×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

gas station canopy
2

gas station canopy

gas station canopy

(OP)
An architect is wanting me to design a drive thru that has only 2 posts, similar to the structures they install over gas pumps. Has anyone ever designed one of these? Are the columns designed as a cantilevered column to resist lateral loads? It seem this is a very unstable structure. I've noticed that alot of the new canopies have 4 columns and the ones that have 2 columns have alot bigger columns than the older ones.  

RE: gas station canopy

Hello deereman,

The columns are designed as cantilevers to resist lateral loads as well as unbalanced snow load on the roof.  The foundation must be able to resist these eccentricities.  Roof beams must be connected to the top of each column with a moment connection adequate to resist unbalanced wind uplift and snow load.

Structures like this are fun to design.  Do not skimp on the column size and enjoy the experience!

 

Best regards,

BA

RE: gas station canopy

Yes, BA is right.  These are fun.

It has been my experience (thus far), wind uplift and overturning always controls the size of the foundation.

RE: gas station canopy

There's still a bunch of those laying around next to gas stations all over southern Louisiana from Gustav...


If you "heard" it on the internet, it's guilty until proven innocent. - DCS

http://www.eng-tips.com/supportus.cfm

RE: gas station canopy

Gas station canopy design specialist crank these cantilever designs out two per day for five hundred dollars each.  Soil bearing values vary and make each one unique.

RE: gas station canopy

This type of canopy doesn't hold up well to being struck by the digging boom of a Ditch Witch trencher either.  I can still remember the lurching that was going on complete with all the falling of the florescent light bulbs when I drove that truck with a DW trencher under it and the boom caught the canopy.  I hit it a good lick and put quite a tweak in it, but it didn't fall.

I bet that wasn't factored into the original design.

rmw

RE: gas station canopy

I've done quite a few cantilevered canopy designs...yes, they are more fun than the others.  Expect large columns, huge footings, and strong moment connections at the columns as noted by others.

RE: gas station canopy

rmw brought out a good point, make sure that the canopy columns are well protected from traffic impacts.  For overhead impacts well we can make the whole world "idiot" proof

RE: gas station canopy

Be conservative!

These things (along with pre-engineered buildings) are the first structures you see on the Weather Channel floating away during a windstorm. It says to me that we don't use the same factors of safety for these as we do for other structures. I don't know that ASCE 7 properly covers them.
 

RE: gas station canopy

I hear the word 'canopy', 'free roof' and 'awning' thrown around interchangeably (is that a word?). Can someone please inform me if there is a difference between these three forms of roof.

Otherwise, design as a cantilever and ensure that the foundation has capcity to resist overturning. You may be able to use outriggers to tie the columns together in the out-of-plane direction.

RE: gas station canopy

asixth,

The use of these words varies somewhat with geographic location, but an awning is usually attached to a larger structure.  In the OP, I think canopy is appropriate.

RE: gas station canopy

I did a repair on one of these in WI.  A truck & camper with some crap tied to the top ran into the roof deck.  It developed some P-delta action and was enough to tip the free standing canopy into the adjacent wood frame main building.  That, in turn, seemed to be enough to cause problems with the door and window operation of the main building.  Weird stuff.  Part of the problem was probably that 80 of the building walls were glass.

RE: gas station canopy

I'd like to contact Ron privately if possible to ask a few things about this thread. Would it be possible Ron?

RE: gas station canopy

I have a patio canopy near a building, that is similar to a gas station type canopy, that I need to analyze for wind uplift.  I don't have a copy of ASCE-7 handy.  Can anyone tell me if ASCE-7 addresses calculating uplift forces?
Thanks in advance.

RE: gas station canopy

FDiego...sorry I didn't see your post until now.  Yes, you may contact me through the Eng-Tips procedure.
 

RE: gas station canopy

I was driving a few weeks ago during some relatively high winds (maybe 30-40 mph) and saw a gas station canopy with only columns where the roof of the canopy was moving A LOT.  I mean on the order of at least 1.5' at the ends - this did look exaggerated as one end was 1.5' up and the other end was 1.5' down (it reminded me of someone shaking out a blanket with the way the "waves" were moving through the roof).  I actually called the station and suggested he have someone look at it since it really didn't look safe.  The guy seemed kind of pissed off and annoyed that I called and said that it's supposed to do that.  Bear in mind, I didn't talk all high and mighty to the guy (I didn't even say I was a structural engineer).  I just called as a concerned citizen.  
Is that true?  Are they designed to do that?  I almost couldn't believe it.  If it was moving that much in a 30 or 40 mph wind, what would it do in the 90 mph wind that it was designed for?

RE: gas station canopy

When you have a lot of motion you get a whole additional set of aerodynamic "wing" effects that I don't think ASCE really captures. It seems to me that 18" sway with "fluttering" could spell trouble at higher speeds.  

RE: gas station canopy

StructuralEIT....no it should not do that.  That indicates the designer did not limit the deflection of the cantilevered column to a tolerable value.   

RE: gas station canopy

Sounds like the gas station operator may have done his own design.

RE: gas station canopy

"The guy seemed kind of pissed off and annoyed that I called and said that it's supposed to do that."

That's classic.

RE: gas station canopy

I should clarify that it was the roof that was moving up and down 1.5'.  The roof itself looked like a blanket being shaken at the beach (and this was only a 30-40 mph wind).  To be honest, I didn't even look at the column drift, but that's because I was so surprised (and focused on) by the amount of movement of the roof.

RE: gas station canopy

I'm sorry StructuralEIT, but are you saying FEET or INCHES?

If it is feet, then my only advice would be RUN!!!!!

RE: gas station canopy

FEET!  It really was crazy, that's why I called.

RE: gas station canopy

Was it a two-post structure?

I checked one of these one time where it was not really stable - sort of a teeter-totter in one direction. The designer inadvertantly was relying on load-symmetry to "balance" things out. Otherwise they might have seen the deflections you are describing.  

RE: gas station canopy

Yes, it had only two columns.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources