×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

VFD vs Servo Lifting Application

VFD vs Servo Lifting Application

VFD vs Servo Lifting Application

(OP)
I have a design application involving the vertical positioning of a horizontal pipe.  One of the design inputs that I've been given is that the positioning has to be within plus or minus 1/4" accurate and repeatable.  There are various vertical positions based on pipe diameter sizes.  The different sizes also means that the load will change as well between each type of pipe.  We will be using a rack and pinion drive system and traveling at 2 in/s max through a 70:1 gearbox.  1 revolution of the gearbox output shaft will lift the pipe 6.28".

The original plan was to use a servo to do the positioning, but we are exploring the idea of using a vfd and ac motor (1800 RPM) instead due to cost reasons.  I'm looking at a closed loop vector control VFD and 2500 PPR encoder.  We will ramp down to a slower speed of 1 in/s approaching the target position before stopping.  The plc will read the encoder position on the drive via fieldbus.  Upon stopping the motor when the target position is encountered, an output from the drive will actuate the motor brake.

I think this is viable to do, and based on my calculations using the above parameters I think it's definitely feasible.  Personally, I would rather pony up the money for a servo system.  For only a few thousand more we can have a packaged servo system that's a lot more flexible and precise in my opinion.  Plus I'm wary of the plus/minus 1/4" tolerance spec and feel that we may need to be more accurate.  I'm also skeptical of what type of delay/problems the fieldbus communication may cause in the grand scheme of things.

Has anyone had any experience trying to be as accurate as 1/4" using the above method?  Your thoughts and opinions will be greatly appreciated.

 

RE: VFD vs Servo Lifting Application

That is certainly acheivable with a sensorless vector drive but I would suggest one that has output relays that do level detection and time delays.

It's not quite as simple as stopping and putting on the brake or vice versa.

It takes time, for example, to magnetize the motor and, if you release the brake at the same time you start the drive, the load will drop a bit before the motor develops enough torque to carry the load.  Setting a relay to detect torque level and then release the brake works much smoother.

RE: VFD vs Servo Lifting Application

(OP)
Yes, you're exactly right.  That's the route that I plan on taking, except I felt that I may need to close the loop using an encoder instead of the using sensorless vector.  Maybe not though...

I had a previous application using a yaskawa drive on a vertical hoisting application using the level detection relays that you speak of.  I didn't have to run an encoder back to the drive in that case.  I set the level detection output relay to a low frequency, and upon ramping down the output relay forced the brake.  I had no issues with load dropping.

My only concern is that some of the mechanical design team feel that I need to be within thirty thousandths as opposed to the 1/4".  In that case I want to go with a servo.  Like I said previously, I'm extremely wary of the plus or minus 1/4" that others have cited.  A certain level of "tolerance" has been built into the tooling (which we insert into the pipe after it is lifted) to allow for this greater variance supposedly.    

RE: VFD vs Servo Lifting Application

Some years ago I had a similar question and asked the SEW-Eurodrive guy.  At the time he stated that "an AC motor coupled with our drive and an encoder" give me equivalent performance to a servo rig.

I was skeptical, but at least it's worth a phone call to see what their Applications Engineers say.  Or Nord, or Leuze, or Falk, or Reliance, or ...

Your situation seems to be completely dependent upon your speeds and loads, and should be evaluated very closely.

TygerDawg
Blue Technik LLC
Virtuoso Robotics Engineering
www.bluetechnik.com

RE: VFD vs Servo Lifting Application

There was a similar case in thread237-220699: Help with hoist application needed
The OP needed a drive for a hoist application and found that the Invertek Optidrive could be used without any encoder and that it did hold the load.

The OP actually came back with a very positive answer: "Gunnar, Thanks for the recommendation of the OptiDrive Plus 3G. We picked one up. We also bought an encoder module for the ABB ACS350 drive we are currently using. Wow! So far, there is absolutely no comparison in performance. The ODP can start from a dead stop and hold the hoist there at our maximum weight. That's very impressive. We're talking with ABB's engineers now. It's hard to belive that a sensorless vector drive can beat out a closed loop vector drive in our hoist application. I really wanted to go with the ABB, but everyone who's seen the two picks th ODP every time."

But don't take my word for it. Read the whole thread.

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
100 % recycled posting: Electrons, ideas, finger-tips have been used over and over again...

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources