1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
(OP)
Hi All,
We have a deep well water pump in our site and we have had more than 5 failures on it now. I am given the task of finding the root cause for the failures and give recommendations of what can be done to prevent future failures.
Here is the Pump Information:
1000 Horse Power Centrilift 725 HMI UT Motor
29 Stage HC3500 Centrilift Pump
4 Bag Sealing Section 6.75 OD
4160v Switch Gear with 469 Multilin Power Management Relay
Load information
Avg Discharge Flows of 1350 GPM
Avg Water Temperature of 95 Degrees Fahrenheit
Background:
I talked with the Electrical Supervisor and he thinks that the pump is being started lot many times ( 8 to 9 starts per day ) and that is the reason it fails. He argues that the pump fills the store water tank quick and so the level sensor shuts the pump. He recommends we do a lake and pump water into that and store so that we have less starts on that pump.
Other argument is that the inrush on the pump would be too high. Right now the pump is started with a DOL starter. Some recommend that we go with a VFD or a Soft starter to start and hence reduce the inrush and increase the number of starts. I think this is good than the lake option.
Also, do anyone have a recommendation of how to measure the sub transient and transient inrush current values of the pump during the start? I want to measure and see how much is the current rise. Wouldnt that help in the appropriation for VFD or soft start?
I know a little about pumps and hence whatever you guys give would be a valuable peice of information for me.
Thanks.
gokul
We have a deep well water pump in our site and we have had more than 5 failures on it now. I am given the task of finding the root cause for the failures and give recommendations of what can be done to prevent future failures.
Here is the Pump Information:
1000 Horse Power Centrilift 725 HMI UT Motor
29 Stage HC3500 Centrilift Pump
4 Bag Sealing Section 6.75 OD
4160v Switch Gear with 469 Multilin Power Management Relay
Load information
Avg Discharge Flows of 1350 GPM
Avg Water Temperature of 95 Degrees Fahrenheit
Background:
I talked with the Electrical Supervisor and he thinks that the pump is being started lot many times ( 8 to 9 starts per day ) and that is the reason it fails. He argues that the pump fills the store water tank quick and so the level sensor shuts the pump. He recommends we do a lake and pump water into that and store so that we have less starts on that pump.
Other argument is that the inrush on the pump would be too high. Right now the pump is started with a DOL starter. Some recommend that we go with a VFD or a Soft starter to start and hence reduce the inrush and increase the number of starts. I think this is good than the lake option.
Also, do anyone have a recommendation of how to measure the sub transient and transient inrush current values of the pump during the start? I want to measure and see how much is the current rise. Wouldnt that help in the appropriation for VFD or soft start?
I know a little about pumps and hence whatever you guys give would be a valuable peice of information for me.
Thanks.
gokul





RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
Is the pump ever started when it is back-spinning? This may be the most probable cause of burnout, but proper setting of the Multilin will give a lot of protection.
The Multilin should give you more information than you need.
In a healthy motor the sub transient and transient currents are to a great extent determined by motor design. Of more interest is the duration of the starting currents.
Have you done any calculations on the starting voltage drop at the motor terminals. The long conductors to the motor, although adequate for running current may be undersized for the starting current. Too much voltage drop when starting may lead to extended start time that may lead to motor burnout.
It should be easy to determine the starting time from the Multilin. Contact the pump or motor manufacturer for their reocmmendations for maximum allowable stating times.
Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
"If I had eight hours to chop down a tree, I'd spend six sharpening my axe." -- Abraham Lincoln
For the best use of Eng-Tips, please click here -> FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
You could refer to the manufacturer in regard to the number of starts, DOL starting etc, but I would suggest that if you have evenly spaced starts, 8 - 9 starts per day is not an issue, neither is DOL starting.
I would be more concerned about insufficient water level above the pump or severely imbalanced or distorted supply.
Best regards,
Mark.
Mark Empson
L M Photonics Ltd
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
rmw
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
Keith Cress
kcress - http://www.flaminsystems.com
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
rmw
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
The numbers do not seem to add up unless it is a very deep well.
I wonder if the problem is related to the pump running backwards? that would explain the low flow and high water temperature.
Many of the submersible pumps that I work with have a maximum winding temperature of around 35 - 45 degrees C (95 - 115 degrees C) so if the water is that temperature at source, it would not give much cooling to the motor!
Typically, a 200 KW motor at around 100 meters will deliver in the order of 90 liters per second with a head above the surface of around 5 Bar. - total pumping head around 100 Meters of water.
Best regards,
Mark.
Mark Empson
L M Photonics Ltd
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
Is it outdoor pump? Do failures tend to occur more during rainstorm? If yes moisture intrusion should be considered among possibilities.
Also consider turn insulation / surge failure if failures occur T-storms, system transients or during motor start.
8-9 starts per day every day seems to me on the high-side for 1000hp motor. Especially if 2-pole motor, and if starts are clumped together during a high demand period without adequate cooling. Also especially if motor runs for a very short time after start (motors cool a lot quicker when running after start then when standing after start). What is the rough duration between installation and failure? Are there any nuisance trips from overload? Do you happen to have winding temperautre indication? That would not be definitive, but would help assess the severity of the starting duty. Review of relay to determine time to start is good suggestion - good qualitative indicator of the severity of each start. If you have voltage issues or rotor degradation (*) prolonging time to start, it'll show up there.
* Repetitive starting of large motor can certainly damage rotor over time. To check health of rotor, do a high resolution FFT of the current waveform looking for pole pass sidebands around line frequency. Also look for current oscillations. Other checks possible in the shop.
If the starting duty turns to be an issue, I think installation of soft starter is a dubious solution. The total heat generated during reduced voltage start is at least as high as DOL start (and can be higher). The only good things are reduction in winding forces and the heat is spread over longer period of time... I have heard soft start is effective for some centrifuge type loads where start is prolonged to 5 minutes or so.... but I haven't heard of that strategy for centrifugal pump.
On the other hand, vfd with smoothly ramped frequency does significantly reduce heat generated during each start.
=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
I suspect that it is a submersible, so water cooled.
Best regards,
Mark
Mark Empson
L M Photonics Ltd
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
everyone should pardon me for not answering your questions. I am closely following your replies and trying to collect all the information. I will get all the answers and reply to guys. Thank you so much for the responses and the time you guys took.
gokul
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
Here are the answers for some of the questions.....
What is the failure mode of the pump during all 5 events?
Three motors have failed due to end coil failure. Likely cause is from frequent starting and stopping of pump and starting current.
Does it look like overheating or insulation failure?
Overheating is not evident
Is there a possibility of water ingress? Is it a submersible pump?
We have not had any water ingress. It is a submersible pump
What is the static water pressure on the pump when it is not pumping?
Answer yet to be found out
Is the pump ever started when it is back-spinning?
Pump has 30 min lock out timer
Have any calculations on the starting voltage drop at the motor terminals
yes, voltage drop is minimal. Less than 5 %
What is the pump or motor manufacturer recommendations for maximum allowable stating times
Nothing specific. But recommends to reduce the no of starts by keeping the pump running longer, install vfd
Is the unbalance of currents at the motor terminals measured?
Multilin has not tripped from load imbalance. It is set to trip at 20% and provide alarm at 15%
How much number of starts per hour is allowed by the manufacturer?
Manufacture recommends 1-2 starts a day
How much time it takes for the pump to fill in the storage tank?
Less than two hours
How much deep is the pump setup?
1840 feet deep and the water level is 660 feet deep
I will try to find more answers and will post is as soon as i get them
thanks,
gokul
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
Overheating may involve the entire winding, and the portion inside the core may be hotter than the end turns.
You may have high voltage transients damaging the end turns.
Are you using a vacuum contactor?
Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
There should be at a minimum motor time current curves showing damage region. One possible step is verify your starting times are below those, which is a necessary but not sufficient condition for reliable operation.
Sounds reasonable to me although I don't work with submersibles. I see the motor bears the same company name as the pump. You'd think the conflict between manufacturer recommendation and application demands would have come to light during design/specification stage
=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
If so, then a soft-starter should help. You would just need to limit the inrush and lower the forces in the motor.
Ask the manufacturer if there is any limits on the ramp-up time. Some submersible pumps use a water bearing which lifts the rotor/impeller assembly and they must reach a minimum rpm fairly quickly.
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
We run several 4160 deep well pump motors on drives with excellent results. They are set to match delivery exactly to demand. The only time they shut down is if the power goes off or maintenance is in progress. Power consumption has been reduced, demand is controller and load factor increased.
After a few more motor replacements you will have the drive and transformer completely paid for.
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
Have you calculated the gallons pumped per kW consumed before and after the VFD install?
So much of the "energy savings" in water pumps is focused on how lowering the speed a little lowers the HP or kW usage a lot. This is completely the wrong approach. You have to focus on increasing the gallons pumped per kW of power used if you truely want to save energy.
After posting that, I will now post that a VFD is an excellent tool for process control. You can lower the pump speed and maintain a constant water flow and steady pump operation which will easier on the pump system. In this application, A VFD may well be a very good solution.
However, I still believe that if it the failures are due to mechanical forces in the windings then a soft-starter will reduce those forces which should give the motor a long life.
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
Yeah, I know it takes ~900 psi, so a cheap compressor won't do it.
Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
I think that there are enough deep well pumps working well that starting isn't the issue. We have to find what's damaging the windings. Vacuum contactors have been known to generate High frequency transients that may give rise to high voltages that often attack the end turn windings, but I have no reply to my query re vacuum contactors.
Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
I don't see the logic for ruling out frequent starting as a contributor when it has been stated the manufacturer recommends 1-2 starts a day. Is 8-10x per day cycling of 1000hp motors supposed to be a common application? (Yikes).
Another clue may be the location of the failures. If failures are not confined to first few line end coils. we expect probably it is mechanical stresses as was suggested by Lionel. There are also many clues of winding movement (at least in air-cooled motors). Cracking of resin around ties in the endwinding areas. Dusting visible at the coil exits and perhaps in the vent ducts.
Was a lot of copper missing at the failures (usually suggests turn to turn fault to me, which also leans toward mechanical causes).
I may have missed it but do we know which protection took out the motor... phase overcurrent (time, instantanios) or ground fault or something else?
Another question I was curious about... how long roughly from installation to failure. Or if not that, then 5 failures over what time period?
=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
Here is more what i have found out.
waross : yes we are using a vaccuum contactor.
Electricpete: Manufacturer tell we need to start the motor by 2 secs. yes there is a ramp up time constraint here. The motor has to start by 2 secs. Sooner the better.
Also rough duration between installation and failure is around 6 months and the motor is a 2 pole motor.
LionelHutz : I thing I answered your question too. Yes, there is a ramp up time constraint. It has to ramp up by 2 secs
I actually spoke to support engineer from the manufacturer and he recommends VFD. He says his VFD has some kind of sensor which actually communicates with the motor and smoothes the flow of water.
I have to provide the appropriation to the management on whether to spend that cost for VFD.
What do you guys recommend. From what all we discussed i am starting to confirm that its a starting current issue. So should I go with a VFD or save some bucks with the Soft Starter. :)
Thanks once again for all your feedbacks.
gokul
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
Start problems usually result in rotor damage rather than stator damage and if there is no rotor damage, then it does not sound like a thermal problem resulting form excessive starts or starts per hour.
The use of either a soft starter or primary resistance starter would reduce the start transient and should also reduce the end winding damage resulting from initial start transient torques.
Another source of very high transients, is "auto reclose" which is essentially the situation where the supply to the motor is lost for one or more cycles. On reclosure, there is a very high transient which can do considerable damage including breaking shafts. If there is an issue on the supply, or in the contactor control that allows the contactor to bounce, it could also be the cause of the problem.
I have seen a number of level control systems where the contactor is able to bounce at the top level.
A VFD with a fast ramp could also be used, but in this case, I would caution against any expectation of energy savings because the flow is not being mechanically restricted. If the flow is being reduced by some means causing the pump to "slip", then reducing the flow by reducing the speed will result in energy savings. If the flow is not restricted, then a soft starter will have a lower running cost than a VFD.
Best regards,
Mark.
Mark Empson
L M Photonics Ltd
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
1. Mechanical damage due to the magnetic forces during starting or due to the contactor bounce/chatter as brought up by Mark.
2. dV/dt damage due to the vacuum contactor.
What is causing the damage still needs to be determined. The motor uses a vacuum contactor. Are there surge arrestors and/or surge caps on the motor side?
I know the manufacturer says 2 secs to full speed but if you use a VFD that's not possible because you will run below lower speed continuously.
As for the energy savings - I would expect this system to use at least 10% more energy with a VFD.
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
1. Submersible pump - pump assembly and motor is at the bottom of the wellhead, motor is water-cooled (distilled water inside motor cavity), check valve at the surface.
2. Deepwell pump - the motor is at the top while pump stages are at the bottom, motor is air-cooled provided by ventillating fans, pump column equipped with foot valves.
Since you confirmed it is a submersible pump, the problem could be (1)a check valve passing that allows water in the pump column to drop and spin back the shaft; (2)transients due to vacuum breaker's high dv/dt or (3)over-capacity resulting to many starts/day. To check if the check valve is passing; use an ultrasonic flowmeter(strap-on) and see if there is backflow when the pump is off. On the transients problem, you need to install surge arresters at the motors. If you can determine that your pump is too big, try taking out one unit(if it is possible- you mentioned two arranged in tandem, I presume they're in arranged in-line with the discharge of the first stages routed to the second set of pump stages) or throttle your discharge valve a bit. A softstarter could also be your solution if all those mentioned are in order.
Glad to be of help.
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
Alan
----
"It's always fun to do the impossible." - Walt Disney
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
Solution - use a surge suppressor across the motor supply terminals.
Muthu
www.edison.co.in
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
Our engineer has suggested that we remove some number of impellers from the pump such that the water pumping flow is reduced and so we smooth the operation of the motor. He says it can configure it such that the pump will run for 24 hour operation and pump the same amount of water.
Any comment about this??
gokul
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
BUT first I would investigate the possibility that the vacuum contactor is causing the problems. Fix the cause, not the symptoms.
Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
Yes, you will want some extra capacity so you don't run out of water.
Yes, you will still need to address the cause of the motor failures.
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump
RE: 1000HP Deep Well Water Pump