×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

(OP)
Hi folks,

Has anybody experience on neutral instability during the energizing of a wye-delta transformer?
 
The transformer is energized throught the high voltage (230 kV) of which windings are wye connected and the neutral grounded.

The low voltage (69 kV) windings are conected in delta and, therefore, have a "ficticious" neutral point.

My questions are:

1. How this "ficticious" neutral point behaves with relation to the grounding during the transformer energizing?

2. If there is a TP on each phase of the delta side with its primary winding connected between the phase and the grounding, what kind of voltage I will get from this TP?

3. Is it possible to get a phase to grounding voltage bigger the phase to phase voltage?

I would appreciate your thoughts!

Best regards,

Herivelto Bronzeado   

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

If the delta secondary is open circuited, and not grounded, you may be getting capacitive coupling with the 230 kV winding.
This could result in voltages to ground greater than the phase to phase voltage.
Also,a wye-delta transformer experiences switching surges when energized. I understand that these surges can reach 200%, but I may be corrected here. If your wye grounding does not have good continuity or has a high impedance back to the source, you may be getting switching surges. These surges are transient and will dampen out.
Is your 230 kV/69 kV transformer large enough that the potential transformers may not be able to drain the capacitive voltage from the 69 kV winding?

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

From my standpoint, that's a pretty unusual connection for a 230 kV transformer.  Normally, 230 kV is a 3-wire circuit.  Most transformer connections from 230 kV that I'm familiar with are delta wye.

How do you establish a ground connection at the transformer?  There's no way to tie it back to the source unless you use a static wire.  In any event, it's probably a fairly high impedance path to ground.  For this reason, I would be tempted to treat it more like a floating wye delta connection.

On the distribution scene, this connection has been shown to cause overvoltages due to single-pole energization, with phase to ground voltages of 2.65 per unit possible.  How are you energizing the transformer?  I'd imagine you're using a circuit breaker or gand operated switch.  If that's the case, then I wouldn't worry about getting the 2.65 pu value.

Did you have any arrester failures associated with this?

Finally, what's a TP?  Terminal pole doesn't seem to fit.

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

(OP)
Dear Bill and Magoo2,

For your information, I am talking about a 100MVA, 230/69kV transformer wye-delta connected. The neutral point of the wye (230 kV) is solid grounding.

In general, we have more that one transformer with the same connection in a substation. Normally our delta system (69kV) has a grounding reference given by a zig-zag transformer.

When the second transformer (100MVA, 230/69kV, wye-delta) is energized by closing a 230kV circuit breaker, the delta (69 kV) will be open (including a bay of 50-100 m of cable from transformer bushing to circuit breaker) for some time before closing the 69kV circuit breaker that inserts the transformer to the system. My question is related to what happens with the "ficticious" neutral of the delta side during this period of time (transformer energizing).

May this "ficticious" neutral point reach some "positions" against grounding in which the phase-to-ground is bigger than phase-to-phase voltage?

Please, send me any literature or thougth on that. I need to anderstand this phenomenon.

Thanks Bill for you input. I will consider the capacitive coupling between the windings.

Best regards,

Herivelto  
  

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

First off, I'd say that your transformer connection is quite common, 69kV systems tend to be delta sourced relative to the "infinite bus".

Your fictitious neutral will tend to be somewhere within the voltage triangle.  The placement of that neutral will be determined by the capacitance to ground from each phase.  To the extent that those capacitances are balanced (they won't be) your neutral will be in the middle of the triangle.  The only way to get the neutral outside the triangle is to charge those capacitances, open and then reclose out of phase with the stored charge.

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

(OP)
Thank David for your reply.

Please, have in mind that the transformer is being energized, with the poles of the circuit breaker closing in different instants. So the "capacitances" involved may be charged differently of each other.

Also, inrush currents of high magnitude will flow throught the transformer primary windings (230 kV, wye) and may go into the ground.

Best regards,

H. Bronzeado

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

Are you trying to get to the root of specific misoperation or is this more general?

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

(OP)
David,

We have a lot of transformers wye-delta (230/69kV) in our system. During transformer energizing, it has been found phase-to-ground overvoltages in the delta side (69 kV) which remain for some time. These overvoltages seems to be caused by:
 
a) Neutral instability or

b) Ferro-resonance

What I expect to get from this forum of experts is some technical information, some light, to explain this phenomenon.

Bill (see above) has given some tips which I will work on that.

The voltage measurements comes from PTs with their primary windings connected betweem each phase of the delta system and the ground.

Best regards,

H. Bronzeado
 
    

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

What is the primary rating of your VTs?  If it is 40kV, rather than 69kV, the VTs will be going into saturation with the peak of voltage of each phase.  Do you have any physical evidence of overvoltage on the 69kV system or are you only seeing overvoltage on the secondary of the VT circuit?

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

(OP)
David,

The VT primary rating is 69kV.

So far, we have not seen any physical evidence of overvoltage on the 69 kV, only on the secondary of the VTs circuit.

Regards,

H. Bronzeado



  

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

Try adding some resistive loading to your VT secondaries.  My guess is that you don't have a problem at the 69kV level, but you do have a problem on the VT secondary.  Once the transformer is connected to the rest of the 69kV system you could even disconnect the loading resistance from the VT.

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

(OP)
Thanks David for your advice.

That is one solutionn for ferro-ressonance. Is it the phenomennon that is happening?

I would like to know a physical explaination on the phenomenon that is really happening.

My guess so far from discussions on "instability" of the neutral point of the delta side are:

1. Voltage rise of the substation grounding network during the transformer energizing due to the high inrush currents going into the ground network.

2. Voltage transfer due to the capacitance divider formed by the capacitances between the windings (high and low voltages) and the windings (delta) and ground (Bill suggestion as far I anderstood).

As a consequence, the delta neutral point will be at a "position" at which phase-to-ground overvoltages may impar the equipment, includind saturation of the PTs and, perhaps, the power transformer.

If ferro-ressonance appears, it should be the effect not the cause.

Do you agree with these comments?

Regards,

H. Bronzeado
   

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

Capacitive coupling at 60Hz should be quite low; at lightning type high frequencies the transformer looks like a capacitor between the two sides, but not at the power system frequency.  Do you have relays on the 69kV VT secondary circuit that can be programmed to capture a waveform of the voltage as the transformer is energized?  Knowing what the voltage looks like could help in figuring it out.

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

Hi Herivelto.
Are you have some news on the issue?
Could you please explain why you start with this Q's.
My collegue sent me today other case ( but on the same issue), he see this is ferroresonance problem on the VT. But in case of two VT's on the BB w/o any load ( 10kV). In case of one VT, no problem, and this case occure only on the one SS.
Are you have this effect in the special place or on the few installation?
Best Regards.
Slava

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

Hi Herivelto.
Are you have broken delta connection in the your VT?
I haven't documents on the English.
It's problem of small C ( you need add some 150-200m of cable for avoid this effect). In the Russia lot of MV grid is isolated neutral and this effect is very known.
Neutral point driven, but of VT.
It's effect of saturation of VT cores, and isn't same saturation per one phase VT, C and L are changes up to current resonance (C=L). This also move to increas of phase to ground voltage.
Hope that help.
Best Regards.
Slava

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

(OP)
Hi Slava,

I will try to get some voltage waveforms (69 kV) in order to show a better picture of the phenomenon we talk about.

I still thinking that ferro-ressonance (if it happens) may be an effect of the phase-to-ground overvoltage, NOT the cause.

Regards,

Herivelto  

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

Hi Herivelto
We wrote togehter smile.
I haven't option now check this effect, but in the begining of 2009, we'll start commissioning of some SS, where we have this option, but it will be 11kV.
Regards.
Slava

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

This sounds like a good application for an EMTP like ATP.  Have you tried modeling this in an EMTP program?

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

Without very good information on the saturation characteristics of the transformers there'd be no point in an EMTP study.  Good saturation models can be very difficult to come by.  Sure, you could use some generic saturation information, but it might not do a lot of good for the very specific case in question.

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

Bronzeado,I came across this phenomena some 25 years back and had to struggle for several weeks to understand it,find a solution etc.Great American engineers of GE & WH had studied this and 4-5   AIEE papers ( of 1940's) describe this.They called it  as neutral inversion- some form of feroresonnance.I had all of them,but at the moment I find it difficult  to locate the titles.I shall try.The solution is to connect a capacitor to delta lines or close the secondary delta of CTs through a resistor.But once you have zig-zag trfs connected,this will not be a problem.

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

(OP)
David is correct when saying that we need a VERY GOOD information (and very good models) to do a simulation of this phenomenon.

prc, I will waiting for the papers. PLEASE, try to find them. Thank you!

Regards,

H. Bronzeado

  
 

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

Hi.
Additional capacitors, this is a point.
Instead this I would recommend use longer cable from delta side of trafo. Longer cable add capacity to circuit.
Second, in lot of application we are installed zig-zag trafo before trafo CB.
Best Regards.
Slava

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

(OP)
Hi folks,

Please, find attached the voltage and current measurements during a 100MVA, 230/69 kV, wye/delta transformer energizing, by closing the 230kV circuit-breaker.

From the top to the bottom, it can be seen:

1. 230 kV voltage waveforms (Va, Vb and Vc)
2. Currents on the 230 kV side (inrush currents, Ia, Ib and Ic)
3. 3V0 voltage waveform (Va+Vb+Vc, 69 kV)
4. 69 kV voltage waveforms (Va, Vb and Vc)

My question is: why the 69 kV voltages behaves like that?

Best regards,

H. Bronzeado

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

Hi Herivelto.
You need additional capacitance in your installation.
It's VT saturation.
Are you have antiresonance resistor across broken delta connection of VT about 22-27Ohm 350-400W.
Reagrads.
Slava
 

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

(OP)
Thank you, Slava, for your advice.

However, I need to understand what is happens before applying any solutions.
So, I wonder if somebody could explain why this voltage behaves like that.

1. Is it due to the electrical coupling between high and low windings?

2. Is it due to a grounding rising?

3. This happens due to zero sequence current circulating in the delta windings?

4. As the potential transformer is connected between phase-to-ground in the delta side (69 kV), are the voltage measurements correct (assuming the capacitance of the bay is the same for all phases) or meanless?

5. Is this phenomenon caused by ferro-ressonance or it may cause ferro-ressonace as the VTs may saturate (cause or effect)?

Bill, magoo2, davidbeach, slava, ePOWEReng, prc, you have the words.

Best regards,

H. Bronzeado
   

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

Bronzeado, I wish I could locate the old AIEE papers.The neutral inversion or shifting is occurring in an unearthed system due to resonnance of inductance of the transformer winding with the capacitance on the terminals.At certain values of L vs C this happens. By putting a capacitor on the line we are moving away from that resonnance point withe respect to the L &C of the system.It has nothing to do with any of the points mentioned by you.

RE: Transformer saturation-driven neutral instability

(OP)
Thank you, prc.

Herivelto

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources