×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

fan selection based on static pressure

fan selection based on static pressure

fan selection based on static pressure

(OP)
Hi Everybody
Sorry to take you back to thread 403-43928 by VEEKRISH AND TO THREAD 403-31557 by juan2025...My question is :
I want to pressurize a building by adding an intake fan and Iam calculating the fan cfm based on equation:
P1V1=P2V2
P1=ATMOSPHERIC PRESSURE
V1=VOLUME OF BUILDING
P2=STATIC PRESSURE TO BE ACHIEVED(O.5")im my case
V2=OVERALL VOLUME OF AIR NEEDED.
Now don't we need T1 AND T2 ?Why it is not P1V1/T1=P2V2/T2?
The temp. of air doesn't count here?
Thanks

RE: fan selection based on static pressure

Nope.  Size the fan on the amount of leakage you expect.  If the building is leaking 1000 cfm, size the fan for that  + 10%.  You can see that it is really quite simple.  Temperature is negligible, especially since the building's temperature will soon = outside air temperature with all the air you will be pumping through it (unless you have a really robust A/C unit).

RE: fan selection based on static pressure

(OP)
Thank you trashcanman..but please try to calculate with me.Suppose the building volume =1500ft3 and the ambient temp.=90 and the internal temp =75F( to be acieved by A/C UNIT).NOW taking temp into consideration and applying to the formula:
P1V1/T1=P2V2/T2
10000*V/90=10010.16(eq.to 0.4"s.p.)*1500/75   GIVES V=1801.8 FT3
1801.8-1500=301.8 FT3
fan should be 301.8 +leakage+10%safety factor
but if we don't take temp. into consideration:
P1V1=P2V2
10000*V=10010.16*1500  GIVES  1501.5 FT3
1501.5-1500=1.5 FT3  compare it to the 301.8  doesn't that make quite a difference?????

RE: fan selection based on static pressure

You should be careful to work with absolute units. Convert the temperature to absolute units and then you will get about 40 cu.ft more.

The reason why you have to ignore the temperature is the air coming inside the room is always at 75F. The pressure builds up as you go on pumping air inside. So, 1500 cu.ft of air flows in (cool air as it comes from AHU) and room will be at atmospheric pressure. If you pump in more air (at 70F) then pressure rises. You are not allowing the air to heat up for sufficient time as you are continuously renewing it.

Once you provide 1.5 cu.ft of extra volume inside the room, the room pressure builds up to 0.4" but then since the room pressure is more than the surroundings, air leaks out into low pressure areas. The leak rate is quite significant than the quantity required to pressurize a completely sealed room. That is the reason you need not use the PV = C formula.  

RE: fan selection based on static pressure

My opinion here is, that you can not use these formulas like PV=contant or PV/T= constant or even PV/T=Rs*m. These formulas are for closed systems and yours is leaking.

RE: fan selection based on static pressure

(OP)
Thanks quark and hollandhvac
quark why did you assume air coming inside the room is always at 75F  .I want to clarify that air is entered through a pressurization fan and so the air entered will be at ambient temp. until it is conditioned by the AHU. and I don't understand your second point about not allowing the air to heat up. This second point doesn't support the idea of taking the temp. into consideration in our calculations?
quark what is your reply about hollandhvac comment that we can't use these formulas in this case.This is really an issue.
Regards

RE: fan selection based on static pressure

You must have a control (closed) volume for pv=nrt to work. The reason it is called the perfect gas law is that it doesn't work very well for imperfect gasses, which air is.

 

RE: fan selection based on static pressure


The equation that applies to a leaking building would be:

dP = 1/2 x density x v^2 x z

for each and every leak in the building...

The pressure-difference dP will result in a flow of air through the leak at flow-velocity v with resistance factor z put in to take into account the shape/form of the leak.

In other words: Impossible to calculate...

All you can do is make an estimate on the leak or run a test with a fan you have at hand and measure the airflow and pressuredifferece it creates inside the building and then scale up to the required pressure-difference using dP=1/2 x density x v^2
 

RE: fan selection based on static pressure

Or you can do a blower door test, or more simply look up data on blower door tests done on buildings with similar construction.

Read this to get started.  Everything you ever wanted to know about infiltration:
http://epb.lbl.gov/Publications/lbl-35173.pdf

RE: fan selection based on static pressure

At any instance, the volume of air contained in a pressurised room, under steady state conditions, can be calculated by using PV = C and there is absolutely no reason as to why you shouldn't use it. What HollandHVAC says that the formula is inappropriate to calculate leak rates.

Secondly, pressure is not built up in the fan but in the room as you restrict the return air flow (once the room is pressurised then fan considers this as system resistance and then develops the required static). As the room entry temperature will be more or less constant, you can ignore temperature effect.



 

RE: fan selection based on static pressure


> Read this to get started.  Everything you ever wanted to know about infiltration:
> http://epb.lbl.gov/Publications/lbl-35173.pdf

Note how Equation 8 on page 13 of the above mentioned document contains a reworked form of the equation I mentioned in my earlier post (dP = 1/2 x density x v^2 x z).


 

RE: fan selection based on static pressure

quark wrote:

> At any instance, the volume of air contained in a
> pressurised room, under steady state conditions,
> can be calculated by using PV = C

The volume of air will be constant as I do not think the room will be changing size.

The amount (mass) of air inside the room will have to change in order to raise the pressure inside.

Questions to delimashare:
- does the building consist of individual rooms or is it one large space?
- do you need to control the pressure?


PS: I just glanced over the other two threads the original poster mentioned: boy, this topic has evoked some discussion in the past! Interesting to see how people can end up thinking totally the wrong way about something with respect to the physics involved.
 

RE: fan selection based on static pressure

If you want to be precise, I am talking about the standard cubic feet(volume of air reduced to 14.696 psia pressure) and not actual cubic feet (room volume at given pressure). The reason why I didn't say it specifically is that it can cause more confusion to the OP.

In layman's terms, a 1500 cu.ft room should be filled with approximately 1545 cu.ft (at atmospheric pressure) of air to raise the room pressure to 0.4" wg when there are no leaks.

If you feel something wrong with the above threads, you can start with your views in a separate thread.

RE: fan selection based on static pressure

Please read you can start as please startblush

RE: fan selection based on static pressure


My comment on the other threads was merely a sign of my amazement that the topic resulted in such a lengthy discussion whereas in my personal opinion the practical problem of putting pressure in a room is a rather trivial one. I'm sure you will agree that any fair discussion of different views is a good one.

> In layman's terms, a 1500 cu.ft room should be filled
> with approximately 1545 cu.ft (at atmospheric pressure)
> of air to raise the room pressure to 0.4" wg when there
> are no leaks.

I agree, it can be helpfull to put things in terms that are easy to understand.

However, the amount of air needed to pressurize a room is in my view a piece of information that is irrelevant to the OP and the problem he has to solve.

My startingpoint is usually a difference between supply- and extraction airflow of 1 or 2 times the roomvolume, so 1 or 2 AirChanges per Hour.

And you have to make sure the buildingcontractor does his best to minimize leaks in the room/building.
 

RE: fan selection based on static pressure

There is nothing to disagree with you and you are correct. Volumetric increase in room volume is insignificant and it is already mentioned above by me and other posters.

Regarding other threads, it was my sincere request to know your views and no hard feelings from my side. There is a problem posting my replies today and so I replied in haste. That is why it took me a second post to correct it. Why I said a separate thread is because the earlier threads are already locked.

Individual experience and knowledge are what making these forums so lively. We all benefit from each other.

RE: fan selection based on static pressure

Quark,

> Regarding other threads, it was my sincere request to know your views and no hard feelings from my side.

I see. To be honest, I was a bit unsure myself whether or not I had stepped on anyone's (quark's?) toes when I made my remarks on the other threads. If so, it was of course unintentional and I appologise.

> Individual experience and knowledge are what making
> these forums so lively. We all benefit from each other.

I could not agree more !!

Now all we need to know if all this was any help to the OP... smile

delimashare, please let us know




 

RE: fan selection based on static pressure

(OP)
Thanks to all of you.I really need some time to go all through your replies in this thread and in previous ones.
Write to you soon.
 

RE: fan selection based on static pressure

(OP)

I am really glad with all this feedback. Thank you all very much.

Actually the application (function) of the building is highly technical. There are electrical equipments running in this building, which explains my worries and concerns. Calculations here are very critical.

Zesti .About your questions, here is my answer:
1.    The building consists of three different buildings(one of them is the building we are talking about) .Those 3 buildings are attached to each other in series, and there is a door connecting building 1 to 2 and building 2 to 3.
2.    The control of pressure is of high importance here.

Now. The information you all provided is very helpful. Still I would like to go further and ask you kindly for more support.

Quark.
1. Where did you get the 14696psi from?
2. Your comment about not allowing the air to heat up for sufficient time makes me think:
What is the role of the A/C unit here? I need the room to be maintained at 75F all the time.
Specially that there are huge amounts of air supplied to(and exhausted from) the building, OTHER than the air supplied by the pressurization fan.

Zesti.
1. I am not sure if I understand your point about allowing 1-2 air changes/hr as a difference between supply and extraction.
Let's calculate
2air changes/hr * 1500ft3(room volume) =3000ft3/hr.
So, based on existing EQUAL supply and exhaust in the building, the capacity of our pressurization fan should be around 3000ft3/hr?

KiwiMace
Frankly saying I had no chance to read (The use of blower door data). I WILL for sure and thanks.

I hope I will come up with a summary after all and share it with all of you.

Regards
delimashare
 

RE: fan selection based on static pressure

Quark, can you believe it was seven years ago when we were talking about this?

delimashare, you referenced those threads - did you read through them? I'm just curious. If you did, I'd hope you woundn't be sizing a fan based on P1V1=P2V2...

RE: fan selection based on static pressure

CB,

Welcome back. I agree, time is flying. I remember that I had jet black hair that time and now it is half grey (chromatically), though not sure about how much wisdom I picked up all these days.

BTW, I sincerely feel this forum is missing you. Seems you have been busy for quite some time.

RE: fan selection based on static pressure

Just from my experience, in-line with the previous posts, when trying to pressurize a space, the airflow design (differential between supply and exhaust)is usually based on a guess on the amount of leakage.

The differential is confirmed after the room has been constructed by testing leakage with a blower door set-up.

The differential airflows are adjusted based on the findings of the blower door test.

RE: fan selection based on static pressure

> 1. The building consists of three different buildings
> ..
> and there is a door connecting building 1 to 2 and
> building 2 to 3.

If the doors are relatively "airtight" and are kept closed as much as possible then you only need to consider the one building you need to pressurize.

> 2. The control of pressure is of high importance here.

In that case I would take a fixed amount as the supply to the building and put a VAV-system in the exhaust.
Frequency-controlled fans on both AHU's. The VAV-valves would be controlled by a differentialpressure-sensor.
The frequency-control on the fans would be regulated to a constant pressure in the duct.

> What is the role of the A/C unit here?
> I need the room to be maintained at 75F all the time.

If by A/C-unit you mean the AHU: like I said, maintain the supply at constant flow, vary the supply-temperature to control the room-temperature.

> Specially that there are huge amounts of air
> supplied to(and exhausted from) the building,
> OTHER than the air supplied by the pressurization fan.

Are you talking about a separate fan just for pressurization? You do not need that if you already have an AHU for ventilating the building.

> 1. I am not sure if I understand your point about
> allowing 1-2 air changes/hr as a difference
> between supply and extraction.

Like Walkes says, you need to guess at the "leakiness" of the room/building. 1-2 air changes/hr is just my first guess.
If, for instance, you are already using 6 ac/hr for the ventilation/temperaturecontrol of the building then this could all end up leaking from the building at the desired pressure. Then there would be nothing left to do for you exhaust fan. If 1 or 2 air changes/hr is the leak-flow from the building then your exhaust system needs to take care of the remaining 4-5 ac/hr.
The calculation you make is indeed what I mean.

It's like this:

                      ^      ^  leaks (unknown)
                      |      |
                  ------------------
  fixed          | room/building    |     variable
  air supply --->|                  |---> exhaust
  (AHU)          | pressure build-up|     (AHU)
                 |                  |
                  ------------------
 

RE: fan selection based on static pressure


Oh, the picture I tried to make looked better when I was typing it...
 

RE: fan selection based on static pressure

Quark - thanks for the positive note! I have been busy but try to stop in and keep involved when I can.

Walkes I agree w/your last post.

Zesti, I've yet to see a VAV exhaust matched with a CAV supply, but it doesn't mean it can't be done. Would probably depend which is more critical (supply or exhaust).
 

RE: fan selection based on static pressure

@ChasBean1:

> I've yet to see a VAV exhaust matched with a CAV supply,
> but it doesn't mean it can't be done. Would probably depend
> which is more critical (supply or exhaust).

I'm afraid I don't quite understand what you mean.

The VAV on the exhaust is controlled by the measured room-pressure.

I would want CAV on the supply-side because supply is based on, for example, heatload, number of people in the building, some health/safety requirement etc.

Anyway, main point being that the exhaust flow is controlled according to the room-pressure.
 

RE: fan selection based on static pressure

(OP)

Thank you all very much.

ChasBean1. I understand that leakage has the biggest effect on pressure . I am not sizing the fan based on p1v1=p2v2.  I just don't want to miss anything in my calculations. No matter how small it is.

walkes ,KiwiMace, Zesti.  The application of BLOWER DOOR TEST and its relation to the (guessed ac/hr) are clear to me now.


ChasBean1 and Zesti.  Before proceeding in discussing the CAV and VAV,I would like to explain that my intension was to use a separate pressurizing fan in order to be able to pressurize the building in case of gas leakage while all other equipments including the A/C(A.H.U.)are controlled to stop running.

Talking about which is more critical here supply or exhaust. I would like to clarify that there are electrical equipments in the room which needs a fixed rate of air supply (specified in data sheet) in order to run properly.

I feel that Iam giving you the information in pieces. I apologize. I was thinking of simplifying things.
Is there anything I can do to give you a better idea about the case.

 

RE: fan selection based on static pressure

I don't know where to go from here. Size your supply to meet heat loads and fresh air flow per occupant needs; have your exhaust track about 10% lower initially by some means. That value can be adjusted as you see fit for pressure control. Also consider sealing and door gaskets and sweeps to get a certain DP if offsets become too large during adjustment.

RE: fan selection based on static pressure

(OP)

Thank you ChasBean1
I will calculate and come up with real figures.
Please What do you mean by (heat loads) in your sentence (Size your supply to meet heat loads and fresh air ...) .The pressurizing fan here is A SEPARATE fan; it not the HVAC fan.
Do I understand you correctly?

ChasBean1 , Zesti
Back to the VAV and CAV any more explanation!

Is it possible to add to the system :
1. a space pressure sensor controlling a relief fan with a frequency drive?
 OR
2. to add a barometric relief damper? and which is better ?and why?
 
You are all challenging me.Thanks
 

RE: fan selection based on static pressure


Do you need the pressure in the building to be at a required minimum level at all times?

I mean, if the level of pressure is important, you need some sort of control.

You say you have separate systems for ventilation/AC and pressurisation.

The amount of air going through the AC-system will vary over time when the filters get more and more dust in them.
This will influence the pressure of the building and the separate pressurisation-system needs to be able to adapt.
Even more so if this systems needs to work when the AC is switched off.

If all you are going to have is a supply-fan for pressurisation then you need it to be frequency-controlled according to pressure in the building.
 

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources