×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

(OP)
Using intersection curve, I have produced a sinusoidal path on the surface of
a cylinder and using sweep cut, I was able to cut a rectangular channel
along the path.
The problem I am having is that the channel does not have a constant width
because the rectangular sketch I am using as a profile to cut with seems to
traverse and slide laterally as it follows the cut path, instead of turning to
always stay normal to the path and create equal width channel. I have tried
multiple combinations of guide curves and swept cut options with no luck.
A picture of the situation is attached.
Help is appreciated!

RE: Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

(OP)
Yes, but have had no luck.  Do you know how the program makes the profile normal to the curve?  When I click most of the sweep dialogue options, the resulting cut does not make sense according to the option chosen so I am wondering what the program is actually doing for a lot of them.  Is it something to do with adding a relation between the path and the profile?

RE: Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

Try the Solid Sweep cut option.

RE: Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

not up to speed on SW's methods that CorB and Eltron mentioned, but if (as it appears from the pic) that you're milling a path for a cam follower or similar, the rectangle that is used for the "cutter profile" has to remain perpendicular to the sinusoidal path; not parallel to one of the principal planes, (such as the front plane).

RE: Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

If Solid Sweep doesn't work, I think williedawg is onto this.  When I do a sweep, I almost always create a plane normal to the sweep's guide curve and sketch my profile on that plane--that way I KNOW it's normal to my cure--at least starting out.

 

Jeff Mowry
www.industrialdesignhaus.com
A people governed by fear cannot value freedom.

RE: Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

(OP)
Thanks for your suggestions everyone.  Making a reference plane normal to the sweeps cut path did the trick.  

The next question I have is if it is possible to use a mathematical equation to create a path on the surface?  Or if it is possible to generate the path in a principal plane and then wrap it around the cylinder surface?

 

RE: Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

Equation driven curve is new in 09' it is only for 2d though.  Put in another vote for 3d curves.

Rob Stupplebeen

RE: Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

It would be possible to generate on any plane that is tangent to the cylinder and then wrap.

-handleman, CSWP (The new, easy test)

RE: Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

Can't we make 3D points from an Excel file (generated by the equation) and then fit a 3D curve through those points?  Wouldn't that do the trick?

- - -Updraft

RE: Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

(OP)
Thanks again for the help.

I used the equation driven curve to generate a 2 cycle sinusoid and tried wrapping it around the surface of a cylinder, however, the wrap function requires a closed spline/curve.  Is there any way to wrap it and then close it on the surface, as the two ends of the curve will be touching?

Also, is it possible to achieve this projection of mathematical curves using the split line function?

RE: Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

You can use the "Projected Curve" Feature (Insert->Curve->Projected from the menu) instead.

It allows to project opened single curve on the surface. In case you have correct curve length which equals to the cylindrical length (2*Pi*r) the two ends of the curve will be in touching.

Artem Taturevich
CSWP

RE: Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

Was able to get this "cutter path" to work in a cylinder model; so if anyone wants to know what I used, I'll post tomorrow or Sunday.
 

RE: Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

(OP)
All,
Thanks for your help.  On Friday I installed SW09 and it seems that the swept cut feature in 09 has a few more options than 08.  The 09 options allowed us to do what we wanted and more.
Thanks again.

RE: Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

Here's what I did to get the "cutter path".
Made 2 Excel files for Curve> Curve Through xyz points.
1) for the sinusoidal path on the cylinder surface, & 2) a second sinusoidal path that is used for the 1st Guide Curve.  
This Guide Curve is what becomes the center of the cutter at depth of cut (DOC).

For instance, I used a sinusoidal wave of amplitude 1.375 and 1.500 radial distance (3" cylinder), then had Excel calculate X & Y values from 0deg to 360.  (it was set up this way so that it will start at 0 and end at 360 with a 3deg increment in the autofill mode of Excel.  Any increment will work as long as it comes out evenly)
Then, those values were converted to Radians and Excel did it's magic.
The Z value was in a third column and the function was; = SIN(angular value in Radians)* Amplitude.
Once all xyz values were generated, just those values were copied and pasted into a txt file in Notepad.

This curve was then Inserted into a model of a cylinder with base at 0,0,0, and Extruded 6" Midplane in the Z direction (Front Plane)

The Guide Curve was similar, however; the radial distance to calculate the x & y values is now 1.375 for the .125" DOC.

All the Z distances are the same as the first curve; but the xy values will change because of this .125 "offset".
The xyx values were copied and pasted into Notepad as before, then this 2nd Guide curve was Inserted into the cylinder model as well.

A Sketch representing the cutter was Inserted into the Right Plane using these Curves and a Pierce relationship to a construction line from the origin.
The 2 curves are shown in blue in this jpg



A Plane was Inserted perpendicular to a Plane from an Axis at the Origin (using the Top and Front Planes) and a Point at where the first Sinusoidal Curve and the Right Plane intersect.

In this Plane (Plane 2) a 3" Circle was Sketched to represent the OD of the cylinder.  Using this Circle, I could confirm the cutter width of .375 the .125" DOC.



And lastly, a Drawing was made to show the dimensions of this feature, and that the sides of the cut are less than .125" because of the geometry at that Section View.



Hope this will help those wanting to construct a Sinusoidal cut.
If anyone wants to see the (abbreviated) Excel file, I've got a jpg of that as well.
I could also make the SLDPRT available too, however it's in SW2006.



 

RE: Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

(OP)
Thanks for that detailed post.

So, I have made multiple types of cuts with varying sinusoidal paths to simulate slow and quick linear motion, but now I am having a problem with mating parts.

I use "Equation Driven Curve" to generate the desired sketh of the path and then wrap that around the cylinder surface.  The cut works great, however, SW09 seems to treat each part of sketch as its own entity even after it's wrapped.  For example, my path is made up of sin(x) and sin(2x) and I can highlight each sinusoid part separately even though they are in the same sketch. This is a problem when I try to mate parts as now I cannot mate a peg to follow completely around the cut path as I can only highlight and mate to one part of the path.  

Is there any way to merge these separate parts so they are treated as one continuous path? Any other suggestions on how to get the peg to follow the entire path?

RE: Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

Put your two parts in a subassy to keep them together then use that subassy to mate to your cam.

- - -Updraft

RE: Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

(OP)
I think my post was a little unclear.

One of the parts in our assembly is a cylinder on which we have a cut a path into for a follower.  This path was created using "Equation Driven Curve," wrapping our curve around the surface of a cylinder and then sweep cutting along the path.  However, I could make the whole cut in one piece, but had to use multiple profiles and sweeps for the different sin equations used, as even though they are in one sketch, SW still treats them separately.  

Now with this cut path in the cylinder, we are trying to mate a follower to the path, but we can only mate it to one sin equation section rather than all of these sections joined together.

Clear as mud?

RE: Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

Although I'm not using the "Equation Driven Curve" method and because I'm still in SW2006; referring to my previous post about Inserting Curve through xyz points, (Excel generated), a Part e.g. cam-follower or pin can be Inserted into an Assembly and mated to the cylinder so as to provide a linear motion as the cylinder is turned.

In an Assembly, Insert an Axis using Top & Right Planes.
Insert the cylinder as a component; mating the cylinder main Axis to this Axis
Mate the Origin of the cylinder to the Front Plane.
This allows rotation of the cylinder.

Make and Insert a Part that represents your cam-follower.

Mate the follower to the cylider & Assembly as shown in this jpg.

When the cylinder is turned, the follower stays in the slot and moves linearly.

RE: Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

...thought I'd clarify a bit more about the mates,

(-) Pin<1>
    Mates in Assem1
       Coincident Axis of (Pin<1>, Right Plane of Assem)
       Parallel1  Axis of (Pin<1>, Front Plane of Assem)
       Tangent3 Side Face of Cut in (Cylinder 3 inch<1>, Cylindrical Face of Pin<1>)
       Coincident6 Face @ Bottom of Cut of (Cylinder 3 inch<1>, Origin of Pin<1>)
 

RE: Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

(OP)
We are performing this exact mating procedure and using the same types of mates.  The problem lies in the fact that the "FACE @ BOTTOM OF CUT" is not continuous and niether is the "SIDE FACE OF CUT"

Maybe this picture will help make things easier to understand...

Notice that I can select the face at bottom of cut for one portion of the channel but I cannot select all of them in one click to make the mating happen for the entire channel.

RE: Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

I played around with this for quite some time and cannot get "wrap" or some other method of placing the curve/cut on the cylindrical surface to work (except for what I've explained earlier)

And again, I'm in SW2006, so I don't have some of the newer methods.

Using "wrap", I could get the Bottom of the cut as one continuous surface and was able to Mate with the Origin of the cam-follower or "pin", but not the side surfaces to the Side Face of the "pin".  I made the length of the Sketch 3*Pi (for a 3"dia cylinder) using a formula in the Dimension box, and rechecked for Tangencies, etc, but still SW made the sides in 3 pieces, which I could not find a way to make as one (??)

http://my.engineering.com/pg/file/williedawg/read/194631/wrapcut-cylinder

 

RE: Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

(OP)
Thanks for playing around with this.

One of the things I have been trying is to merge the ends of the different sinusoidal equation sections but for some reason SW won't allow this and an error box appears simply saying "Cannot merge points" so that's not much help.

Anyone have more advice on why the wrap function treats these sketches like it is doing?

RE: Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

After some more tweaking and experimentation, I got those pesky transition lines out of the Wrap curve cut.

While in the Sketch, Tools>Spline>FitSpline was used to combine the segments that make up the seperate sides of what will be the Cut. Then when the Sketch was Wrapped around the cylinder, and an Assembly made, the sides were now un-interrupted and the "Pin" side Face can be Mated Tangent to one or the other sides.

This all looked nice, until I rotated the cylinder about the main Axis.  The Pin wobbled from left to right as the cylinder rotated.

The only conclusion that I can come to, is that the Wrap is not the thing to use; as that even tho the Sketch was constructed of Spline and then a .500 parallel offset which was also Splined, the resultant slot doesn't allow the Pin centerline to remain vertical.  
For example, if the cylinder were rotated 26deg, the top of the Pin would end up being at an angle of 2.63deg with the Top Plane, and more than 10deg at the worst.



 

RE: Sinusoidal Cut Path on Surface of Cylinder

rollupswx
Thanks for the link.
The Cylindrical Cam tutorial was helpful and resulted in a "cut" that did not cause the axis of the "Pin" to deviate from vertical as was the case with the offset/Wrapped curve.

However, applying the appropiate Mates and then making the Tangent Mate between the Side Surface of the "Pin" and the SideSurface of the Cam, the Cam can only rotate 180deg; there is still the problem of the Surface not being one....even the tutorial shows these lines.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources