×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

(OP)
Hello All,

A couple of gensets will be operated at a constant load for 1500 hours a year on a 16h/day scheme. Engines are GM industrial powertrain Vortec 5.7L (350 cu.in), 8.1L (496 cu.in) and 8.1LT (496 cu.in, turbocharged), fired with Natural Gas and load is about 80%, 65% and 75% of standby rating respectively (see below).

The question is: what would be the expected engine life at the above conditions? By expected life I mean the time between major overhauls, with a decrease in the initial output power of no more than 10% to 12%. Of course, very close maintenance programs would be performed on these units. Is it nonsense to expect 13000 to 15000 hrs engine life, before having to overhaul it?

Additional application data:

GM Vortec 8.1LT-based genset
Actual Load=120kVA
Rated Standby power=163kVA
Rated Prime power=144kVA

GM Vortec 8.1L-based genset
Actual load=65kVA
Rated Standby power=94kVA
Rated Prime power=101kVA

GM Vortec 5.7L-based genset
Actual Load=60kVA
Rated Standby power=69kVA
Rated Prime power=75kVA

I've been trying to find an answer to this during the past three weeks, but I only got confused replies from prospect suppliers.

Does anybody know where I can find this info or has an answer for my question? Any help will be greatly appreciated.

Thanks!
Ernesto.

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

Sounds like you need better suppliers, they should be in the best position to know expected life.  Have you tried to get a hold of GM about this?

Assuming these are 1800 rpm units, you're running 100-140 psi BMEP on these engines.  Turbocharged engines built to run continuously on natural gas typically operate at 145-175 psi BMEP and the heads/top ends will last 16,000-24,000 hrs.  I don't know if they've beefed up the heads for this type of service but 15,000 hrs sounds a little high to me.  

We do rebuild these type of engines, I'll talk to some people around the shop and see if they've got a typical lifespan for you.

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

Please do not post the same question in multiple forums. Instead provide a link here to the other forum you posted the same question, as itsmoked suggested in other forum. So that all answers are in one place.

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

Ernesto
Using your numbers (1500hrs X 60MPH =90000 miles per year)This 5X what a normal auto should see in a year.

I work for a GM industrial engine distibutor and the GM factory warrentee is for 36 months or 3500 hours.

We have some engines that have been running 24/7 for 3 to 4 years with no major problems. So,I don't think it's unreasonable to expect 7500 to 10000 hours. I think that 13000 to 15000 hours is quite a lot to expect.

If there is any thing I can do to help please let me know

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

(OP)
Bribyk: Unfortunately, both genset manufacturers gave me completely different figures. One stated "about 10000hrs" and the other one "17000hrs".

All engines are 1800rpm, but there's something I don't understand: you say the heads/top ends will last 16000 to 24000 hrs, so why 15000 seem too much to you?

More or less the same question to Fmangas: 3 years @ 24/7 wouldn't mean 26000 hrs?

thanks!

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

The heads that will last 16-24000 hrs are on engines that were specifically made for the fuel and continuous operation (Caterpillar, Waukesha, Superior, etc...).  Even then the heads are an issue and very touchy about what oil you use and the quality of the gas.  These GM engines are being run fairly hard at a low speed (compared to automotive, almost lugging).  

Word around here is about 18 months to 2 years is best case for these engines and this may include a cylinder head swap or two in that time.  Usually, the valves recess into the head which bottoms out the lifters and wipes out the cam shaft.  At that point, for the price of these engines they are pulled out and replaced with an exchange long block.  15,000 hours doesn't sound unreasonable but that will likely include a top end overhaul.

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

The standard GM warrentee is for 3 years or 3000 hours and thats what we limit our liability to.

I used the 3 years @ 24/7 as an example of what the engines are capable of. Will all GM engines last this long no, If there taken care of (Regular preventive maintenance, quality fuel, and properly adjusted fuel system)They are quite capable of a long life.

As to why the heads are usually the first to go Natural gas and LPG are dry fuels. There is no cooling property as there is with Gasoline. This tends to make the entire combustion area hotter then normal. If the fuel quality varies and the fuel system isn't adjusted to compensate. The exhaust seat gets too hot and starts to transfer metal from the seat to the valve. When the valve cools the metal particles fall off. This is when valve recession occurs.  

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

Don't take this the wrong way, Fmangas.  I'm not knocking your product in any way, just giving our experience with these applications.  All of the gas engines have valve and head issues.

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

I completely agree with you everyone has head and valve problems. There usually caused by poor maintenance, poor quality fuel, and lack of proper fuel system adjustments.

If you take care of the above problems on any engine you generally will get a good life span.

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

(OP)
The units will be operated with natural gas from the a distribution network supplying some steel mills and other industrial activities in the area. Everybody says the gas is of good and constant quality (but I don't have any figures or quality parameters).

Assuming we change oil every 250hrs, install double oil filters and oversized cooling system, plus we monitor the systems remotely for temp. gas consumption, power output, running hours... will you trust these units will last up to 13000hrs? What would be the expected head life in the above scenario?

I'm pushing both prospect suppliers to give a clear indication of expected life and I'm asking a couple of other manufacturers for quotes and info... will post any relavant data I'll get.

Thanks to both of you for your help!

 

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

You're basically asking for ten years TBO for piston engines in two-shift duty.  

I think that's, um, overly optimistic.

I'd distrust anyone who said it was likely.





 

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

In industrial terms, these engines are cheap.  Around here they are rarely monitored and an operator will usually just stop by to see if they're still running or not and whether there's oil in it.  Don't go overboard trying to make them last forever, there's a point of diminishing returns where it's cheaper just to junk it and swap in a new longblock.  We rarely rebuild them here, just buy a longblock and swap over the auxiliary and custom parts.   

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

Is there some reason you don't just put in one gas turbine?  That'll get you those hours no problem, and with little maintenance too.

Keith Cress
kcress - http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

(OP)
Yes, I know these are not the perfect engines for the job, but the combination of required power output and working hours a year seem to be in "gray area" where automotive-derivate engines are too stressed and industrial engines are to expensive (the application requires a low cost solution, but it still has to make financial sense).

We also analyzed the microturbines, but they seem to make sense financially for applications with more than 5000hrs/year.

I'm getting the sense I'll have to choose between using "cheap" engines and hope they don't fail too often or use industrial engines and not maintain them as thoroughly as I should...

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

Bribyk nails it on the head, around here, in Northern British Columbia, there are a good number of GM industrial Vortec, and Ford industrials running small gen sets, and when they stop running, a replacement long block is put in, and old one tossed in the recycle bin.  Sounds wasteful, but this makes the most economic sense here.  
You have to pay attention to your fuel composition. If the Butane levels are relatively high, then the engines can detonate, and obviously, not survive for long. If the fuel you are proposing to use is "sales gas", make sure it indeed is, and have a composition test done.  This will help determine optimum ignition timing.  As the engines "age", the savvy field mechanics here will retard the timing a bit at each maintenance inspection to ward off detonation. At the end of their usefull life, the power will drop off to the limit of acceptability, but at least they won't ping to death.
Same goes for A/F ratio.  Have it checked once and a while, as the turbocharged 8.1L is quite sensitive to detonation, if run on the rich side.

Robin Sipe.

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

Also consider using all GM Vortec 8.1L-based gensets.

Not a 5.7.  Then one long block will go into any one of them.

Alternatively could you get a deal on 4 sets - one as a spare.

Then if one needs service there is no panicked rush required.

Keith Cress
kcress - http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

(OP)
Firts of all, thanks to everybody, you've been of great help (much more than the suppliers!)

Robin: do you have any figures of how often you change the longblocks and what is their % load with respect to prime power? This info would be extremely helpful.

So far the manufacturers either don't give a straight answer or just stick to the book, i.e. they just say the engine can't be operated continuously above 65% rated prime power.

One of them said they can endorse using the genset 8hrs/day at 100% rated prime power, but above that point they want me to downrate the genset. He didn't however tell me what would be the expected life of the engine should I make it work at our conditions...

So far, the informal information I have points to what Brybik said: maximum 6000 hrs total life and one head swap in between

Later today I'll call a major GM engine integrator to see what they tell me, I'll post the reply.

Thanks again,
Ernesto.
 

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

ebarba; Tough one to pin down, due to so many variables, but here where I live, on average, the automotive based industrial longblocks are changed out every 1.5 years. (If run 24/7, with regularily scheduled maintenance.) In your case @ 1500 Run Hours/Year, perhaps you might expect eight years service, IF the units are run on "good" fuel, and maintained well.

Robin Sipe.

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

(OP)
Thanks Robin, that is very valuable data!

Yesterday I called one of the biggest GM engine integrators in the US, they told me they really don't see any problem with the units lasting up 6000 hrs, but they want me to talk to another person today.

Here in Italy the gas quality should be good, but I'm asking the distribution company for a composition sheet to be sure

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

ebarba
If you haven't already, you may want to talk to the guy's at Rama Motori. They have experience in your country with Industrial (GM,John Deere, and Briggs) gensets

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

Good luck with your composition sheet.  I tried to get some defined limits from my gas distributor and they don't have any hard limits, what you get is what you get.  The various levels of suppliers will blend the gas to keep it near the distributor's contract values but there's no guarantee on what comes out the end of the pipe.  I did get last year's high and low BTU values from my distributor but that doesn't mean it's going to be the same this year.  It "should" be good gas but unless you sample yourself there's no way to tell.

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

I am surprised that no-one has mentioned valve rotation. International Harvester used to instruct users to remove the positive valve rotators for propane service. Any valve rotation and the valve will grind its way into the seat.
And you may consider reviewing your loads and reporting in kW instead of KVA. Not the same. Depends on the characteristics of the load. KVA describes the capacity of the alternator but kW describes the power of the motor and the load on the motor. Generator/alternator KVA is typically 125% of engine kW. That's the rating. The actual values depend on the load and its characteristics.
kW will never by more than KVA but KVA is often more than kW. Sometimes a lot more.
 

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

(OP)
Bill, The engine integrator says the heads have been modified for NG-Propane operation by using specific material as well as oversize components, but I don't know if they remove the valve rotators, I'll check with them next monday.

On the other hand, I've been reporting kVA power because, as far as I know, the engine will have to supply it and not only the real component (kW). It made sense to me, since the total energy (which should be real+reactive) has to come from somewhere and that's the prime mover. I'm not an expert in electricity issues... can someone confirm this?

Ernesto.

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

ebarba if the integrator you're talking to isn't [/i]Buck's Engines[/i], you might try them as well for some more real world experience.

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

Ebarba
Be careful of anyone who says they change the heads or any components on a new engine. This will immediately void the GM warranty. I have came across the integrator you are talking about. I have taken there heads apart and they have standard GM parts.

The heads that come from GM are already equipped with hardened seats, different valves, and different springs.

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

(OP)
Thanks for the warning! Don't worry I would never trust modified engines. So far, the integrators say they use industrial engines with heavy-duty heads, but everything comes from the GM factory and has GM's warranty.

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

I wrote to a colleague who uses the GM industrial blocks for continuous service to move natural gas at high altitude.  The engines are low compression port injected closed loop lean burn turbo 8.1L @ 2800rpm & 0.6 bar boost.  They nearly extended the life of the heads in comparison to the naturally aspirated stochio setups by going with lean burn turbo and the long blocks last an extra 1000 hours at best.  The heads are the std GM ng/lp spec parts without rotators.
They retrofit a wide deep sump oil pan with a 15 qt oil reservior.

The lean setup saves fuel but they did not care, the lean closed loop setup is more reliable and costs less per hr.

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

(OP)
turbocohen, very interesting info. What is the life they're getting from the engines? Have any of the engines you're talking about been dismissed yet at their end of life?

We are not sure of using the engines in lean burn mode, as NOx will increase and we'll be near the permitted emission limit, but closed loop makes a lot of sense to me...

On the other hand and as promised, here's some feedback from distributors and integrators:

Integrator 1: "Engines at those conditions will last 10 years, if properly maintained"
Integrator 2: "Standar Engine life is 25000 hrs, at your conditions and with proper maintenance, you should get at least 18-20k hrs"

Both integrators said no head replace would be necessary...

Local distributor 1: "About 10000 hrs before you replace the head, then another 10000 hrs"

Genset manuf. 1: "17000 hrs, you will have to swap heads at 8000hrs"

Genset manuf. 2: "Don't even think about using the 8.1L turbo at 120kVA (they offered Doosan engine instead and said it'll last >20000hrs). The 8.1L nat. asp. will do for 60kVA and will last >13000 hrs"

My conclusion is that integrators trust the engines more than the distributors/genset manuf... maybe because the genset manuf. don't know the engines as well as the integrators. Maybe it's just a very unusual application we have here.

I'll try to knock on GM's door directly, but they are not having a great time lately, so I'm affraid it'll be harder than usual.

Thanks to everybody!

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

What assurances did you get >in writing<?


 

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

Meant to say they nearly extended the life of the heads to that of the block..

One grenaded at 2K due to a coolant leak but they run about ~9k hrs, annual replacement.  They run substantially derated for longevity.

As for lean burn, if the system is well designed then Nox is low without need for much aftertreatment.  Real low.  They use a large commercial three way cat for nmhc due to high oil consumption.  One of the keys to longer valve life is to let the valve guides leak more than usual and bleed off a little air from the turbo to increase crank case ventilation which is not a problem with port injection.

My invlovement has been limited to the fuel system. The injectors do not seem to fail due to wear but to keep the engine running they filter and dry the fuel with a regenerating dessicant system that costs as much as the engine/compressor.

I think the life expectancy would be less with a genset in your application.  Just my 0.02 dinars
 

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

(OP)
To Mike: as you may guess, no integrator nor distributor sent any written info, just information over the phone. The genset manufacturers sent e-mails with the expected life on it, but no reference was made in the formal quotations.

Once againg, real life experiece (turbocohen's) suggests that the information from the integrators and genset mfgr. is at best not reliable...

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

If it ain't written down, it didn't happen.

If TBO or uptime is that important to you, maybe it's time to find or develop a spreadsheet to balance out the lifecycle costs of:
- extended warranty
- service contract
- preemptive replacement/ planned downtime
- on condition maintenance
- more expensive engines
- fancier monitoring equipment
- cost of unplanned outages, including collateral damage

Surely someone has done it before.

It's all a crapshoot anyway, but if you've got an MBA beating on you, well, they love spreadsheets.

 

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

(OP)
For me this is VERY interesting info, I don't know what you think about it, but this tells me that a 496 engine should be able to deliver about 94kVA (75kW) for 15000 hours before it'll need overhaul. Not bad!

Thanks!
Ernesto.

RE: Natural gas fired engines driving gensets - life expectancy

here in the gas field we use gm industrial engines for running wellhead compressors, the 5.7l gm have run continuos under 50% load for 4 yrs or aprox. 22,000 hrs with no failures, under heavier loads less of coarse, no cylinder wall or bearing issues, (oil changed once a month,clean dry fuel) valves last more or less depending on fuel, use a higher detergent oil to prevent sludge build up, we use 15w40 oil,with a custom over size pan, my customers have had issues with the 8.1 running to lean on the back 2 cylinders because of intake design, i will check to see if this issue has been cured, if you did heads every 10,000 hrs and a long block every 20,000 you won't have any problems, running a constant rpm makes a big difference on life of these engines

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources