×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Increase Very Old Undersized Footing
5

Increase Very Old Undersized Footing

Increase Very Old Undersized Footing

(OP)
I have a 4 story residential building with a very small footing built in the 1920's. The footing size is 16" wide x 5" thick. Is underpinning it with a larger footing the only "practical" way to increase it in width. The major problem is the building has been totally renovated and its at the end of the bank financing it. The Architect never required the existing footing to be checked. The buildings stucco and brick is cracked like a road map. I got the job to inspect it and  remediate from the owners lawyer. Any tips will be greatly appreciated.

RE: Increase Very Old Undersized Footing

Is is possible to add additional new footings rather than increase the size of the existing?  That would be much simpler.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: Increase Very Old Undersized Footing

(OP)
By underpinning the entire continuous footing thats there now I am essentially making it all new.

RE: Increase Very Old Undersized Footing

What about using some piles that a lot basement repair guys use.  They are driven to refusal and seem to work??

RE: Increase Very Old Undersized Footing

OK - continuous footings...

You could use pin pile - 2 " diameter - per a geotech recommendation at the exterior continuous footings, and underpin any interior strip footings periodically along the footing.   

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: Increase Very Old Undersized Footing

I would talk to a specialty contractor who installs Atlas brand resistance piers.  I think that would be a better solution in this situation.

DaveAtkins

RE: Increase Very Old Undersized Footing

(OP)
DaveAtkins

Resistance or Push Piers on a building thats looks ready to collapse and is already a lawsuit against the Architect?? I don't think so.

RE: Increase Very Old Undersized Footing

This is an existing condition and if the use hasn't changed significantly, can the existing footings be left? What does the geotekkie say? We added an additional 4 floors to a building in downtown Toronto that had been founded on spread footings.  Can testing be undertaken that would indicate a higher bearing pressure considering the consolidation that has occurred over time. Was the reason for checking the foundations a consequence of foundation failure? Foundation failure will not likely be catastrophic. Would the owner be accepting of any risk realising that future remedy may be more costly? Would the authority having jurisdiction be satisfied?

I"ve been involved with a few projects that have been standing for the better part of a century and the foundations have been somewhat undersized.

Just some ramblings...

Dik

RE: Increase Very Old Undersized Footing

(OP)
dik

The building is 90 years old and the owner is looking to get another 40 years out of it. The 12" brick walls have no lime mortar left in their joints and the rear wall is on the verge of collapse. Something has to get done ASAP.

RE: Increase Very Old Undersized Footing

OK... then there is major renovation going on and it may be prudent to bring the building up to snuff.

Is there any heritage value to the building and any heritage restraints?

Also SlideRuleEra has a pdf paper on historic masonry that I prepared.  You might want to take a gander at it. If you are planning to maintain the original masonry, you have to examine the issue of vapour barrier and existing mortar.  In old buildings, vapour barrier is not often used and the wall relies on the mortar to 'wick' moisture from within.  In addition, modern lifestyle creates a lot more humidity within a building.  Someone (architect?) should look into this.

Often damage is done to old buildings by a lack of understanding on how they function.

Dik

RE: Increase Very Old Undersized Footing

A 16" wide by 5' thick continuous wall footing under a block wall is very minimal and almost useless.  Helical piers might be a good way to underpin the building.  You would need to get the pier brackets up close to the wall by trimming off the edge of the thin footing.  However, the center to center helical pier spacing may be small because the footing probably is not strong enough to span a reasonable distance between helical piers.

You could also underpin the footing with alternate concrete piers - that is, maybe 4'w x 3' piers spaced at about 8' on center or closer.  This would provide at least the same bearing area, but hopefully at a deeper elevation with better bearing capacity.

However, whatever method you chose, there is the probability that the building will experience some additional settlement and damage. Therefore, you want to make sure the owner is aware of this and that you are not responsible.

RE: Increase Very Old Undersized Footing

Call Hayward Baker.  They do a bunch of this kind of work.  I listened to one of their technical presentations and the work they can do is pretty amazing.  They can fix some pretty gnarly situations.

RE: Increase Very Old Undersized Footing

cap4000,

Why not resistance piers?  Isn't that easier than concrete underpinning?  And perhaps better than helical piers.

DaveAtkins

RE: Increase Very Old Undersized Footing

I think underpinning is the way to go.  At 5" thick, it's likely not reinforced.  Even if you could make it wider, it's probably too thin for the widening to be practical (it may help with bearing pressures, but could easily be a problem for ftg strength for moment and/or shear).
Any piles you can do would likely need to be so close together (because of the 5" thickness of the footing), unless you can assume the wall itself will span between piles and not count on the ftg to do the work, that you will be essentially performing an underpinning operation with piles.  
Just underpin it.

RE: Increase Very Old Undersized Footing

(OP)
My understanding of resisitance or push piers is that its uses the building as a reaction point to get the piers in the ground. The factor of safety is therfore 1.0 and the very old building will also get damaged in the process. Am I correct??

RE: Increase Very Old Undersized Footing

I would start with the premise that there is no footing.  The 16" wide section of thin concrete is just a working mat for construction of the 12" wall.  If you need wider than 12" bearing, I think the wall has to be underpinned.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources