×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Torsion of Cruciform Column

Torsion of Cruciform Column

Torsion of Cruciform Column

(OP)
I've got a cruciform shaped column; a W27x84 crossed by a W14x53. I'm trying to check torsion, but am unsure how to determine the torsional constant, J.  Do I simply add the two together? Any guidance on what to do would be much appreciated.  Thanks!  

RE: Torsion of Cruciform Column

I am not sure but I would think that J is the summation of bt^3/3. However, for the sections given, I would think that the majority of the resistance might be in warping since the flanges are like wings out away from the CG.  

RE: Torsion of Cruciform Column

I would use the method Jike stated.
The result would be interesting. Remember the proposed twisted spire building in Chicago?

RE: Torsion of Cruciform Column

Check ths against the sum of the two, I expect it would end up the same.

RE: Torsion of Cruciform Column

Article 13.3.2 of CSA S16-01 handles Torsional or Torsional-Flexural Buckling.  In particular, it addresses doubly symmetric cruciform sections.

I do not know what the equivalent section in AISC would be but I would expect it is there.  If you can't find it or get access to the Canadian code, I will try to copy it for you.

Best regards,

BA

RE: Torsion of Cruciform Column

(OP)
Thank you everyone for your help.  I've actually figured it out.  In my research I've discovered that to determine the Shear Stress in the column it's much easier, and more accurate, to use Torsional Resistance, R, rather than the torsional constant, J.

shear stress = Tc/R ...look similar to Mc/I? It should.  

T is the Torque, c is the distance from the center of the section to the outer fiber and R is the Torsional Resistance.

To determine R(total) of the cruciform it needs to be broken down into it's 6 solid rectangular sections. Then the R for each rectangle can be determined using R=(beta)*b*d^3, where beta is based off the b/d ratio. Then just sum them up!

Hope this helps us all learn something new.  

Have a good one!

RE: Torsion of Cruciform Column

K:

Can you elaborate a little on derivation of beta, and its significance. I am somehow getting lost.

RE: Torsion of Cruciform Column

(OP)
Absolutely!  I'll attach some scans here in just a moment for you.  It should help explain.  Gimme just a sec...   

RE: Torsion of Cruciform Column

(OP)
Okay, attached is a page from the text book I used.  It has the table to determine beta based on b/d.  I also attached my calc of the cruciform section as an example for you.  Note that 'b' is the long side of rectangle and 'd' is the shorter side regardless of it's orientation, unlike when determining moment of inertia, I, orientation is crucial.  I hope this helps you and if you have any other questions let me know... I've been studying up on this for a few days now, so I practically feel like an expert!

Enjoy the day!

RE: Torsion of Cruciform Column

kisshenry,

I recognize the page from "Design of Steel Structures" by Blodgett.  Please note one point, however.  The term 'J' in that book represents polar moment of inertia, not the torsional constant which we now call 'J'.  In most cases of I-Beams, channels and angles comprised of flat plate elements, the term beta is close enough to 1/3, so that there is no serious error in using J instead of R.

 

Best regards,

BA

RE: Torsion of Cruciform Column

(OP)
Thanks BAretired!  I didn't notice that... good catch!  ;o)

RE: Torsion of Cruciform Column

Ok, I think BA is right on the mark again.

According to "Structural Engineering Handbook" by Gaylord & Gaylord, the "torsional stiffness (constant)" for a rectanglar shape is "[(b*t63)/3]*[1-0.63*(t/b)+0.052(t/b)^2]"; "t<b". For b >> t, this eq reduces to b*t^3/3.

K & BA, thanks for the opportunity to review the basics.

RE: Torsion of Cruciform Column

kisshenry,

Just one more point respecting this thread.  You calculated that the column was not adequate to resist a particular torsion.  However, you did not address the axial capacity of the column and it is important to note that there are three ways in which such a column can buckle, about each principal axis and torsionally.

CSA S16-1 addresses torsional buckling for this shape and I am sure that AISC does as well, but I do not have that document so can't say for sure.

Best regards,

BA

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources