×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?
5

Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

(OP)
I am currently doing a study for an economical way to blanket a 5,000 M3 Boiler Feed Water tank. The tank doesn't have a blanketing system at the moment, and is atmospheric tank breathing to air. Therefore the plant experiences corrosion problems caused by the dissolved Oxygen in the water which was introduced by contacting with air at the tank.
The usual way to improve this, I think, is a Nitrogen Blankeing System. But someone says he heard about using floating balls in lieu of N2 Blankting system. To a little bit more explain this: to add floating balls on top of the water in the tank by a few layers, and this floating balls reduces the contact of water with air and thus serves as a simple blanketing system. If this works it will be much cheaper than the N2 blanketing system to operate.

Does anyone out there hear about this? or know anything about this?

It sounds like to work, but it does not completely prevent air contact and thus still have some Oxygen dissolve into the water. Then the question is how much will be the Oxygen content, or by using certain floating balls how much contact surface will be reduced in percentage?

Thanks,
HTech01

 

RE: Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

It would help but to work well the water under the balls would have to be near boiling. injecting a little steam into the water would provide some O2 stripping though the "packed bed" of floating balls. If your feed water tank is not hot it will not help much.

RE: Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

You could also look at adding water treatment to scavenge oxygen.

The effectiveness of the balls is also a function of the diameter of the balls.

RE: Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

(OP)
The water temperature in the tank is close to ambient temp., so it is not warm...

RE: Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

I have heard of an application where ping-pong balls were used.

RE: Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

(OP)
Thanks for your posting TBP,

Can you explain a little bit more?
Do you know how the performance was - reduction of  dissolved oxygen or reduced corrosion?
How much layers did they used?
 
Regards,
Htech01

RE: Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

I had no direct involvment with the application. It was someone I worked with years ago, who had seen it done in another plant where he had worked. As far as I remember, the ping-pong balls did the job. And they're cheap, and readily available.

RE: Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

Ping pong balls have so much bouyancy that they would only cover a portion of the surface of the water and the rest of it would be exposed to atmosphere, and probably enough so that the ping pong ball effort would be pretty much negated IMHO.

Why not just pour some oil on it?  Just be sure to never pump it all the way down.  See the tongue in cheek......

rmw

RE: Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

My collection is that the balls were several layers thick.

RE: Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

That would make a more tortuous path but not a seal.

rmw

RE: Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

(OP)

I don't think pouring oil will work. Because the oil will dissolve into water even very small amount, and that is not acceptable to boiler feed water.

Having balls floated on the water surface will definitely reduce surface area of air-water contact and thus reduce the oxygen dissolving rate into water. So I have no doubt that it will have positive effect. The question is how much!
Also in either case, oxygen will only dissolves up to the saturation concentration at that temperature. And if the water residence time in the tank is long enough to go to the saturation even at the reduced surface area with floating balls. That is my doubt.

So I am wondering what's the result in the actual applications.  

By the way I have mistaken about the water temperature in the Tank. It is actually quite warm at 80deg-C.

Waiting more advices and comments,
Thanks,
 

RE: Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

2
Though I've never seen them used in a situation as in your OP I have used them on some waste recovery tanks for both odor and evaporation and to conserve heat. All the literature I have says they will impede mass transfer and that whats you are looking at. Air water contact is largest mode of O2 transfer in lakes and oceans.


http://www.euro-matic.com/hollow.html

http://www.paradisenw.com/bird_ball_cover.php

RE: Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

(OP)
unclesyd,

Thank you so much.
These are exactly what I am looking for.

 

RE: Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

Unclesyd, a star from here too.  

Htech01, this is a very interesting question, as we have some open water storage tanks that we use for testing, and have been dosing for corrosion control.  Would be interesting to see if you come to any conclusions regarding your question.  Could you please post any conclusions you reach here?

RE: Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

(OP)

It will take some time before I come to the conclusion, around a month.
But I will definitely post my conclusion and rationale later in this Thread.
 

RE: Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

Even better, Htech.  Looking forward to it.

RE: Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

Have you noticed that the mentioned system has the "stabilizing rings" around the each ball?
I think this is the clue of that method. Without it the balls will rotate, (i.e. in case of pin pong balls) and if so, each ball will be covered by thin water film, perfectly expanding the exchange surface, and thus, extending the oxygen and carbon dioxide dissolving process.
If your water already is 80C... well, it's not far form old type degasifier, where steam at 105C was bubbling through the water.

RE: Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

A couple of things need to be added to this discussion.

The water entering the tank must be deoxygenated or the tank dosed with an oxygen scavenger. The floating balls only reduce the surface area exposed to the atmosphere which limits the rate of absorption of atmospheric oxygen. If the water in the tank is saturated with O2 the balls won't help.

Don't try this with ping pong balls, use HDPE balls. DI water is very corrosive and may attack the ping pong balls. HDPE is virtually immune to this type of corrosion.

RE: Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

(OP)
The water is deoxygenated.
I found some vendors for these balls.
The material used for the balls are usually HDPE, PP or PVDF depending on the temperature and application.

 

RE: Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

Do you have the option to use a low-pressure steam blanket instead of Nitrogen?  Maintain a slight positive pressure on the tank to exclude air.

RE: Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

(OP)
Yes, a steam blanket is one of the options.
But I think the nitrogen blanket would be more cost effective than the steam blanket.

The reason:
For steam blanket, I am thinking to purge steam from the bottom. Even so, to make the steam blanketing to be effective - to prevent air leak from outside - I have to maintain the positive steam pressure inside the tank which means I have to feed enough steam to maintain the temperature above 100deg-C. Considering the tank operation temperature of 80deg-C, I have to feed a lot of steam.

Any comments?
  

RE: Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

As I suggested before you can inject steam just below the water surface which is covered by balls. The surface will be 100C. The balls will minimize heat loss. The water at the bottom of the tank can be cooler. The balls, with steam injection, will act as the barrier you seek and not use a lot of energy.

RE: Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

Consider adding a floating roof to your tank.  Insulating it will reduce heat loss, and the roof itself prevents air contacting the liquid surface.

A roof does the same thing as the floating balls, but eliminates the water surface exposed between the ball circumferences.

Most tank manufacturers can add a floating roof to an existing tank.  It will cost 2-3 ft of tank volume to add one.
 

RE: Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

The use of steam is probably not a good idea. Large storage tanks are usually designed for atmospheric pressure. You put your boiler feedwater tank at risk of a collapse if your low pressure steam condenses.  It happens all of the time when people are trying to clean a tank with steam.

http://www.trainorders.com/discussion/read.php?1,1894873

Floating balls has been widely used conserve heat in open tanks. However, floating balls will not be effective for this application, especially when one is trying to maintain ppb oxygen concentrations.

In the applications that use floating balls, the tank fluid level is a constant. The tank water level is not a constant in a boiler feedwater tank. When the boiler feedwater tank water level drops during operation, the exposed walls of the tank will be covered with water. Once the water has absorbed the oxygen and carbon dioxide from the air, you will have the tank corrosion that you are trying to prevent.

You also will have a problem when you lay up your unit. How do you propose to keep the oxygen out when the tank is drained?

Adding the balls to the tank would also provide a place that will allow microorganisms and crud to accumulate.
 

RE: Blanketing of Boiler Feed Water Tank with Floating Balls?

Internal floating roof perhaps? One off investment, no continuous N2 supply. Or perhaps increase the Oxygen content to a controlled level (refer to Russian literature).
My two cents..
gr2vessels

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources