×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

concrete column retrofit
3

concrete column retrofit

concrete column retrofit

(OP)
A client needs to fix a failing concrete column. The problem is corrosion. It appears that moisture from a very humid indoor environment has started corrosion from the bottom and is working its way up the column. The bottom 18" of reinf. is severely corroded, allowing the column to crush and spawl. I was thinking of removing the damaged material and encasing the lower half with a reinforced concrete jacket. It's 14" diam., about 8' tall, supports a concrete beam and is on a 48" sq. pad foundation. It's in a utility room. Using the pad dimension to assume the column load, the column design seems to be more that adequate. It's not part of the lateral force resisting system.  The plans provided aren't enough to determine the applied loads.

'Anyone have advise?

RE: concrete column retrofit

You are probably on the right track.  Is it possible to post a photo?

RE: concrete column retrofit

Install a dehumidifier too.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: concrete column retrofit

(OP)
Hokie,

No, I don't have a photo.  The damaged area has vertical cracking, bulging & spawling outside the rebar. The ties are rusted through and broken.  The verticle bars,(6)#8's anf (6) #6 ftg. dowels, are really bad. It's like peeling bark off a tree.  It's pretty hammered.

I think the extent of the damage is limited to the bottom.
The entire column seems to be protected with Thoroseal or something.  

I'm wondering if it makes better sense to cut the entire bottom third off & add an 24" or so pedestal W/ epoxied dowels.  There would be a pinned connection I guess. Cleaner, & the rust will be gone.

If this is a common problem, someone should have a better fix.

   

RE: concrete column retrofit

I'd like to know a little more about this corrosion.  Concrete columns are used in seawater and fresh water all the time.  And corrosion is not an issue.  Humidity shouldn't bother a concrete column at all.  Unless the moisture is entering through a crack or the reinforcing is in contact with the ground.  Is there a chemical environment?
A concrete jacket might not stop the cause of the corrosion.

RE: concrete column retrofit

Are you thinking electroysis?

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: concrete column retrofit

NGW,
I think you are on the right track.  Typically if a concrete column is not too severely corroded, the vanilla method is to remove the loose and deteriorated concrete, clean the rebar, add rebar or other reinforcing if necessary, and replace the removed concrete.

In your case, it sounds like the corrosion is excessive so removing and replacing a significant portion of the column might be the way to go.

The other response to this is to verify what caused the moisture/corrosion in the first place (per JedC above).  If there is moisture coming in from above, then some remediation of the waterproofing is in order.  If it is simply a wet environment, and will continue to be wet, then perhaps other measures could also be included such as sacrificial anodes, epoxy rebar, concrete mix corrosion inhibitors (DCI for example), etc.

 

RE: concrete column retrofit

Also condition of the pad footing should be checked. If it's reinforced it is also likely to have problems.

RE: concrete column retrofit

As others have stated, it is important to verify the root cause of the problem so that you can come up with a suitable solution and not just a temporary patch.

It may be worth getting a concrete repair company on board, their reps will often come to site and give you advice. They may be able to tell you straight off what the cause of the problem is.

Once the required chemical considerations are taken care of then it is simply a matter of restoring the load path.

RE: concrete column retrofit

(OP)
Thanks to all of you for your input.  
I'll go back and take a closer look.  I'll find a concrete repair company.
I'll call the original engineer if possible to confirm the loads.
It's definitely going to take epoxy rebar & some kind of seal at he ground level.  I don't think the soil is naturally highly corrosive.  Could calcium chloride additive have this kind of effect?

Assuming the footing rebar is corroded, what do you think about just making the pedestal large enough to spread the load instead of R&R of the footing?

 

RE: concrete column retrofit

Here are a few suggestions:
1) If bulging is occurring, I would highly recommend some shoring of the beams be placed immediately. You will also need shoring when chipping out the concrete...especially if you have to chip to sound concrete...be careful how much you chip out.

2) You need to identify the source of the probably...if you dig deeper you will always find other areas/elements of concern. Is it moisture and/or concrete chemical properties. I would request a material testing and investigation program be performed in the area of concern as well as another part of the structure. The question: Is this a localized issue or a global issue? Older concrete sometimes have chlorides from admixtures...and if their is a waterproofing issue...then it gets activated. Need to define extent of problem, and stop cause.

3) Would recommend spraying all concrete in the area with a migrating corrosion inhibitor.

4) Jacketing the column with new concrete is probably preferred in this case. I would also add anodes (pucks) inside the mix. Make the mix expansive with low water cement ratio. Make sure to prep surfaces properly.

5) Call Structural Group (Structural preservation Systems) for help.

RE: concrete column retrofit

(OP)
InDepth,

By preping the surfaces, do you mean acid etch & bonder?

I've alerted the original engineer via e-mail.  If this were my project, I'd want to know about it.  I'll wait for his response.  

Either way, this has been a learning experience.  Migrating corrosion inhibitor and anode pucks?  I'm impressed.

Thanks

RE: concrete column retrofit

If calcium chloride was used in the concrete, that is your likely problem.  If that is the case, I would replace the entire column.

RE: concrete column retrofit

(OP)
Replacing the column would be tough because of all the pipes hanging from the ceiling.

'Turns out there are no plans or calcs. to be found.  The project engineer said there was a water intrusion problem about 20 years ago.  There are no visible signs like stains on the block walls.  I think the room houses pool equipment, pool acid, chlorine, etc.  That's probably the cause.

I'll just recommend further investigation, handle the column problem & move on.  I'm thinking 24" sq. x 24" to 36" pedestal with epoxied epoxy coated rebar, 4,500 psi type V concrete (maybe with anodes (pucks)).  If further retrofit is required elsewhere, this still needs to be done, even if temporary.  

agreed?

RE: concrete column retrofit

Agreed.  But get rid of all the loose stuff first.

RE: concrete column retrofit

(OP)
Got it.

Thanks

RE: concrete column retrofit

NGW - some sources suggest that using epoxy coated reinforcement is not a good idea in repairs where there is still active corrosion due to chloride content in the surrounding concrete.

What apparently is the concern is that if you use the epoxy coating for replacement bars, the oxidation of the bars is actually magnified due to concentration of the electrical current (from oxidation) at the point where the epoxy ends and the original non-coated bars begin.  

There are conflicting opinions on this and you should check them out.  ACI has a very good repair document out there that discusses this...not sure of what it is but do a search on the ACI website.

 

RE: concrete column retrofit

(OP)
Thanks JAE.  I'll look into it.  Do you mean the already rusted bars will continue to rust at greater rate?  Or do you mean the bars above the column will rust quicker?  I'm sure they have some rust on them even if not connected to the problem rust below.  

I think my epoxy coated bars will be some distance from the Rusted bars in the footing.  The rusted bars in the column will be gone.  

 

RE: concrete column retrofit

Incipient anode effect means that the reinforcement around the edge of the patch corrodes much faster.

RE: concrete column retrofit

Yes, what DaveMinter said - right at the end of the epoxy paint on the original bars is where you get the attack.

RE: concrete column retrofit

The development length on epoxy bars is much greater, I believe ACI requires twice the development length. May not be an issue but needs to be considered.

There are proprietary sacrificial anodes that can be embedded into the concrete to avoid the above mentioned corrosion. Once again I would recommend you seek advice from a reputable manufacturer.

RE: concrete column retrofit

look into Delta Structural Technology - they perform concrete repairs using various forms of fiber wrapping.  good luck

RE: concrete column retrofit

NGW, sorry for the late response.

On preping I would recommend chipping to sound concrete and then coating the surfaces with either a latex bonding agent or a epoxy based agent. I use SIKA products for these sort of repairs, like Sikatop 123 and Sikadur. You'll need to consult their spec sheets for application. Sika also has epoxy products for coating the reinforcement which has corrosion inhibitors in them. Ferroguard is the pucks.

Use Guide.
http://www.sikaconstruction.com/con/construction-applicationguide.htm

http://www.sikaconstruction.com/con/construction-factsheets_in_construction_name.htm

http://www.sikaconstruction.com/app-cpd-mortars-us.pdf

yes, be careful with using epoxy coated bars and pucks...you may just shift the corrosion problem to another part of the structure....maybe even right next to the repair. I highly recommend finding out what is causing the corrosion.

RE: concrete column retrofit

Oh, and since it is a pool area, you may want to find out the depth of chlorine penetration into concrete. I would recommend placing a new flooring or concrete sealer to mitigate further chlorine penetration....but you have to be careful not to lock in moisture and chlorine under the sealers...because this may even accelerate corrosion.  

RE: concrete column retrofit

(OP)
Thanks InDepth,

Your advise has been helpful.

I think I'll recommend finding an expert in this field for the corrosion investigation and mitigation.  I lack the expertise.  
 

RE: concrete column retrofit

NGW,

The manufacturer such as Sika will give you the options, but it will still be up to a structural engineer such as yourself to do the final specification as it needs to be structurally adequate.

The structural adequacy you understand, the chemical and durability considerations will be addressed by their rep. I see no need for you to offload it to someone else.

Also, manufacturers like Sika usually have a list of approved repairers who know what they are doing, so the site work should not be an issue.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources