×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

A286 Forgings and Grain Size
2

A286 Forgings and Grain Size

A286 Forgings and Grain Size

(OP)
We have been buying A286 forgings for high temperature applications.  The stock materials are either ASTM A638 Grade 660 or A891.  After forging process, they are being solution treated and double aged.  Then the mechanical properties are tested from specimens from the forgings and grian structure is also analyzed.  The forging process and heat treatment are done by third party venders. Recently we had some issues with grain size and structure.  We had to reject these forgings due to their non uniformity in grain size and larger grains.  Our requirements call for minimum grain size of ASTM size 4 or finer and most forgings meet this requirement.  I am attaching the photomicrographs of the ones with grain size issues.  The first three have mixed grain structure.  The last one has very large grains.  I would like  to understand the reason for these unacceptable grain structures.
Any insight or experience on this would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks.

RE: A286 Forgings and Grain Size

2
metalseng;
Some additional information would help to evaluate what you observed;

1). What was the forging temperature range? This should be available form the 3rd party that is doing this work.

2). What was the solution treatment temperature and time? This information should be available on the MTR from the 3rd party that is performing the heat treatment.

3). What is the approximate size and shape of each forging?
 

RE: A286 Forgings and Grain Size

Forgot my two last questions...

4) Is any type of forming or straightening operation performed after solution treatment but prior to aging?

5). What is your double aging heat treatment?
 

RE: A286 Forgings and Grain Size

(OP)
Thank you for the interest.
1. The Forging company claims that they stay within specified range.  I have no way of checking it.
2. The solution treatment temperature is 1800F.   The solution times were 3-4 hours.
3.All Forgings are pancake forgings (thickness ranges 4-5 inch). Diameter ranges 20-22 Inches.
4. None
5. 1400F for 16 hours and 1200F for 16 hours.

Thanks.

RE: A286 Forgings and Grain Size

metalseng;
You absolutely need to track the information in 1) down because the literature I have indicates the forging temperature range for A 286 is narrow, and depends on the amount of work reduction.

I would consider visiting the forging shop and review/audit their procedure for A 286. Also, you should request this information as part of traceability for these forgings. I suspect there could be a problem with a lack of temperature control and subsequent consistency by your forging supplier.

 

RE: A286 Forgings and Grain Size

(OP)
Thanks for the reply.  I agree that the forging temperature is critical. The reference you have provided recommends a forging temperature of 2150F for large amount of deformation.  However, I do not understand how how the temperature will stay lower when it is being deformed heavily.

I have another related question.  A891 specifies a solution treatment time (at 1800F) of 3-5 hours.  Does that apply to even thicker forgings (min thickness of 12 inches)?  We cannot drill a hole to insert a thermocouple in the center of the forging to measure the time the center section is at the solution treatment temperature.

Thank you for the link.  I was not aware of it.

 

RE: A286 Forgings and Grain Size

metalseng:

Quote:

I agree that the forging temperature is critical. The reference you have provided recommends a forging temperature of 2150F for large amount of deformation.  However, I do not understand how how the temperature will stay lower when it is being deformed heavily.

I have audited several large forging shops and of the reputable shops I have visited all have some type of process procedure or guide that details forging reduction ratios and temperature hold points. This is why I said you or your organization hire someone to review the forging shop.

Yes. The austenitization time for most ferrous materials occurs much quicker then most believe. The actual soak time at 1800 deg F should start when the part reaches the solution treatment temperature of 1800 deg F, not when you place the forging in the furnace. The hold time allows for the complete dissolution of precipitates that formed during and after forging.
 

RE: A286 Forgings and Grain Size

(OP)
Thanks again.  By the way, is there any way to check (right after it has been forged) if the forging has been properly forged before the heat treatment and machining.  Sometimes, we find out the grain size is no good after machining and full soltion heat treatment- means all the expense associated with this is wasted. I was thinking of hardness measurements or grain structure.  Any guidence would be helpful.
 

RE: A286 Forgings and Grain Size

I agree, the removal of extra stock for hardness and grain size evaluation from test samples after forging would be beneficial. This requirement would have to be part of the process requirements for the forging vendor to follow. Look at ASTM A788 for guidance.

RE: A286 Forgings and Grain Size

(OP)
Thank You Metengr

RE: A286 Forgings and Grain Size

We are a forging plant in China. In my experience, the critical things for grain structure are material and forging ratio. If we do your forged disks, first we will choose the suitable forging ratio then ultrasoniclly test the billet or ingot. Heat treatment is necessary but has limited effects for grain structure.  

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources