×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Concrete Walls

Concrete Walls

Concrete Walls

(OP)
Does anyone know how to determine the maximum allowable eccentricity for a uniformaly distributed load on a 10" wide, 8 foot high foundation wall?
The walls were poured 3" off square and the result is a parallelogram shaped foundation wall.

RE: Concrete Walls

I am confused here - is the eccentricity (3" off) in the height of the wall, or in the thickness?

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: Concrete Walls

(OP)
The eccentricity is in the thickness.  At worst case, the centre of the sill plate (2x6 flat) and wall above would be 3" outside of the centre line of the concrete wall.  

RE: Concrete Walls

Is the 3" to the inside or outside face (soil face) of the wall?

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: Concrete Walls

(OP)
On one side its to the outside face (soil face) while on the other its to the inside face of the wall. I think the eccentricity on the outside face is more critical (?).

RE: Concrete Walls

If you could post a diagram showing the vertical reinforcing placement and clearances with the relative soil heignts, it will help with the comments.

Is this a free standing retaining wall, or a basement wall?

In general, for a basement wall condition, with reference to the soil face, any eccentricity toward the soil will add to the bending moment and away from the wall will decrease it.

For a free standing retaining wall, eccentricity towaed the soil will decrease the bending in the wall, whereas the opposote will add to it.

Sounds to me that you may not have an easy solution here.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: Concrete Walls

(OP)
I've attached a typical section through the wall.  The wall is reinforced with 15M @ 8" at the bottom of the wall approximately 36" from the bottom. The top section is unreinforced. The height of the wall is approximately 7'-4" and backfill height 6'-6". The strength of the concrete is 25 MPa.

RE: Concrete Walls

With no floor joists perpendicular to the wall at the top of the concrete, this is acting as a non-yielding wall.

Outside of the eccentricity, which I consider a minor problem, I have one major concern here:

The fact that it is detailed as a yielding wall, but the footing appears too small and wall improperly reinforced for the soil load.  With a 6'+ soil retention depth, this should be an engineered wall.  Is the dead load from the structure above sufficient that the soil side of the wall does not go into tension?  The footing needs to be large enough with any overturning so as not to overstress the soil at the toe.

I have no feel for the load or rebar values you have mentioned.  I am in the states.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: Concrete Walls

(OP)
Hi Mike,
Thank you for your reply.
A little background into this case.
In Ontario, Canada, designers are permitted to specify wall sizes if they follow the values given in the Ontario Building Code, table 9.15.4.1.  This table shows that a 20 MPa (2900 psi) strength wall, 9 7/8" thick can support ground cover to a maximum height of 7'7", provided the top of the wall is laterally supported (which this one will be).
The code futher shows that the minimum footing width for 2 storeys, exterior wall is 17 3/4" (table 9.15.3.3).
So, had the contractor made all the angles square, this wall would be considered acceptable under the Ontario Building Code.  
As far as rebar and concrete strength, 15M bar is no. 5 bar and 25 MPa is approximately 3500 psi.
I'm trying to calculate the moment capacity at the top of the wall where there is no reinforcing and to determine if the wall will have sufficient capacity for the eccentricity.

RE: Concrete Walls

So, what you need to calculate is the cracking moment of the unreinforced section.  Considering the embediment requirements of the reinforcing trhat is present, you may want to see what the cracking moment is at the base of the wall.

I have an ACI publication "Notes on ACI 318-83" put out by the Portland Cement Association. It has guidance for doing the calcs for this situation.  There should be a similar publication for the most recent ACI code that you might be able to get and use.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: Concrete Walls

You have a mess here, because your concrete wall is curved (if I read correctly). Without lateral support on top, the wall is a cantilever, it deflects away from soil side, therefore you were correct in saying "the eccentric load on the non-soil side is more critical than the soil side". I would prefer to tear the wall down and rebuild it. However, you may try to add weighing block (counter weight) to the soil side (if space permits) to make the wall push-into the soil to counter the effect from the eccentricities. You should be able to determine the size of the block by performing simple stability analysis. If this scheme is viable, connect it to the wall by (drill & grout) dowels. This wall might show random cracks after all, depending the stresses level, which are very difficult to determined.   

RE: Concrete Walls

(OP)
Thank you for the note kslee1000,
However, the contractor will provide lateral support at the top with joists.
What is complicating the project is we need to backfill asap since proper shoring was not provided.
I would like to tear down and rebuild as well, but that would significantly delay the project.

RE: Concrete Walls

Regardless of what the calculations show, do not backfill this wall prior to the installation of the joists and associated plywood diaphragm.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: Concrete Walls

Which side is the joists to be installed? Will the joists installed prior to backfill, or vice versa? Are the joists considered as lateral supports in the design?

RE: Concrete Walls

(OP)
Joists are to be installed first with plywood on the non soil side and are considered lateral supports in the design.

RE: Concrete Walls

Now the matter is down to perform a structural analysis on a wall with pin-pin (top-bottom) condition using at rest earth pressure, and the eccentric load on the non-soil side. If you are not comfortable to do it by your own, you will need to get a structural eng. to help out.

Before you do the above, check with the code official to see if you can get hold on the background materials/assumptions used in developing the code recommendations. (It might have included certain amount of eccentricity from the structure.)

RE: Concrete Walls

VictorAK,

You have concluded that the wall is adequate to resist the lateral pressure of the earth, provided the top is braced.  While some of us may disagree, that is not your question.

Building the wall above on top of the floor framing (platform construction) should remove any concern about eccentricity of loading on the concrete wall.

RE: Concrete Walls

(OP)
Thank you hokie66,
I would still like to calculate the moment at the top of the wall and compare to the moment capacity of the wall at the top. I'm thinking of treating as a simply supported beam, with a gradually increasing udl for the soil and a point moment at the top where the eccentricity is.
The problem is an assumption for percentage steel in the calcs.
 

RE: Concrete Walls

Yes, the soil load is triangular, and the wall should be treated as simply spanning.  I think you can ignore the eccentricity from above, as that will be taken out by the floor framing.  In the top part, p is of course zero.  In the bottom part p=As/bd, where d is to the outside face.  But realistically, the steel does nothing for you, as the maximum moment will be just about at the end of the bar.

RE: Concrete Walls

Add surcharges to your soil diagram - from compaction, construction loads during/after backfill, normal live load. You shall include all loads that produce moment, even small, since your upper wall was not reinforced. Check compression in the joist as load has increased due to eccentricity. Check foundation base shear, make sure there is adequate shear friction to resist the reaction. If there is ground water, you might have big time problem.

RE: Concrete Walls

Please note increase in bearing presuure could result due to the construction imperfection. Check it to see if allowable bearing strength is exceed. Be on the safe side.

RE: Concrete Walls

kslee,

Why do you have to make everything so complicated?  He asked one question, you have asked a lot more, and answered your own questions.  Do you want us to comment on your questions and anwswers?  If so, start a new post.

RE: Concrete Walls

Victor was asking a "known or suggestive allowable maximum eccentricity" to justify the mess, I don't know any, and I don't feel comfortable with/confident on the details (rather small footing base good for mainly concentric load, no upper wall reinforcing, even small bending could cause trouble), so try to encourage him to abide to the conventional way to justify this situation if choosing to. Years down the road he might need to dig out the calculations to justify his decision today. Maybe I am quite conservative on this, but isn't that this forum about - to express one's opinion, concerns through series of discussions/inquires? I really don't understand your complain, if I ask/answer something you don't like, ignore it, dispute it, comment on it, or take it if you like. It's not that complicate.

RE: Concrete Walls

VictorAK:

Sorry for the distraction. Please continue the discussion if you feel need for better/more ideas. Good luck.

RE: Concrete Walls

Why don't you check it under the provisions of "Plain Concrete" in A23.3-94?  I don't think it should be much of a problem, but if it is, you might want to specify some vertical steel straps on the inside face of the wall, fastened to the concrete using Hilti fasteners?  The cost of doing so is peanuts.

 

Best regards,

BA

RE: Concrete Walls

VictorAK

Did you intend to use platform framing?  The sketch didn't indicate that to me, and I can't find it in your posts.

RE: Concrete Walls

I think you have more problems.  If the contractor can't provide proper shoring and apparently cannot measure accurately, what is the rest of the building going to look like?

How many more problems are you going to have?

Might want to accept a delayed project and insist the contractor redo it.  After that, I'm sure he will be paying attention, if you don't insist on him taking it out, the rest of this project may (will) go the same way.

Let us know how it ends up.

Regards.

RE: Concrete Walls

After a good night sleep, I would like to tune down my tune a little.

While all my talking above was from a conventional view on a "single wall" that was curving in plane (S-shape), you may want to look the problem globally. I believe the wall forms an enclosure (wall all around) to support the structure above, from this bigger picture, the localized imperfection may not be a big deal, however, attention needs to be put on the local effects. Your decision to do a cal is correct call. The steps and focus points could be tedious, but the cal itsself is rather straight forward. I agree with BAretired' suggestions in case the plain concrete section does not work.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources