×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

What is Largest Practical Limit?

What is Largest Practical Limit?

What is Largest Practical Limit?

(OP)
What is the largest practical limit for a compressor?  Is it feasible to compress a gas stream as large as 2e6 acfm to 100 psig?   

RE: What is Largest Practical Limit?

Let's assume that you're talking about an air compressor going from about 14.73 psia and 60F (so the suction acfm is basically SCFM) to 100 psig.  That is less than 8 compression ratios so it is probably a 2 stage recip or single flooded screw.  In either case it is around 330 hp.  That is what is called a small industrial air compressor.  Yeah, they come a bit larger than that.  The practical limit is at least 20 times larger.

If you told us what you were trying to do, you might get some help selecting equipment.

David

RE: What is Largest Practical Limit?

(OP)
I may not have been clear about the flowrate.  The flowrate should be 2,000,000 acfm @ 14.7 psia, 130 deg F, and at a density of 0.06 lbs/ft^3.  This is just a thought problem, but I am curious about the feasibility of compressing fluegas from a power boiler from 15 psia to 100 psig.   

RE: What is Largest Practical Limit?

The flow rate is around 2.5 MMSCF/day (the elevated temp reduces the SCF number about 12%) and you are not going to a very high pressure.  

Most of the time I get asked to look at this sort of problem, the target discharge is 1,000 to 10,000 psig and the hp requirements go way up.  Your application is 250 hp (with the lower mass flow rate)--to go to 1,000 psig the hp goes to 1100 hp in three stages, and at 10,000 it is around 2,800 hp in 5 stages.

Compressing flue gas is done every day.  Your boiler doesn't sound particularly large (I don't have a feeling for the BTU rating of the boiler based on flue gas flow rate) and this is a pretty easy application.

David

RE: What is Largest Practical Limit?

(OP)
Am I slipping a decimal point somewhere?

2E6 acfm * 60 min/hr * 24 hr/day * 88% = 2.5e9 scf/day

                = 2500 mscf/day

Theoretical Hp if one stage is approximately

144/33,000*(1.4/(1.4-1))(14.7 psia)*(2e6 acfm)*((115/15)^((1.4-1)/1.4) - 1)  

           = 354,500 Hp

It looks like we're off by a factor of 10^3.

RE: What is Largest Practical Limit?

(OP)
Thank you!  The 33,000 is the conversion from ft-lbf/min to Horsepower and the equation I posted is for acfm.  I am talking about 7.5 million pounds per hour of gas or 2.5 billion scf/day.

Thank you for the reference to axial compressors.  I knew I would have to use multiple compressors, if it was realistic at all.  If my pressure was lower, say the 30 psig you mention, would that allow me to use fewer centrifugal compressors, or some other type?  

RE: What is Largest Practical Limit?

As the great Emily Latella said "Never Mind".  It really is amazing how attached you can get to a wrong bit of arithmetic.  The OP was right about the magnitude of the hp, I get 360,000 hp.

As to how high you need to get the pressure, that depends on what you are going to do with the stuff.  If you're just going to separate out the CO2 from the water and Nitrogen compounds then you can do it at a pretty low pressure, but what then?  Putting pure CO2 into the atmosphere has the same "carbon tax" risks as just letting the mixture go up the stack (to say nothing of the emissions from the compressor drivers).  CO2 sequestration projects generally require pretty hig pressures (the one I worked on late last year was at 1,200 psig and that is the lowest I've seen).  If you are going to try to get to food grade CO2 the market is pretty saturated.

David

RE: What is Largest Practical Limit?

if you go to www.gpaglobal.org and then to publications and then to papers 2008, you will find two papers discussing CO2 capture from stacks.  

I also ran simulations and what you find out is you will have amine circulation rates in 50,000 gallons/minute with 20 to 25% of the power plants electricity and low pressure steam being used in recovering the CO2.  Then you will expend another 5% to 15% of the power plants output compressing the CO2 to pressure wher it can be sequestered.  These papers will also verify the cost to remove.  The recovery plant will have a capital of about 25% of the original power plant, then with the loss of 35% of the plants capacity, you'll have to make the power plant 50% larger than you need.  The net is the capital cost will nearly double and the energy output price will nearly double.

RE: What is Largest Practical Limit?

I got similar numbers.  The only way I can see sequestration working is if you need the CO2 for an enhanced recovery project.  Then the compression capital and operating costs go to the EOR/ECBM project and the economics get much better.  Without that, the "carbon tax" would really have to be huge to offset.

David

RE: What is Largest Practical Limit?

(OP)
Thanks!

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources