P.E. Liability in Exempt Industry
P.E. Liability in Exempt Industry
(OP)
Greetings,
I know that many aspects of P.E. licensing have been covered in-depth. If the answer is out there, please point me to it! Or if this topic is more appropriate in a different forum, please suggest which one.
I currently am an EIT and working in an exempt industry where a PE license is not required. However, for my own ego/self-improvement, I have debated if I should at least attempt to get my PE eventually. I still have a little more to fulfill experience requirements, a lot more studying to do, and would have to try to dig up references (difficult when all contacts are in exempt industry and therefore not likely to be PEs). However, what I would like to know for the future is:
1) If I get my PE license, pay for the exam myself, and pay for registration, do I have any greater liability at work? Will I be held to a higher standard for the engineering I do? If so, why would I bother to get my PE? It seems like it adds personal risk with no benefit. (Assume for this that my employer doesn't even know that I have my PE)
2) I assume that having PE on a business card or anything submitted to customers, vendors, etc would increase my personal liability, even if I do not stamp anything. Correct?
3) Following the lines of question #1, if I were to get my PE but not advertise that I have it (Not on business cards, verbally, etc)... What if a salesperson at my company told the customer I have a PE? Would that increase my personal liability even though I personally did not tell/offer professional engineering?
I will start with those questions and we'll see where it takes us!
Thanks, --MechEng2005
I know that many aspects of P.E. licensing have been covered in-depth. If the answer is out there, please point me to it! Or if this topic is more appropriate in a different forum, please suggest which one.
I currently am an EIT and working in an exempt industry where a PE license is not required. However, for my own ego/self-improvement, I have debated if I should at least attempt to get my PE eventually. I still have a little more to fulfill experience requirements, a lot more studying to do, and would have to try to dig up references (difficult when all contacts are in exempt industry and therefore not likely to be PEs). However, what I would like to know for the future is:
1) If I get my PE license, pay for the exam myself, and pay for registration, do I have any greater liability at work? Will I be held to a higher standard for the engineering I do? If so, why would I bother to get my PE? It seems like it adds personal risk with no benefit. (Assume for this that my employer doesn't even know that I have my PE)
2) I assume that having PE on a business card or anything submitted to customers, vendors, etc would increase my personal liability, even if I do not stamp anything. Correct?
3) Following the lines of question #1, if I were to get my PE but not advertise that I have it (Not on business cards, verbally, etc)... What if a salesperson at my company told the customer I have a PE? Would that increase my personal liability even though I personally did not tell/offer professional engineering?
I will start with those questions and we'll see where it takes us!
Thanks, --MechEng2005





RE: P.E. Liability in Exempt Industry
Since you have no P.E.'s at your employment, you might have a bit of difficulty meeting the requirements for taking the P.E. exam, since most states require direct internship under a licensed engineer. Check with your state board on that one.
As a P.E., you will almost always be held to a higher standard of practice, after all, non-licensed engineers have little in the way of defined practice criteria, even though most are as ethical and technically competent as any P.E. The license doesn't make you a good engineer, just one that can get into easier if you're not.
Having P.E. on your business card does not increase your liability. It increases your exposure, but that's not a bad thing as long as you practice competently.
Others having knowledge of your P.E. also doesn't necessarily increase your liability, other than the typical of having a greater duty for performance.
I would suggest that if your company is going to recognize you as a licensed engineer (and they will likely want to use that), that they become licensed with the state as required, and that they indemnify and protect you with appropriate professional liability insurance.
Good luck.
RE: P.E. Liability in Exempt Industry
Bottom line of that conversation was that the attorney's opinion was that while working for the company I did not assume any additional liability while performing exempt tasks. That as a P.E. I was assuming an obligation to report improper practices (much like the lawyer assumed as an Officer of the Court), but that I better not ever use my stamp at work. He had no problem with my having "P.E." on business cards and letterheads, but that I couldn't stamp anything.
This was in a job that worked under an industrial exemption. It is very different from the advice I would have gotten had I been is a company that was holding itself out to the public as engineers. In that situation, insurance and liability and compensation issues are all items for negotiation.
David Simpson, PE
MuleShoe Engineering
www.muleshoe-eng.com
Please see FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips Fora.
"Life is nature's way of preserving meat" The Master on Dr. Who
RE: P.E. Liability in Exempt Industry
RE: P.E. Liability in Exempt Industry
Certainly the PE takes on a higher ethical duty to the general public when he accepts his license. Again, the use of the stamp does not change his duty to the public.
RE: P.E. Liability in Exempt Industry
So, if I am understanding correctly...
If I get my PE and continue to work in an exempt industry, I do not need to take any action (i.e. getting insurance personally, ensuring I am named on company insurance, etc). This applies even if I have P.E. on business cards, email signatures, etc.
However, if I get my PE and were to stamp/sign a drawing, I incur the liability and MUST have insurance, either personally or by being named on my employer's policy. (Obviously if I were stamping something, it would be for work and I would certainly expect to have them pay for the insurance and an increase in compensation for my increased value and liability).
If I get my PE, regardless of if it is a secret from my employer, customers, wife, etc, I will be held accountable for a duty to ensure all designs are safe by the state board. While I may not be able to be sued, I am subject to any "punishment" the state board determines appropriate if a problem arises with something I have designed.
Am I understanding correctly? Also, for those who have worked in exempt industries with a PE, do you expect additional wages/compensation for the "advertising" value even if you never stamp anything? Is it common for employers in exempt industry to pay for the PE exam and/or registration?
-- MechEng2005
RE: P.E. Liability in Exempt Industry
Yes we feel the PE adds value and that we should be compensated accordingly. Gonna be a more difficult argument to make if the rare stamping occasion is killed by the company lawyer.
Been registered since '97, and used my stamp twice. Once for a reference for an engineer to sit for the exam, and again just a few weeks ago to enhance a document that called for "engineering judgment."
RE: P.E. Liability in Exempt Industry
You almost described my situation when I still worked in an exempt industry, but not quite. The fact you have a P.E. does not mean If you don't have a business reason to review someone else's design then you are not accountable. You are accountable for the designs you work on, and have some specific responsibilities to the public but they are very similar to what any degreed engineer would be expected to assume.
David
RE: P.E. Liability in Exempt Industry
While any engineer is accountable and has a duty to the public, the board has no authority over the non-PE working in an exempt industry. The PE accepts this authority regardless of where he works.
RE: P.E. Liability in Exempt Industry
David
RE: P.E. Liability in Exempt Industry
RE: P.E. Liability in Exempt Industry
RE: P.E. Liability in Exempt Industry
Would a charge of "practicing engineering without a license" come from the state board or from the court system? I'm guessing issues arising from unethical/unsafe practices in engineering generally go through the state board and then are followed up by the state's attorney, regardless of if the defendant is a registered PE or not, so all trials would look the same at that point. The only difference would be if the plaintiff has a formal document from when you got the PE or if they argue that the duty of care is the responsibilty of all engineers, licensed or not.
-- MechEng2005
RE: P.E. Liability in Exempt Industry
RE: P.E. Liability in Exempt Industry
If you are in an exempt job and an argument can be made that the work you are doing is in fact "holding yourself out to the public as an Engineer" then the boards regularly invoke sanctions along the lines of "practicing engineering without a license".
If you have a P.E. and you are in fact holding yourself out as an Engineer then if you do something "wrong" then the Board has a list of sanctions they can impose and the Civil and Criminal systems can get interested as well.
David
RE: P.E. Liability in Exempt Industry
It is possible that someone in your chain of command is a licensed PE. This may satisfy your board regulations for applying.