×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Concrete Footing Reinforcement

Concrete Footing Reinforcement

Concrete Footing Reinforcement

(OP)
I am reviewing some old calculations/design of a 4' thick concrete footing.  The design engineer placed their required (As.min) flexural reinforcement (tension/compression) on the top and bottom faces in each direction.  This I understand.  However, they placed an additional layer of reinforcement in the dead center of the footing, and this is where I'm questioning the logic.  Based on the calculations, it appeared that the rebar is used simply as temperature reinforcement, but I know there is sufficient quantities in the top and bottom layers to account for this.  Additionally, the location of the rebar is basically useless in my opinion because its situated on the neutral axis.  Am I missing something here?

RE: Concrete Footing Reinforcement

craig...I see no reason for it.  I do a lot of 2' to 4' thick footings subject to high overturning loads and I use two mats...top and bottom.

RE: Concrete Footing Reinforcement

(OP)
Thanks Ron.  Always a comfort to have a second opinion.

RE: Concrete Footing Reinforcement

I would also agree.  if the reinforcement is at the NA then in theory this is the area in the concrete where tension & compression is equal to zero.

RE: Concrete Footing Reinforcement

Your statement about the midheight steel being at the neutral axis is incorrect for a cracked section. However, I do agree with Ron's response.

RE: Concrete Footing Reinforcement

I've seen engineers do this as well for a very thick mat.... 6 ft thick or so.  Though I remember the middle layer being included the total temperature / shrinkage reinforcement.

I've also been a young engineer on a job that did not require a 3rd layer where the EOR told me to add a middle layer only because it made him feel more comfortable with the design that I had come up with.  

RE: Concrete Footing Reinforcement

Sometimes extra steel is placerd to support the steel at the top of the footing if there are two layers.  This is non-structural steel.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: Concrete Footing Reinforcement

Or it is just a feel good rebar used, in a thick footing, for the engineer to feel that they are "holding together" the concrete....sort of a shear friction mentality.

Not saying they are needed, engineers just like to feel good, right?

 

RE: Concrete Footing Reinforcement

yeah - middle row of steel...thats good - sounds like a case of somebody else's money

RE: Concrete Footing Reinforcement

i remember i saw a drawing for a very thick footing for a vibrating compressor equipment..
around nine feet thick or so.. and there was like for 4 or 5 layers of rebars..

dont get the logic for that..

RE: Concrete Footing Reinforcement

Some people just don't understand.  If an engineer can't think like concrete, he shouldn't be an engineer.

RE: Concrete Footing Reinforcement

I've had the opportunity to design several radiation vaults associated with medical facilities. They are basically a concrete bunker, with minimum concrete wall thickness of 3'-4' (depending on where in the vault), and up to 8' thick at the beam blocker. I used multiple layers of reinforcing, basically for minimum shrinkage & temperature... I believe up to 6 layers, if I remember correctly. The whole idea is to distribute the reinforcing throughout the section. Even though the coefficient of thermal expansion of concrete (0.00055 per 100 degrees F) is similar to that of steel (0.00065 per 100 degrees F), they are not the same. Layering creates a more "homogeneous" section throughout the member's thickness. I believe this is also important as the structure cures & shrinks.

Granted, I don't believe that I would do this for a spead footing, but the concept is valid.

RE: Concrete Footing Reinforcement

Shrinkage, bending, shear and other cracks start from the exterior of a concrete surface and then propogate inward.  Wouldn't reinforcing always be the most effective near the surfaces?  
If there was a choice between a top and bottom layer of #8s or 4 layers of #6s, wouldn't it be cheaper to stick with the fewer number of bars?
What would be an example of a failure mechanism that would be prevented by multiple layers of reinforcement over just the top and bottom mat?

RE: Concrete Footing Reinforcement

(OP)
Thanks for everyones input so far.  One rule of thought is that multiple layers of reinforcing might be needed to allow sufficient spacing between rebar, else the rebar could get mighty crowded in one mat with a thick slab.  However, with components such as footings, it is a good idea to limit your rebar spacing in order to minimize crack width.  This will subsequently decrease permeability to groundwater intrusion.  

In regards to the temperature reinforcement in footings, I'm not sure how needed it would be.  The ground would have a significant moderating effect so as to prevent large temperature fluctuations.  I'm sure shrinkage would be evident, but the relatively tight rebar spacing should compensate effectively.  

I think the bottom line that as it was put above, this is pretty much "feel good" rebar in this application.  I'm assuming there is no formal documentation or ACI references that really show otherwise.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources