×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Differential Settlement of spread footing

Differential Settlement of spread footing

Differential Settlement of spread footing

(OP)
I am adding a column onto an existing spread footing. It is not the bearing capacity that I am worried about but the differential settlement due to additional load that I need to check. Can someone enlighten me how I can check this? How much additional load on a spread footing (in terms of percentage) would aid in differential settlement? Is there a chart with load to settlement that I could use? The footing is a 30'X30' with 2000 kips load on it. I am adding an additional 200 kips to it at 11.5' from centerline of footing. The bearing capacity is 4000 psf.

RE: Differential Settlement of spread footing

This would depend entirely on the layers of soil beneath the footing.  There is no simple or universal answer.  You might get better advice in the Geotechnical Engineering forum.

RE: Differential Settlement of spread footing

A geotechnical engineer should be by your side to read the response here :).

I feel there is a great chance you are over concerned for 2 reasons:

1. If the 2000 kips is the true maximum load the footing has experienced, it produces a soil pressure of 2.22 ksf that is far less than the 4 ksf allowable. In another word, the footing hasn't reached the anticipated settlement permitted in the original criteria, which would not be exceeded even with the 10% added load. (the original assumption/anticipation could be: if all footings in this site being loaded to 4 ksf, a settlement of x" would occur with the max. differential settlement of y". Since the actual pressure is less than the given allowable, thus there is margin left over for add'l load to push towards x", and not exceeding y")

2. The add'l load might produce little or no add'l settlement at all due to effect of consolidation, if the building has been there for a long while.

There may exist other influencing factors I have failed to point out, or your setup is very sensitive even to a slight increase in settlement, check all out with a geotech as recommended.

 

RE: Differential Settlement of spread footing

Aftg= 30x30 = 900 SF
Sftg= 30x302/6 = 4500 feet^3.

Pressure before new column load = 2000/900 = 2.22 ksf

Change in pressure = P/A +- M/S = 200/900 +- 200*11.5/4500
= 0.222 +- 0.511

Max. pressure = 2.22 + 0.222 + 0.511 = 2.95 ksf < 4.0 ksf

Min. pressure = 2.22 + 0.222 - 0.511 =  1.93 ksf >0 < 4.0 ksf

So where's the problem?
 

BA

RE: Differential Settlement of spread footing

There is not a problem with the bearing capacity, as the OP stated, and assuming that the original load is symmetrical.  But with this amount of eccentricity of the added load, there could still be a differential settlement (tilting) issue, which depends on the soil structure and the time periods involved.  Probably not a problem with a great big footing, but anytime I add 200 kips to a footing, I think reevaluation is appropriate.  I worry more about settlements than bearing capacity.  

RE: Differential Settlement of spread footing

hokie,

The OP would have to talk it over with the geotech on the job.  They may want to compensate for the eccentricity of loading.  The eccentricity of the load is 200*11.5/(2000 + 200) = 1.05', so by attaching a strip 2' x 30' with epoxy and rebar on the proper side, the centroid is moved one foot over and concentricity (if that is a word) is once again restored.  

Personally, I don't think I would worry much about it but neither did the guy who designed the tower in Pisa.

BA

RE: Differential Settlement of spread footing

The allowable bearing capacity generally allows for limiting the settlement.

RE: Differential Settlement of spread footing

I had a similar situation with a wall and a bridge footing. The bridge footing was on a flowable fill mix and the wall footing was not. The geotech report said max settlement 1/4" for both. The question was asked about why we didnt use flowable fill below the wall, and what the differential settlement would be. I said the wall footing is not close to max bearing pressure, and that at max bearing capacity it would all be settling 1/4" max. So I gave a answer of the ratio of my actual bearing capacity and the allowable times a 1/4". Is this what is going on here, since the bearing capacity is not met, there is no differential settlement, just settlement overall?

Kinda long winded, hope you can understand

RE: Differential Settlement of spread footing

No. It does not mean no differential settlement when given bearing capacity has not exceeded, but the quantity of such difference is in general within allowable/tollerance.

RE: Differential Settlement of spread footing

(OP)
Thanks a lot people for your input. I have decided to use Meyerhof's formula to determine settlements based on the bearing pressures that I calculated to see how bad of differential settlements we are talking about. Somehow, the geotechnical engineer has not got back to me yet on this. But if he does not, I will just calculate differential settlements based on Meyerhof's equation and feel satisfied if they are within allowable. So, any comments on this? Has anybody used this before this way?

RE: Differential Settlement of spread footing

I will leave it to the geotech. But wouldn't hurt if you want to try. Watch out for overlapping if there are other footings are close by.

RE: Differential Settlement of spread footing

The next question...even if you can accurately predict the amount of differential settlement, how much is acceptable?  Over a width of 30', 1/4" or 1/2" differential settlement is not very significant.  Or is it?

BA

RE: Differential Settlement of spread footing

csd72 - allowable bearing capacity does not limit, in my view, settlement - it limits the stresses induced with respect to shear.  Net allowable bearing pressure limits settlement (serviceability).  I know some will argue but I think this makes a clear distinction between selecting the design pressure based on shear or on limiting settlements.
  Estimating settlements are not an exact science - you can use the same basis and several different methods (see Som and Das 'Theory and Practice of Foundation Design').  For permissible differential settlements, Tomlinson and others have identified permissible rotations for various types of structures.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources