×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Damaged Capacitors in VFD
2

Damaged Capacitors in VFD

Damaged Capacitors in VFD

(OP)

I have a 30hp 480V Siemens MM440 VFD that recently failed.  When pulling the VFD out of service to investigate, it was obvious that something has been smoked for there was black soot all over the enclosure and the control boards.

Upon taking all the boards apart and looking at them one by one we found that it appeared that only two of the capacitors were all that were damaged.  These capacitors appeared to be burnt up and was obvious that they were the cause of the failure.  Everything else seemed to be fine, and it appeared that these capicitors smoking were the cause of the soot elsewhere.

What would cause capacitors to fail suddenly like this?  Is it possible that they were subject to overvoltage?  What is the common cause of capacitor damage in VFD's?

I should mention that this VFD is on a HRG system limited to 5A.

We have suspected possible voltage transients in this area for a while.  In some cases overnight when the VFD was not in use the drive would trip out on a DC bus overvoltage.  This led us to belive that there were some transenits occuring in the system subjuecting the DC bus to overvoltage.

I'm going to put a fluke 1735 power meter down in the area to monitor voltge.  The meter will only pick up events lasting for 1/2 cycle or more.  Do you think the meter would pick up a voltage transient or are typical voltage transients shorter than 1/2 cycle?

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

Your theory that:

Quote:

was obvious that they were the cause of the failure
is not a good theory.
But it is a possible  theory.

The caps can go due to age or transients.  I would probably give replacing them a try, on a drive that expensive.

If it were me I would;
 Check the front end diodes as one of them failing could have caused the problem or one could easily fail when the caps went.

Hunt down replacement caps/diodes and order them.  Then wash the sooted circuit boards in very warm water with some 409.  Use a tooth brush.  Then rinse them with warm water.  Follow that by a rinse of distilled, de-ionized, or distilled water.  Then stand them on a corner and let them dry for a day or two.

Reassemble the whole thing, roll the dice, and power it up from a distance.

Keith Cress
kcress - http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

It is unusual that overvoltage transients would cause the damage that you describe in the way the caps have failed.
A few possibilities:
1) What is the ambient temperature? Is it possible the drive is subjected to high temps over a period of time?
True, the VFD has protection over this but if this is a constant problem and the drive is stopping over periods and cooling down, the damage could be done and electrolytic caps 'dry out' and could fail.
2) Is the MM440 mounted in a place where there could be high vibration?
The caps on the MM440 are soldered directly to a power board and vibration could affect the solder junction point and cause failure. I've seen this before.
If the damage to the cap is at the 'solder' end then this is a possibility.
3) If you cannot power up the VFD due to the state of the VFD. Try and get hold of a Profibus module- not for profibus but this has a 24Vdc power supply that allows you to power the control board up. Apply 24Vdc and then check the fault and alarm history. This is a good indication of what was going on before the VFD went kerrboom.

What's a HRG?

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

Rockman7892

Thinking about your problem I have the following questions;

How long has the drive been in service?
Siemens drives can be bought either with the DC link earthed - centre point of the DC link capacitors - or without. Which version have you got?
Are there any power factor correction capacitors on the same or connected 480V busbars?
Is the neutral really earthed - ie not been disconnected?
Have you got an input line reactor?
Are there any varistors across the input rectifier - if so are they still OK?

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

Just to pile on a bit, my experience has been that when the caps go, most likely the transistors are now bad if the motor was running at the time. If it was not running when the damage happened, you have a chance.


"If I had eight hours to chop down a tree, I'd spend six sharpening my axe." -- Abraham Lincoln  
For the best use of Eng-Tips, please click here -> FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies  

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

Drivesrock
On the MM440 the Y cap is disabled by the user, not at the factory. A wire is clipped out. Once clipped then it cannot be reconnected easily.  

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

I think you need to provide more details. Are you talking about the main buss capacitors or some small capacitors on one of the PC boards?

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

(OP)

Management wanted to go ahead and purchase a new drive at the cost of $5,000.00.  Apparently they told me that Siemens does not sell replacement boards or parts and that we would have to ship the drive out to get repaired.

To answer some of the questions:

HRG stands for High Resistance Ground, which is the type of system this drive is connected to.

The drive has been in service for about a year now.  The drive is actually mounted in an outdoor MCC so I agree that there could be some temperature issues.  The front of the MCC bucket which it is located in has a vent fan which is in operation when the drive is powered up.  Over the past year this drive has been sitting in its location and seen pretty high temperatures without ever having a problem.  This problem occured early in the morning when temperatures were somewhat still cool.

I'm not sure weather I have a drive that has the DC linked or not.  Should there be a physical connection?  How can I tell?

There are no input line reactors.

I mentioned earlier that this system is HRG limited to 5A, so the neutral of the system transformer goes throguh a ground package before it is earthed.  We have had some problems getting the ground fault test indicator on this package to work and I'm begining to wonder if maybe there is something wrong with the ground system and there is maybe a high impedence connection somewhere between neutral and ground.

I'm not sure if there are varistors across the input rectifier.  The manual that I have for the drive is very vauge about what components are in the drive and their layout.

I may try to see if we can power up the drive with 24V and see any fault alarms.

There are no power factor caps anywhere on this 480V system.

 

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

(OP)
LionelHutz

Unfortunately like mentioned I cannot find anything in the manual that reference or show what boards are what and what parts are what.  

The capacitors that I am referencing where fairly large capacitors in size and there were about (8) of them.

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

My guess is that the VFD was designed for a solidly grounded system, a ground fault happened somewhere on the system, voltages shifted, and the caps didn't respond well to the sustained overvoltage.  Hopefully the ground fault is repaired before the new VFD is installed and toasted.

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

As it is a HRG (sorry, being a bit duh there), you should have removed the connector linking the Y capacitor circuit. It is also recommended to fit an output choke. Here is a section from the Siemens guide:
The purpose of the choke is to limit high frequency circulating currents that can flow during earth
faults. These would cause high currents in the output devices, leading to excessive dissipation and
possible damage.
Further Considerations:
1. Operation on ungrounded power supplies is only possible with unfiltered units. Filtered
units (or units which do not have their 'Y' capacitors disconnected) will be damaged
after running for a short time.
2. An output choke is recommended to limit the fault current during an ground fault. All
qualification tests have been carried out using an output choke.
3. It is often the case that ungrounded power supplies have high levels of transients and
interference. Supplies should be checked for damaging transients before fitting MM4. If
in doubt, an input choke should be installed.

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

Imagine!  Having a nice safe grounded wye power network and then ruining it by adding High Resistance Grounding.  What a shame.

And now, as has been reported here numerous times, it has cost the life of a drive only one year old.  Hopefully, when disconnects are opened, the disconnected conductors are ground jumpered before anyone comes near them or it may well cost the life of a human being, as well.

Why, on earth, would anybody choose High Resistance Grounding.  Low resistance grounding to limit ground fault current maybe, but high resistance grounding?  I'll never understand it.

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

DickDV, lots of good reasons for an HRG system provided they are maintained by knowledgeable staff.  Wouldn't consider anything else for a generator over 1kV.  Some processes need the continuity of service provided by HRG (or ungrounded, but there is no excuse for ungrounded).  Obviously in the case at hand the "maintained by knowledgeable staff" part was violated.  Absent the knowledgeable staff, I'm not sure that even a low resistance grounded system should be attempted, only solidly grounded.

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

Oz,

Quote:

Try and get hold of a Profibus module- not for profibus but this has a 24Vdc power supply that allows you to power the control board up. Apply 24Vdc and then check the fault and alarm history. This is a good indication of what was going on before the VFD went kerrboom.

That is a fantastic little snippet of knowledge - thanks. Could be very useful.
  

----------------------------------
  
If we learn from our mistakes I'm getting a great education!
 

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

(OP)

Davidbeach

I'm assuming that when you mention the voltges shifting during ground fault, you are referring to the fact that when one of the phases is grounded the other two L-G voltages become the system L-L voltages.  If some of the Vfd components are not rated for this L-L voltage then they can be damaged during a ground fault on a HRG or ungrounded system?  How can you find out weather or not the drive is rated for use on a HRG system?

We did pull the drive out and  megger the motor leads from the MCC out to the motor and did not appear to have anything grounded and all voltages looked ok.

Ozmosis

What is the Y capacitor you are referencing used for?  I saw instructions for the removal of this capacitor in the operating manual but no reference to what it was used for.  I also cannot find anything showing what the individual components of the Vfd are.  Where can I find such information?  What Siemens guide did you reference above?

I have set up a power meter on the MCC to record voltages.  Like I mentioned above there are times whre overnight when this drive is not running that the drive will trip on a DC bus overvoltage.  Could there be something strange going on with the HRG system causing these events?  

 

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

Page 22/23 of this:
http://cache.automation.siemens.com/dnl/Tg1NTE1MwAA_19484693_HB/Quick%20Start%20Guide%201_1%20Low%20Res.pdf

Siemens will not allow repair by individuals. This needs to be carried out by authorised persons. When a cap goes like this it is important to check other components such as IGBT's and maybe even the gate drive board. Not tests for someone who has not had the the training.
It is quite possible for the drive to trip on overvoltage when it is not running. Under no load, the DC link voltage will be high and if you get a disturbance on the AC supply, it is more likely to trip the drive due to the limited headroom of over-voltage protection.

It was discussed within Siemens to disable the overvoltage protection when the drive is not running as it actually serves no purpose other than annoyance. However, I don't think this really got implemented.
 

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

(OP)
Ozmosis

Thanks for the document it is helpful.  It does not say exactly what the Y capacitor does or what its purpose is.  Do you know the technical purpose of this capacitor?

It would appear that in the document it referenceds a connection of the drive to an HRG system so therefore the drive would be rated for use on such a system if the Y cap was removed.  What problems would exist if Y cap is not removed on HRG system.

What is this document referring to as a "station ground"?  It appears that it is simply showing a case where the ground connection on the VFD is not bonded to the neutral of the transformer but is connected to some other earth point?

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

That sounds like the main DC capacitors. Some electrolytic caps aren't rated for below freezing temperatures. Basically, the electrolyte freezes. Maybe the drive enclosure was getting too cold in the winter?
 

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

(OP)

I set up a fluke 1735 power logger on this MCC over the weekend and all through yesterday.  I set the logger up to trigger on voltages with the trigger thresholds being +/- 10% nominal voltage.

Attached are plots of three of the events I picked up.  It appears that on this MCC several times yesterday we saw L-N voltages as high as 371V.  This would equate to roughly a L-L voltage of 641 which is extremely high.  Like I mentioned above the system is a 480/277V wye HRG system so nominal voltage should be 277V as shown for periods in the plot.  

Ignore the voltage magnitude for the L1 phase for this probe lead appears to be damaged and only reads 12V L-N when connected.  You can see however that it rises with the other phases.  

The connections were made with each of the three voltage probes on a phase of the MCC, and the neutral probe connected to the ground bus in the MCC.  So technically we were reading L-G voltages with the ground tied back to the neutral of the transormer through the HRG package.

What do you guys make of these high voltage swells?

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

You've got a ground fault on L1, that's all.  I don't see anything that suggests that you ever had more than 480V line-line.

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

(OP)
Davidbeach

Like I mentioned the L1 readings may be misleading because I belive that the probe is damaged.  I have seen this 12V reading on another solidly grounded system for L1.  Also when measuring L-G on L1 with a regular meter we see 277V (measured on different section of MCC).

But I do agree that 371V would indicate a possible ground fault.  Why would the L-G readings only be 371V for a ground fault condition?  With the system neutral tied to zero (grounded) wouldn't we still see 277V L-G even during a ground fault.  I thought that only on an ungrounded system you would see L-L voltaegs for L-G readings on ungrounded phases?  Why would we be seeing 371V as opposed to 480V if the system was ungrounded?

It is strange to me that the voltge swells and then returns to normal periodicaly.  Could this be a re-striking ground fault?  What could we do to find this ground fault if it is intermitent?

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

Fault resistance and location on the circuit relative to point of measurement can have the unfaulted phase to ground voltages anywhere from nominal phase to ground up to phase to phase.  Your grounding resistor will drop 277V for a line to ground fault adjacent to the transformer; that's how it limits the current.

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

(OP)
davidbeach

You are saying that the grounding resistor will drop 277V for a L-G falut, so the other two unfaulted L-G readings should still be 277V?  Is this correct?

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

The resistor drops 277V, so neutral is now 277V to ground.  Other two phases remain 277V to neutral, and are therefore 480V to ground.

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

It does appear there is a ground fault on L1 and that would be the most likely problem that would cause the other 2 phases to have a voltage rise like that.

However, without a proper measurement of that phase no-one can't say for sure. I recommend you get your equipment fixed as soon as possible. You write you've seen this probe problem on another system so obviously it didn't just come up broken when you went to use it this time. If you had a proper log of all 3 phases we'd know if it was a ground fault problem on line 1 without there being a "maybe" thrown in.

You could try putting a voltmeter with a min/max feature on the L1 and try turning different equipment on and off and see if the voltage varies. You almost need a helper and radio communications to do this though. You could also do it with the logger if you track the times you turn each thing on and off then go through the log and see if switching something matches to the voltage changing.
 

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

Rockman7892
Sorry for the delay in responding; my world this week has been shaken, stirred and turned upside down.

You asked earlier "what could happen if you didn't break the Y cap link". Well, if you get a ground fault on a HRG network, then the problem you first posted could be one.
I'm slightly alarmed that you think there might be a problem with your measurement equipment. If you think this is the case, then don't use it. Get comething else that is calibrated and works. Apart from the errors you might get in measuring, think of safety when measuring.

 

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

(OP)

OK I went through this system today and heres what we found:

As I showed in the attached plots there was something occuring on this system causing the L-G voltage to read as high a 371V and be sustained during certain intervals.  

After walking through the system piece by piece we found that there was not direct connection between the HRG resistor and the neutral of the transformer.  This was because the neutral brought out from the transformer was landed on a terminal block on the HRG package that did not have continuity through to the Resistors.  We went ahead and made sure that this connection.  So it appears that this whole time were were indeed operating on an ungrounded system.

After connecting this neutral properly we stareted motors one by one and watched L-G voltages with our meter to look for a rise.  We finally got to the last motor and after starting it, wha-la our L-G voltages went up to 371V and our ground fault indication package (now working properly) indicated a ground fault.  Sure enough we wanted and meggered this motor and found that indeed the motor was grounded.  We see the ground fault current returing through the EGC's back thrgouth the HRG resistors and through to the neutral properly system seems to be working properly.

We still get however strange readings when measuring L-G voltages during this fault event. Before the motor is turned on and the fault induced all voltages L-G read 277V.  When motor is turned on and fault is present all three phases L-G voltages jump to 305V with a regular hand held meter.  I would suspect that if one of the phases is grounded that phase should read 0V L-G.  What should the other 2 phases read?  Should they stay at L-G potential or should they read L-L voltaegs for L-G readings?  Why are all three phases L-G readings being driven up when ground fault is present?  Does this seem right?  All phases measure 480V L-L during fault.  Something still seems wrong.

We measured 305V with a handheld meter as mentioned above, however the fluke 1735 meter we were using read 371V L-G.  Why would this be different.  Something to do with meter input impedence.

The other thing that I am questioning is the fact that there is anotehr larger 75hp drive connected to this same MCC.  Why wouldn't this other drive have suffered the same consequence as the one that failed.  The other dirve i am referencing is what was feeding the faulted motor.

Thanks for all the help!

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

(OP)

Took some more readings today and found that when measuring current on the ground bus of the MCC we appeard to have about 2A of current even when the faulted motor was not running.  This 2A does not appear back at the neutral of the transformer however.  It appears that there is maybe a circuilating current on the MCC?  This current does not change much when the faulted motor is running which I would suspect it would increase due to the fact there would not be fault current flowing through our HRG system and should be pulsing from our kit to try and locate fault.  We can see the pulsing current back throgh the HRG package and at the neutral of the transformer but do not see it on the MCC ground bus.  This leads me to believe that this fault current is returning to the transformer via another path.  Maybe earth ground?

Also when taking readings I put the meter in Harmonics mode and measured a large amount of harmonics on the system when the faulted motor and its associated VFD were running.  We measured 1st, 3rd, 5th, and 9th harmonics, and the total harmonic distortion was about 20% which seemed very high.

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

Total "Current" harmonic distortion? 20% seems low if that's the case. If THVD, then yes, it seems very high.
The VFD should not produce triplen harmonics (3,9th). I would say other 1ph devices of a non-linear load are producing those.
Current Harmonic distortion will be high with the MM440 as there is no DC link choke facility and unless you have an AC line reactor, the typical THID will be in the region of 55-60% at full load.
 

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

(OP)
Ozmosis

The 20% was the THD for the voltage.  We saw these harmonics when the motor was in a fault condition and running.  We replaced the motor and ran the new motor and saw all of these harmonics disapear on the system.

The harmonics we did see on the system with this drive and motor running were indeed 3rd, 7th and 9th.  The 3rd harmonic was the dominant one at about 20% with the 7th and 9th only being a couple percent each.

Would a faulted motor maybe cause these harmonics?

 

RE: Damaged Capacitors in VFD

I wouldn't expect a faulted motor to cause the harmonic distortion but maybe an unbalanced supply would introduce triplen harmonics. I don't have too much experience on HRG when faults occur but maybe davidbeach/others can.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources