×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Live Load Means How Many People?
4

Live Load Means How Many People?

Live Load Means How Many People?

(OP)
If analysis of an existing structure reveals a live load capacity of 20psf, but the code mandates a live load for this structure of 60psf (balcony fixed seating), how many people is 20psf?

I know ASCE uses 60psf to include dynamic forces due to people moving around on an elevated floor.  I believe that I'll have to take the number of fixed seats that are existing, ratio them by 20/60, count the number of seats left, and make that the restriction.  Any other ideas?

RE: Live Load Means How Many People?

That seems like a bad idea. I don't think you can get around that 60 psf. People can still go on to your balcony, regardless of what a sign says. Do you really want to take the risk that a bunch of teenagers will think to themselves...  "let's test that limit"?

RE: Live Load Means How Many People?

And that "live load" could literally be just that: jumping, people crowding literally right next to each other right at the railing's edge, jostling and perhaps even carrying another.

We've seen the shenanigans going on at parties and athletic events.

Are you going to gamble they won't happen on your balcony just because of a "sign" on the wall?

So you have "fixed seats" - how are people going to get to and from the seats, how many other people are going to crowd around without ever sitting down in those fixed seats?

RE: Live Load Means How Many People?

60 psf will be exceeded but the reserve strength, (safety factor), should suffice on the rare occasions when overloaded.  Building to the code is considered good judgement.

RE: Live Load Means How Many People?

My former boss one mentioned that a movie theatre lineup is about 100psf, for what it's worth.

Crush loading in a passenger rail vehicle is often taken as 6 persons per square meter, each at 95th percentile male (220lb) - sorry about mixing units...

tg

RE: Live Load Means How Many People?

I tried something similar to this once.  I explained to a Code official that a client would limit storage live load in a room by creating wide aisles between shelving.

The Code official would not accept this.  On my project, he said a room originally designed for 60 psf live load simply cannot be used for storage without reinforcing the floor members.

DaveAtkins

RE: Live Load Means How Many People?

2
I know of no code-acceptable loading for people in the 20psf range (not stairs, not balconies, not observation platforms...anything). If an average person of say 175 lbs, wearing  size 10 shoes, puts both feet closely together, his loading on that (roughly) square foot is 175psf.  Obviously you won't pack that many people of that size so closely together, but you could give each of them say, three square feet of space and that wouldn't be unreasonable for a gathering. Then you have roughly 58psf.  That's without any dynamic consideration.

Where people are involved, and can gather in close spaces such as a balcony, a crosswalk, or mezzanine, a high unit load is necessary.  Go back and read a few of the articles about the Hyatt-Regency walkway failure.

People will ignore posted signs as racookepe1978 noted.

If you are considering rating an area that you know will hold people and it's capacity is less than the code-allowable (in this case much less), you are being irresponsible and you are not meeting an acceptable standard of care.  If anything ever happened and this came out through investigation...and it would, your actions would likely constitute professional negligence.

Tell the owner it won't work for the application. If you're the owner, it won't work for the application.   

RE: Live Load Means How Many People?

There was a whole bunch of people killed in Chicago a few years back when a balcony collapsed.  They were having a party on it.  As I remember the party overflowed to a balcony below and some of the people killed were on that, when the structure and partiers landed on them.
My point is, if it's available for occupancy, you need to design for that load.  That's your best legal protection against litigation, plus it's the law.

RE: Live Load Means How Many People?

Even though i would agree with Ron, I believe you need to open a dialogue with your code official. There opinion as per Dave's post would be very important.  

When in doubt, just take the next small step.
 

RE: Live Load Means How Many People?

asixth...most occupancy limitations are for fire egress purposes.

RE: Live Load Means How Many People?

Ron beat me to it.

If there is ever a fire in this area do you think people will evacuate and spread out in an orderly fashion - no, there will be a lote of people crushing into a small area near the exit door trying to get out.

Use the code limits as it is often impossible to justify using anything less.

RE: Live Load Means How Many People?

There was recently a balcony that came off of a 2nd story apartment building in our city.  There were 2 kids near their 20's and some free weights involved.  Estimates put it nearly 750lbs on a 8'x8' balcony.  People do crazy things on balconies.  Luckily no one was seriously injured but they had to inspect all of the apartments built by this builder and several balconies needed repaired and were condemned until repairs were made.

http://www.indy.com/posts/lafayette-balcony-collapses-2-hurt
 

RE: Live Load Means How Many People?

If you have space for people to stand you need to have the structural capacity to support them.  There are lots of decks that fail every year during parties.

http://www.chicagobreakingnews.com/2009/07/pedestrian-bridge-collapses-in-indiana.html

I would argue that the above linked failure should never have happened.  If you can fit 150 people on a structure, then you need to design for 150 people.
 

RE: Live Load Means How Many People?

(OP)
I appreciate the responses.  I've written to the client that the balcony must be retrofitted to increase the live load capacity.

Its been argued to me that the structure is 90 years old, served well for 90 years, and why stiffen it now?  I've stated that that may be true, but its probably never been fully loaded, and I can only report the numerical findings and make a recommendation.

It is to be stiffened.

RE: Live Load Means How Many People?

2
I hate those "its been OK for 90 years" arguments.

A good engineer will respond:

"For 90 years the structure has stood because of a combination of luck and statistics.  For whatever reason, the smaller than required safety margin has not been exceeded.  Today, under the current code, and as your engineer, I am liable for the future performance of the structure and I can tell you definitively that it does not provide the required safety margin as is.  If you want to leave it as is two things will happen.  I will have to step away from the project and report the lack of safety margin to the building official, and I will write you a letter documenting this opinion and all liability will fall on you.  I urge you to accept what I'm saying.  If you want a second opinion to confirm my opinion, feel free to do so."

....OK....I live in an ideal world and been smoking something - but you have to admit it sounds good, eh?

 

RE: Live Load Means How Many People?

JAE,
Can you pass some of that stuff around?

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources