job (structural engineering)
job (structural engineering)
(OP)
Hi, I have been reading this forum and I find it very helpful. Now I am looking for some career advise.
I have been looking for a job on and off for a year now. I finally graduated in May with a PhD in structural engineering. I also hold a master's degree in Architecture. I had about 2.5 years of internships in Arch and Engineering (non-structural). I have been applying for structural engineer positions in the Southern California area. I got a few interviews in late 2008/early 2009 and some of them told me that "we are not hiring now; but check with us if you have a job offer." Lately, my resume seems to just go into black holes with no response whatsoever.
I want to ask about the state of the job market in structural engineering. And if there is something about my background that is not landing a job.
Many thanks in advance!!!!!!
I have been looking for a job on and off for a year now. I finally graduated in May with a PhD in structural engineering. I also hold a master's degree in Architecture. I had about 2.5 years of internships in Arch and Engineering (non-structural). I have been applying for structural engineer positions in the Southern California area. I got a few interviews in late 2008/early 2009 and some of them told me that "we are not hiring now; but check with us if you have a job offer." Lately, my resume seems to just go into black holes with no response whatsoever.
I want to ask about the state of the job market in structural engineering. And if there is something about my background that is not landing a job.
Many thanks in advance!!!!!!





RE: job (structural engineering)
With a new PhD in structural engineering, I would think your best possibilities in this environment would be academia, a very large consulting firm, or research for a trade organization.
RE: job (structural engineering)
As hard as you worked for your PhD, you need to understand that many employers do not view the PhD as positively as you might think. While it is a necessity in academia, it can be a detriment in practical application...not that it is right, it's just a fact. Some employers are intimidated by it, some view it as giving you a more theoretical approach to problem solving than a practical one, and some just don't want to pay for it when they can get the same productivity out of a newbie with a BS degree.
If you were able to land an academic position, you could then work part time to build your resume with structural firms in the area and develop a reputation. That would be my suggestion.
RE: job (structural engineering)
My firm believes that practical experience is more valuable than having a PhD......
RE: job (structural engineering)
@hokie66:
I am not trying with my prior internship companies b/c they are not structural firms and I want to be in structural engineering.
@Ron:
How does one work part time in structural firms? Since I am no longer in school, I can't work as an intern, right?
Overall, academic positions are hard to come by as well. States cutting funding to colleges and many schools are having hiring freeze. Most importantly, I prefer working in the industry and applications.
I am very interested in solving practical problems. I got a Masters in Architecture because I want to deal with the practical issues / integrated design between Structural Eng and Arch. I don't necessarily need to be paid as a PhD. My main objective is getting practice experience and working toward my PE.
RE: job (structural engineering)
RE: job (structural engineering)
My research background is in structural dynamics, risk/reliability analysis, building energy analysis, life-cycle assessment...
In short, I am trying to design buildings such that they are safer, more reliable and sustainable at the same time by integrating structural and architectural components efficiently. I have learned a bit of everything in building design (sometime more than a bit) and I now want to learn the practical aspects.
I understand that I may not get to apply any of my research in practice. I am simply trying to gain enough practical experience now and in future possibly identify applications to use my research knowledge. But, in today's market, I cannot even get my feet into practice.
RE: job (structural engineering)
Sell the structural firm on the fact that you have a PhD, you will work for about the same amount as one of their EI's, and that they don't have to pay benefits. They should realize the benefit to them!
RE: job (structural engineering)
Hey do you want salt and vinegar with that chip on your shoulder?
Cheers
Greg Locock
SIG:Please see FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips.
RE: job (structural engineering)
RE: job (structural engineering)
Fe
RE: job (structural engineering)
You may have to extend your search beyond your area. With your education in architecture and structural engineering, you might try some of the big forensics firms. There are plenty of leaking buildings around. But then my impression is that architectural schools don't worry about teaching their students how to make their buildings shed water. Wherever you go, there will be a lot of training involved. No responsible firm will expect you to be able to hit the ground running.
RE: job (structural engineering)
When in doubt, just take the next small step.
RE: job (structural engineering)
RE: job (structural engineering)
Just because you have a PhD doesn't meant you need to headline with it.
I had my business cards done 3 times because they left off the P.E. after my name so I can only imagine how hard it would be to voluntary remove the PhD but it may at least get your foot in the door.
I would not remove it entirely from your resume but move it to the bottom and see if anyone asks.
I recently interviewed with 5 different people at a company. Only one of them even mentioned my degree.
RE: job (structural engineering)
i used to work with a few former PHd guys. one, i actually tried to show out on me over .5 inches of steel.
gee willikers.
RE: job (structural engineering)
That could be the problem here if the perception of others is similar to mine. Clients are interested in saving money, but, in general will not finance huge research projects to do that.
You need to decide here which road you want to travel to make yourself happy.
Again, please do not take offense as I am speaking from my experience.
Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
RE: job (structural engineering)
Hold your head high and be proud of your PhD. The best and most practical engineer I have ever worked with has a PhD in structural engineering. Every individual is different. If you were practical when you started, you can still be practical.
rowingengineer,
Yes, that seems to be what they think they are supposed to do. Sometimes, they are not even successful at that.
RE: job (structural engineering)
As with anything it is all about perseverance.
When in doubt, just take the next small step.
RE: job (structural engineering)
My BS is in Civil Eng; MS+PhD in Struc Eng and a MS-like degree in Architecture (not MArch).
I do intend to be practical. I realized in my undergrad there are many practical issue between Eng and Arch, so I wanted to study in both areas to learn from both perspectives. I am proud of my training and think my background will be valuable in building design.
Just that no one seems to want to hire a over-educated PhD with Arch training in this market. I do want to work my way up from entry positions; I realize that experience now is more important than pay and education for me.
RE: job (structural engineering)
If you chose the private consulting sector as opposed to research, just keep this in mind. It will help feed your family, your career, and your future. Best wishes to you and yours, and congratulations too. It was a hard road.
Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
RE: job (structural engineering)
practical for many people isn't something that's innate. it's something you learn from experience in design as well as being in the field. i developed mine from having to interpret another engineer's structurals and reviewed shops as a threshold inspector. like mike said above me, you'll get to the point where instead of having to run some numbers, you can look at a moment/shear/ect and just know what'll work.
RE: job (structural engineering)
I graduated with my BSCE in 1983 which was one of the worst times to find an engineering job ever. After 8 months of waitressing I finally got a job at a state DOT doing bridge design. Have you thought about trying that? In my state, yours too probably, one must take a civil service test to be considered for junior engineer jobs. Why not take the test just to keep that option open?
RE: job (structural engineering)
thanks,