerned about viscosity loss due to temporary shear thinning of the polymeric ingredients, since that's what HTHS vis indicates.   

RE: mono-grade oil requirement DD two stroke diesels?

(OP)
Thanks guys.  the consensus seems indeed to be shear thinning of the viscosity improvers.  What would cause this?  The DD has all accessory drives with gears, no chains, and there are a lot of them.  it's also a two stroke - there are five piston rings and oil squirters for the bottom of the piston.  What is the primary mechanical cause of oil shear?

Brian

RE: mono-grade oil requirement DD two stroke diesels?

Well, generally geared drives are more shear severe than roller chain drives.  Any place there is a high load high speed sliding contact will cause higher shear stress in the fluid.  If there are long chain polymers adding to viscosity they will stretch & compress, reducing their efffective hydrodynamic volume and viscosity contribution (temporary shear loss).  If they get very stressed it will break bonds- statistically somewhere in the middle- leading to shorter, less viscous polymer chains as evidenced by permanent shear viscosity loss of the oil.

For VI improvers, generally both types of shear stability are related to cost.  There are a host of performance & cost levels available today, meaning that a performance-suitable VI improver could probably be incorporated at some additional cost.  Alternatively, multi-vis oils may be prepared without polymeric VI-improvers by utilizing high VI base oils.  If you Google 15W-40 with 6V92TA or MIL-PRF-2104G you will find some multi-vis products claiming to meet both 2-and 4-stroke requirements.

RE: mono-grade oil requirement DD two stroke diesels?

Old aircraft engines are users of mongrade as well.
I better stop there.

RE: mono-grade oil requirement DD two stroke diesels?

Hi Bevans6,

I'm not an expert on this subject, but I have conversed with those who are.  One that comes to mind readily is a John Martin.  He lives in Phoenix and still (I think) consults.  John is an MIT grad that worked years for EMD and then worked the DARPA funded program at Garrett (Honeywell) in Phoenix to build and test a very high performance two stroke diesel.  If you can find him, I think he will have an answer.

My limited understanding is that the boundary lubrication issues at the piston pin slipper bearing demand different lube characteristics than typical hydrodynamic lubes, but mine is only a cursory understanding.

Dick   

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources