×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Porsche 944 timing belt system
2

Porsche 944 timing belt system

Porsche 944 timing belt system

(OP)
I've recently purchased one of these cars, an '84 normally aspirated model.  These engines are famous for eating their valves when the belt breaks/slips/feels like it.  Searching on-line I've found instances where qualified techs installed a new belt and idlers (all the bearings and belts are sold as a kit) and the engine ate the valves as little as 9,000 miles later, at idle, in the owner's driveway.  It happens so often that the most common mod to these cars is to install a Chevy V8.

Do any of you in the industry have any insight as to the problems with this system?  I see nothing unusual about the system, if anything it seems to have lots of wrap on the pulleys and good support along its runs.

Porsche subsequently went to chain drives on the turbo models of this engine, and they seem to have their own set of problems.

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

It's odd that Honda / Toyota (et al) can get over 100,000km reliably from rubber timing belts. Years ago Fiat (and I assume others) was getting 20,000km (miles?) reliably (and my undertsanding is that those old belts weren't nearly as good as more modern ones).

I wonder if the Porsche belts might live (and die) in a hotter engine bay?  

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

For a start there are degrees of interference. The engine on my Toyota ran for two years with a one tooth error in the timing belt. On another design that might have caused an embarrassing metallic noise.

The belt on my car doesn't look much smaller than that on much bigger engines, so I suspect different manufacturers stress their belts to a different extent. Belts are available in various grades (three from Gates).

So between all that lot, you shrugs and read other people's experience.




 

Cheers

Greg Locock

SIG:Please see FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips.

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

(OP)
I have heard there is a Mitsubishi-spec belt that is more durable, and is being used by some.  I can't see anything that adds stress oveer any otheer OHC engine, although the sprockets are somewhat smaller in diameter, which directly relates to belt forces.

This engine has NO tolerance, in fact I am shocked at how thoroughly a job the pistons do on the valves -- double bends in the stems.  Not cheap to repair!

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

The older Honda Prelude 2.0L FI engines would run with the timing belt out one tooth as well.  Kinda lacked power though.  I've heard of multiple people breaking a timing belt (at idle and at highway speed) on the Honda engines without damaging a valve, they must be zero-interference designs.

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

I've had two belt failures in the past...one on a Fiat 124, twice!  The first time, no harm, no foul.  The second totally wasted the valves...I sold that sucker for twenty five cents!!! No joke.  The Orange County Sheriff's deputy was going to have it towed and I sold it for 25cents.
Second was on our 83 Turbocoupe.  As it turns out, the valves cannot reach the pistons on this Ford engine so no problem, just replace the belt taking care to line up all the pulleys, oil pump drive, dizzy, etc.
One other comment on reliability of the belt...When I rebuilt the 2.3 Turbocoupe engine to much higher hp (295 @ the wheels on the dyno) I chose the Goodyear belt recommended by JBA  and changed it at 50k miles and it was still in the car at 100k miles when I sold it.

The last few cars I have purchased don't use belts...I just don't need the added aggravation at this point.

Rod

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

Temperature will have a big influence on belt life just like any rubber component.  The first gen DSM motors killed the timing belts on the turbo motors before 50k but they would go about double that on the NA motors.  Mitsubishi had a service campaign and replaced the belts no charge with a higher grade belt.

I'm surprised Porsche couldn't get these to live.  The devil is in the details.

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

Bear in mind that the forces in the belt are strongly affected by the camshaft torque and the speed of the engine as well. Pootling around at 2500 rpm all the time is different is to redlining at every traffic light.

Cheers

Greg Locock

SIG:Please see FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips.

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

(OP)
Greg, that's what surprised me;  at least three of the people on the Porsche forum I checked out had their belts fail at idle!  Could be coincidence, but also makes me suspect a harmonic?  The old GM 90-degree V6's in GMC trucks and Buicks used to break timing chains all the time due to the uneven cam loads.

It just ain't rocket science, I would have expected more from Porsche.

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

Idle speed is one of the worst-case conditions for variation in crank speed on each revolution.

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

Having replaced several 944 cam belts, I would like to comment. One didn't bend valves (broke at idle speed). The usual tensioning technique (quarter turn, moderate thumb pressure, longest span) would sing like a bird. Had to resort to adjusting at idle speed, not for the faint of heart. I suspect harmonics also. Good luck

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

Is there any possibility to add a suplementary idler, idealy halfway the longest span?
Even with minimal tensioning it will reduce the belt orbiting or avoid it coming in resonance.

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

(OP)
JCD,  that is essentially what Porsche did in one of their attempts to fix the issue.  They added a slipper-type guard on the water pump, to separate the two runs of the belt at their closest approach in the mid-span of the long tension-side run.  They also made one idler a larger diameter.  Looks to me like they suspected teeth on the two runs might be snagging each other when flapping around under variable tension -- just what you'd expect at idle.

They later went to a spring tensioner, then to a hydraulic one, but there is little improvement in belt endurance.  Bottom line?  They did not properly engineer the one system that needs to be bulletproof on an interference engine.   

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

RossABQ,

I just only noticed the picture with your first post.
The TB idler pulley prevents the belt to go orbiting but doesn't prevent it to deflect inwards.
The traction side of the belt goes straight from the crank pulley to the camshaft pulley. This is not the case in for example most of the DOHC engines.
If the idler pulley forces the belt to make an inward bend it will probably hold it better seated against the pulley. Unfortunately there seems to be very few place here for such a construction.
Is it possible to start the engine without the belt cover (or with one with a window) and film the belt with a high speed camera?

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

(OP)
JCD,  you are exactly correct, and Porsche addressed the problem accordingly in later versions.  My take on the situation overall is this;  there are several causative factors.

The original design had only static tensioners, so when the belt is properly set for running conditions, it is noticeably looser when the engine is cold (all aluminum engine).  Many of the failures are idling in the driveway on initial start-up.

As you note, the tension run is long and largely unsupported. It also passes close by the opposing run, and at idle, I'm betting the long run flops around enough to actually touch the other run (cog to cog).

So what the engineers at Porsche did, in 3 distinct steps, was this:  They added a guard rail, a smooth sheet of stainless, between the two runs at their closest approach.  Then they replaced the static tensioner pulley with a spring-loaded one.  Apparently that was also unsatisfactory, so they later made it a hydraulically-actuated (oil pressure) tensioner.  (I said in my OP that they later went to a chain, that is incorrect)

The shield prevents contact, the active tensioners addressed the cold-to-hot variations.  

What's also interesting is that this engine is half of the 928's V8, and the V8 models apparently were not prone to belt issues (because the two runs never approached each other closely?)

I found the maintenance records on my 944, which has 97,000 miles on it.  It's on its 4th set of belts and tension rollers.  The bill at each replacement was over $1,000 (parts and labor).   

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

FWIW, I never owned an '84 944, but my '85 is run hard, belts changed as per schedule and never any trouble to this day.  Also, I never knew of any reliable reports of dealer-installed OEM belts slipping or failing at 9,000 miles.  IF this early failure occurred, I would suspect aftermarket belt, incorrect installation or adjustment  There were improvements to later versions, but these cars are twenty-five years old now and most have been sold down the river to impecunious owners likely to ignore the schedule or use shadetree shops rather than the OEM dealer.

thnx, jack vines

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

(OP)
Packard, most of my anecdotal info came off Rennslist and 944Online forums.  Not the average "tuner" types on there, mostly pretty experienced D-I-Y'ers and racers.  

I finished the water pump upgrade a week ago, with new belts, idlers, and tensioners.  I tensioned the belts using my thumb and index finger, 90-degree twist method.  I am about ready to open it up for the re-check after initial run, but no problems so far. The balance belt is quiet.

There really are no aftermarket belts, all are either Conti or Gates (OEM).  

It's hard for me to accept that an '84 model is a 25-yr-old car, an antique in most states!

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

You could say ---It's hard for me to accept that an '84 model is a 25-yr-old car, an antique in most states!

My wife's "new Lincoln" is the same age as MY first car, a '49 Mercury---and---at the time, I thought it was positively ancient, a vintage classic !!!

How time flies AND how much my attitude has changed.

Rod



 

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

I like the color.  Needs a bit of pinstriping around the waist...thin red, maybe.  Also a tailgate...I don't like to drive a truck without the tailgate and a good solid bumper!

Rod

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

2
I have built 944 motors and raced 944's for the past 6 years and have owned 944's for 15 years. The timing belt system in the 944 is a well designed including the updated system which is only as good as the person installing updated/new parts and belts. Several problems occur when installing a new timing belt, balance shaft belt, rollers and other parts. The reason for the guide was due to the larger pulley on the Turbo style water pump which was updated due to the additional heat generated by the turbo having water pumped through it to keep the turbo cool. The larger pulley required a guide due to the lack of clearance as the belt passes closer to the other half of the belt which also required the change in the roller size. When the timing belt is reinstalled many times the belt is installed off by one or two teeth a common human error and or due to worn keyways and or the head being milled on a rebuild or cut 40-60 thousands for increased compression. The entire pulley system can be off by one tooth and the only way to verify is with a cam degree system such as Web Cam check. Another problem is the failure to have the belt adjusted after 500-1000 miles as required by Porsche. Another failure is not the belt but a roller due to a failure to replace or inspecting and upon inspecting incorrectly believing a loose spinning roller is good when in fact is worn out as the rollers should show resistance when spun. Finally the installation of the balance shaft belt incorrectly causing excessive vibration and wear including the failure of the fuel rail do to the continued vibration with an end result of an occasional fire, exhaust cracks, loose nuts and bolts. The balance shaft system was designed to keep the motor running smoothly at idle and lower rpm. I remove the balance shaft belt and all rollers in both my race cars and street cars. I have changed belts in a 22 year old turbo based in dry Arizona with the original belts and water pump with the small water pump pulley. The belts were so worn I was able to peal off the ribs. I change belts every 2-3 years depending on use as a cheap investment to valve train damage at a cost of $20 for a timing belt there is no reason for a broken belt done properly and changed every few years. One last failure I have seen was due to over tightening a pulley and the stud broke off causing the timing belt to be destroyed, human error with an air wrench! Too many people wait until 30,000 miles which can be 10-20 years.  Anyone with a Hanes or equal manual can perform all of the belt, rollers, water pump work and keep these well engineered cars running smoothly. All of the above information I have provided is from my experience with these cars.  I have yet to see a timing belt failure under racing conditions.

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

raceu speaks to a  problem I've seen many times over the years..."I just don't know what happened, I followed the instructions to the letter, but it just won't run right"!
Pretty good 1st post in the forum, I'd say.

It was never ok, in my shop, to change a belt or chain without taking the time to double ck the timing...An easy step that should always be done.  Many engines that have separate drives for balance shafts, dist drives, oil pump drives can very easily get 'out of sinc' and cause monster problems, even if the camshaft timing is correct.

I have made no secret of my disdain for 'belt drives' in the past and nothing has happened in the last few years to change my mind.  I used belts on the cam drives of a couple Ford/Cosworth based race engines that worked well enough---with constant maintenance!  For a street car, it's a shortcut in mfgring that I could do without...I won't buy a car with a belt.

Rod

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

(OP)
raceu, You've brought up a pertinent point; Porsche recommends that after you pay a mechanic maybe 4 -6 hours labor to put the belts in (simplest scenario, even more for a water pump job), you are supposed to drive it a couple of weeks and then pay him to essentially re-do the job, "just to be sure"?!  Name another car where this is called for...

I did my belts and the water pump upgrade, and haven't had any problems so far.  Well, just the normal Bosch problems...

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

Hi, Ross,

You said, "Porsche recommends that after you pay a mechanic maybe 4 -6 hours labor to put the belts in (simplest scenario, even more for a water pump job), you are supposed to drive it a couple of weeks and then pay him to essentially re-do the job, "just to be sure"?!  Name another car where this is called for..."

As always, your car, your money your decision.  However, raceu gives it straight and true.  I've known 944s and their owners since the car was new.  Some are made for each other; some are not.  My suggestion, based upon many years of observation - Cut your losses, sell the 944 now.  I can opine from your posts you are most likely never going to be happy with the car.

thnx, jack vines

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

(OP)
Jack,  you have hit the nail on the head!  I am full of angst over what could go wrong on the car.  I've been driving it and like it in many respects, but the thought of having to replace the torque tube bearings (around $2500 at the shops, and some parts are no longer available) or similar work is ever-present in my mind. I'm becoming comfortable with the cam belt system. Of course, the TT bearings are noisy... So I don't know what I'll do.  I have $2500 into the car, it gets in the mid-20's for gas mileage, and is a nice looking car.  I could throw a lot of money into it, and still have less into it than a crappy Hyundai that needs no maintenance but is thoroughly boring.  Not like I'll be in the bread lines if it nukes out.   

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

Ross, Jack is right on. Eliminate all the stress and just sell the damn thing!  There are several very nice, maintenance friendly sporty drives out there, perhaps a Miata, a MR-2 or something like that would better suit you.  I have a couple of friends that owned the "hatch back Audi" and were never happier when they sold them.  Obviously they are, like my Lotus and Mini Cooper, NOT for everyone!!!

No worse feeling than the realization that you have just thrown good money down the drain...unless it's the knowledge that you are STILL doing it!

Rod

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

(OP)
We'll see, I need something to do in my retirement (was going to be in 3 yrs -- now, who knows??)   

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

Retirement will always be "just out of reach".  At least it was for me, for years...I finally just 'bit the bullet' and pulled the pin (don't you just love the English language?) in 1998...It cost me a bit, retiring early...I'll never regret it, best thing I ever did. I got lucky with the stock thing and cashed everything in in Nov. of 2007, Whew!  However, I have cut back on some of my automobile hobby stuff, sold my '37 Buick and my '58 Morris and, on that same note, I have my '59 Nash Metropolitan up for sale (such a deal I can make you, Ross!!!)...I'm cutting back because I'll be 69 next month and I just don't have the energy (desire?) to mess with all of them.  

Hope you make it ok.  Seems like a lot of members are loosing their jobs...That sucks, I know...BTDT!

Rod

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

rod, I'm filled with encouragement at the thought that if I can follow your example, I have 20+ years to go before losing "the energy (desire) to mess with all" my toys, present and future. cheers

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

Hemi, you will be pleased to know that I have not given up completely...Just sent in my entries for a couple upcoming events for my Mini Cooper race car.  This year is the 50th anniversary of the Mini...

http://www.canam50minirace.com/Entrylist.html

http://forum.moasf.com/index.php?topic=2875.0

If your in the neighborhood...Also we are taking the Lotus Cortina out to Willow Springs in April 4th/5th VARA race for my son to drive his first race.

http://www.vararacing.com/

Rod

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

Hehe most common mod is a Chevy V8, thats pretty good.

When the belts are replaced on a 944, it must have the tension checked 1500 miles later. The new belts stretch out a lot. Its a quick simple procedure, I think shop time is specced at 1 hour if that for an 944NA. The plastic belt covers are removed and the tension should be checked with the tools designed for the job.... Not the hokey finger twist method. If it doesnt get checked on schedule then the belt gets too loose and damage can happen. No reason to sell it, as long as you follow the proper maintenance schedules and procedures for doing the belts.

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

(OP)
Just a shame that the "tool designed for the job" costs upwards of $500! sad I pulled off the one plastic cover, the belts have maybe 200 miles on them, and the tensions seem to be the same as installed.  No noise from the balance shaft belt, always a good sign.   

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

"The fault, dear Brutus, lies not in our stars (or in the 944) but in ourselves."

My point was the OP has a unresolvable conflict between what is now a very cheap car to buy, but a very expensive car to maintain.  My experience is OP will let the maintenance costs obscure the unique virtues of the 944 and resent more than enjoy the ride.  As Willy Nelson titled one of his earlier songs, "She's Not For You."

thnx, jack vines

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

(OP)
There's an interesting thread on the Rennslist forum;  "What is the true cost of those $1500 944's?"
http://forums.rennlist.com/rennforums/924-931-944-951-968-forum/486168-what-is-the-true-cost-of-those-1500-944s.html

No surprises there...

Jack, my original post was questioning how Porsche, a preeminent engineering house, botched what is a basic system mastered by every 3rd tier auto manufacturer.  It has kind of devolved into a rant or whining session, my apologies for that.  I actually find the costs of parts to be more or less stuck in the '80's, a 5-yr-old Camry would cost more to repair, part-for-part.  

 

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

rod, thanks for the inspiration... keep the faith! peace

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

Rod, did you, as I, in the fall of 2007, look around at the proliferation of furniture/home electronics rental stores, pay check loan establishments, check "cashing" outlets, and say to yourself "what is happening here?" When asked, My money guy told me that the revenue stream from these businesses, ( all owned by big firms, Citi, etc) was "packaged" and sold into the derivatives market, like a bushel of wheat. Ya know, you can at least eat a bushel of wheat. You can't eat a "promise to pay" from consumers who cannot even live paycheck to paycheck, without kiteing checks ( for a 'fee', of course ). At that point I went to 80% cash, tho I am 6-7 years out from retirement. Glad I did.

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

I lost my shirt in the 2000 tech "market correction"...Enough so that I went back to school and took courses in commodities trading.  I did that for a few years, not too bad...a little better than 'even', mostly gold and silver.  I gave that up as it was just too much work.  It did, however, teach me the lesson of "DON'T GET GREEDY".  In '07 things just started sounding too good to be true.  I'd been through one correction in the market and it was looking much the same.  I bailed out, perhaps a little early to catch the peak, but that's just fine with me (in hindsight)!!!

Hang in there, I did not start preparing for retirement until I was 50.  I planned to retire at 65, but things worked out so well that I retired at 58...Best thing I ever did.

I've kept up with my old portfolio...if I had stayed in the market, I would have lost >60% !!!!!!!!!!! I'd probably be one of those "greeters", the old geezers, at Wall*Mart ;o(

Rod

RE: Porsche 944 timing belt system

Great story, good luck with the Mini & Cortina.  

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources