Measuring "Heat Input" for weld procedures
Measuring "Heat Input" for weld procedures
(OP)
ASME B&PV Section IX, 409.1, lists "Heat Input" as a supplementary essential variable, and lists two or three different ways of measuring, with the limitation that the qualified heat input can't be exceeded in production welding. With manual flux-core welding, what is the normal procedure for measuring this?
The first option involves monitoring travel speed, which implies someone sitting there with a ruler and a stopwatch. The second option involves calculating bead size, which implies measuring actual weld gap and bead depth to calculate the area. Last option is measuring electrode usage per length of weld, which would be awkward with a wire-feed welder. So in practice, what is actually done?
I assume from a brief search, that it is heat input per pass which is considered, as opposed to cumulative.
The first option involves monitoring travel speed, which implies someone sitting there with a ruler and a stopwatch. The second option involves calculating bead size, which implies measuring actual weld gap and bead depth to calculate the area. Last option is measuring electrode usage per length of weld, which would be awkward with a wire-feed welder. So in practice, what is actually done?
I assume from a brief search, that it is heat input per pass which is considered, as opposed to cumulative.





RE: Measuring "Heat Input" for weld procedures
The third option works well for SMAW or GTAW, where the electrode is a standard length. It's just a comparison to your deposited bead length.
IMO, the second option only works well for automatic welding, after the piece has been sectioned and etched at the given V and A settings. How else can you adequately measure thickness?
RE: Measuring "Heat Input" for weld procedures
meet Sect IX rules?
heat input: is it not the relationship V/A in your machine?
fairly new machines have gages to read both V/A and if your machine gages are accurate there is not reason for not using them for the purpose of complying with the Code.
RE: Measuring "Heat Input" for weld procedures
http://www.tvcalx.co.uk/ALX.htm
Strictly, V*A*60/Travel Speed (distance per minute), is the 'arc energy' and not the "heat input".
Steve Jones
Materials & Corrosion Engineer
http://www.linkedin.com/pub/8/83b/b04
RE: Measuring "Heat Input" for weld procedures
Not sure where you are getting your information but ASME IX QW 409.1 states "Heat Input = Volts x Amps x 60 divided by Travel Speed."
AWS D1.1 Table 4.6 states exactly the same thing.
Cheers,
BB
RE: Measuring "Heat Input" for weld procedures
Steve Jones
Materials & Corrosion Engineer
http://www.linkedin.com/pub/8/83b/b04
RE: Measuring "Heat Input" for weld procedures
SJones- I don't think the distinction on the efficency would matter, because we're welding the qualification test with the exact same equipment we'll be doing production welding. It doesn't matter at all to us what the absolute number is, just so we don't exceed it in production.
On the monitors, I don't see that there's a way to adapt them for semiautomatic (IE, handheld) welding, which is the problem.
RE: Measuring "Heat Input" for weld procedures
Your amps, vots and travel speed will be recorded on the PQR.(Amps / Volts should be recorded with an ammeter/voltmeter, not reading what is showing on the machine)
The travel speed is usually recorded with a tape measure, usually 15 seconds and then multiplied by 4 to give you a speed per minute.
From that you can calculate your heat input (J/in - J/mm or Kj/in - Kj/mm)
Your minimum and maximum heat input will then be a known figure that will be listed on your WPS.
If you are in a workshop environment it is quite easy to set all the machines (volts and wire feed speed)and then you just have to ensure that none of the welding operators weld any slower than the slowest travel speed on the WPS.
Finally, remember if the work you are doing does not require impact testing then heat input is not an essential variable.
Hope that helps,
Cheers,
BB
RE: Measuring "Heat Input" for weld procedures
You don't have to. Look at the datasheets in the link that I posted. The monitors are fully applicable to semiautomatic FCAW
Steve Jones
Materials & Corrosion Engineer
http://www.linkedin.com/pub/8/83b/b04
RE: Measuring "Heat Input" for weld procedures
And thanks for the input, everyone.
RE: Measuring "Heat Input" for weld procedures
Steve Jones
Materials & Corrosion Engineer
http://www.linkedin.com/pub/8/83b/b04