×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

How to calculate compressor discharge temperature by hand?

How to calculate compressor discharge temperature by hand?

How to calculate compressor discharge temperature by hand?

(OP)
Hi,

I came across a problem when calculating the compressor discharge temperature. When using the GPSA databook to calculate a single stage centrifugal compressor discharge temperature, the result is much higher than that we gained using the simulation software ProII or a compressor sizing program.

The formula in the GASP is:

T2=T1(P2/P1)^[(n-1)/n]
(n-1)/n=(k-1)/(k*Eta)
Eta - Polytropic efficiency

Who knows how to estimate the centrifugal compressor's discharge temperature? What is the actual formula most vendors use?

What is limitation of the formula in GASP databook?

Thanks.

RE: How to calculate compressor discharge temperature by hand?

I've never had much luck with the simple multiplier approach to determining the polytropic coefficient.  I've only been able to make it work with experimental values for "n" (and even then it seems to have starting temp ranges where it works better than others).

David

RE: How to calculate compressor discharge temperature by hand?



TD = (TS + 460!) * ((Ratio ^ CON - 1!) * C1P10 * (1.0 + .078 / (R - .793)) + 1.0) - 460

C1P10 = 1.10675

CON = (VN - 1!) / VN

VN = e^(.35 - .188 * SPGR)

SPGR = specific gravity of the mostly hydrocarbon gas.

Ratio = Pd/Ps  pressure discharge/pressure suction in absolute

TD & TS are temperatures in degrees F

RE: How to calculate compressor discharge temperature by hand?

(OP)
Hi DCASTO,

Where is your formula coming from? Can you please let me know the book or references?

 

RE: How to calculate compressor discharge temperature by hand?

Mostly from 1970's Oil and Gas Journal an Hydrocarbon Engineering articles.  I used these equations in my copyrighted program called SUPRC.   

RE: How to calculate compressor discharge temperature by hand?

I just performed this calc today, and the GPSA calculated discharge temperature was within 5 degrees of the vendor supplied discharge temperature.  Hysys was also within 5 degrees.  The vendor number was higher in both cases.  I'm surprised you are getting a much higher number.

If you post the info, I can double check the numbers.

Mark

RE: How to calculate compressor discharge temperature by hand?

(OP)
I just found why this difference was happened. Although the calculation of the discharge pressure (polytropic process) in GPSA data book does not indicate the limitation of the equation, there is actually a limitation applied, which is the pressure ratio P2/p1 < 1.15. This means the GPSA equation is only suitable for lower pressure ratio <1.15 compressor. The higher the pressure ratio, the bigger the errors.

In my application, the pressure ratio is 4.6. This means that the GPSA equation will not work precisely. The simulation software like ProII or Hysis and my compressor software give more accurate result.

I don't know other limitation of the GPSA equation. Please comments if you have.

Hippo, is your pressure ratio near 1.15?  

Frank
 

RE: How to calculate compressor discharge temperature by hand?

I was around a 2.3 compression ratio.  I wouldn't think the error would be too large, otherwise it would have likely had been noted in GPSA.  I'm speculating obviously, but I just wouldn't expect the answer to be too different.

Mark

RE: How to calculate compressor discharge temperature by hand?

Which equation in the GPSA data book?  Eq 13-18 or 13-31?  In older books I remeber they use to have curves for HP and discharge temperatures for reciprocation compressors.

What we tend to forget about is valve loss ends up in the equation for discharge temp.  We try to simulate this loss as polytropic efficiency.  Then when we do an anlysis of calculated versus observed we get excited when the calcs say 275 Degrees and the Observed is 280 degrees, this is less than 1% error (remember, use absolute temperatures).

I've attached some sample Td calcs from all sources posted here.

RE: How to calculate compressor discharge temperature by hand?

An isentropic efficiency of about 85% works well for most applications when calculating discharge temperature and gas power.

RE: How to calculate compressor discharge temperature by hand?

I'm sorry. Somehow I got the idea we were talking recip compressors, for which 85% is a good number. I've got recips on the brain these days.....

However, for centrifs it's a different case entirely. For lower flow higher ratio machines I'd use a polytropic efficiency on the order of 68-73%. The narrower the impellers, the lower the efficiency. The older the design (ie. 2D wheels) the lower the efficiency...that is, closer to the 68% number.

For higher flow, lower ratio machines, then I'd be looking at 76-82% polytropic ifficiency, the same qualifies applying as before re: impeller vintage and passage width.

Your best bet is to obtain the PTC-10 based performnace curves for the compressor, which should include a plot of efficiency vs speed and volumetric flow. And then subtract 3-4 percentage points for laby wear.

One well known manufacturer boasts polytropic efficiencies in the low 80's. However, these efficiencies fall off 5-7% in service to normal laby wear...they fall off further than you would expect an older design machine with lower initial efficiency to fall off. I'd recommend caution when using their as-new efficiencies for economic analysis.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources