×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

(OP)
We have a job where the contractor and testing agency is telling us that the A490 bolts are loosening all by themselves.  The bolts in question are 7/8" diameter x 2-3" long, and are being used in top & bottom plate moment connections on floor beams, so loaded primarily in shear.  (non-seismic zone)  We only are requiring snug tight connection.  

They are telling us that within a few hours of tightening them to (supposedly) snug tight, that they can go back and run the nut off by hand.

None of us here have ever seen this before.  There is only three things that I cna think of that would cause this:

1.  Flange and moment plate are not in full contact, so the plate is relaxing under the load, and thus the tension on the bolts is also relaxing.
2.  Tightening method is not reliable, in that they are not going back over the bolts after they have brought the plies together to ensure that they are all still tight.
3.  the bolts are poor quality steel, and are relaxing under the tension from the initial tightening.

Has anyone seen this before?  Do you have any suggestions for what the problem is, or how to solve it?

I am ready to tell them to test a random sampling of the bolts for ultimate strength and for creep/relaxation properties.  Does anyone know if there is an ASTM test method for this?  I have not found one yet in my web searching.

Thanks very much.

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

As you tighten one bolt, the adjacent ones could become loose. I would suggest re-tightening all bolts before re-checking.

I have always used slip critical bolts in oversized holes for this application. See ASD 9th Edition, pg. 4-110 and 111, toward the bottom of each page.  

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

Isn't it required to have slip critical bolts in moment connections?

RC
All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing.
    Edmund Burke

 

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

(OP)

Quote:

As you tighten one bolt, the adjacent ones could become loose. I would suggest re-tightening all bolts before re-checking.

We have asked them that, and they claim to be doing it right.  This has been happening for a while now, some areas have been inspected and failed 4 times now.

Quote:

I have always used slip critical bolts in oversized holes for this application. See ASD 9th Edition, pg. 4-110 and 111, toward the bottom of each page.  

I would too, but in this case, the engineer that designed the connection specified standard holes with bolts in bearing.   Also, we just found out that they are using A490 bolts instead of the A325 bolts that were specified.  

All of this is just coming to our attention, even though the contractor and testing agency have been dealing with it for some time. Now that it is affecting their schedule (they were supposed to start fireproofing this week), they are getting us involved.

 

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

(OP)

Quote:

Isn't it required to have slip critical bolts in moment connections?

In this case, clip critical is not required.  These are wind frames with no seismic requirement.  The code generally recognizes that MWFRS components are not subject to "significant load reversal", as the wind is generally considered quasi-static loading, so typically slip critical is not required.

Also, they are not sharing load with welds, so no requirement in that case for slip critical.
 

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

Sounds like a problem with bolt quality.  Are the bolts of reputable manufacture or from some unknown foreign source?

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

Is there enough extention on the anchor bolts to double nut?

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

I would be surprised if you can have all these holes line up in the field for bearing without drifting or enlarging some holes. How could bolts in bearing possibly work in this case? Have you ask the ironworkers about this? I assume you also have finger shims or strip shims (which are not welded), therefore you still need slip critical bolts.

The flange plates tend not to sit flat against the beam flange; they often tilt upward from welding.

Can you make these connections work with slip critical values since they provided A490's in lieu of A325's and you already have an acceptable faying surface since you are fireproofing. If so, have them fully torque the bolts. If not, you may have to weld.

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

Wrong on the slip critical comments.  Bearing bolts are allowed for these applications, even in seismic connections.  (In seismic, the surface has to be prepped for slip critical, and the bolts fully torqued, but bearing is still OK for analysis.)  Even with shims, bearing bolts are allowed.  There is a strength reduction factor to be used if the shim is thicker than 1/4".

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

(OP)
I have no idea about the bolt quality.  That is why I am thinking of having them submit the bolt cut sheets, and even making them test the bolts.

I don't know about bolt extension right now.  I have one of my junior engineers down at the job site now to look at some of these things, including holes sizes and alignment issues.  And yes there are shims in place, but I am not aware of requirement for slip critical with shim.  Can you point out a reference please?

I think we could definitely make them fully tighten the bolts, though I don't know yet (have not yet run the numbers) if the bolts would be adequate in slip ciritcal.  But in reality, they are still in bearing, as they would probably have slipped into bearing condition now, since the slabs have been cast.  Pockets in the slab were made at the bolts, to allow the bolts to be installed after the dead load of the slab was in place.  So we may make them fully tighten them, in hopes that they won't loosen once fully pretensioned.

Thanks for your help.   

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

structuresguy,
There are a few reasons why this may happen.
1)Are faying surfaces in intimate contact?
2)Are bolts being systematically tightened, from the most rigid point out?
3)Are washers hardend steel?
4)Is there any welding being performed on the connection after snugging the bolts? Thermal expansion will almost always cause snugged bolts to loosen. Although you state that your issues are occurring within 4 hours of snugging. Normal temp differences should not cause problems within 4 hours. But if welding is performed, then this can happen quickly.
A pre installation verification test may be of some help. Snugged bolt do not require this. But it may help determine if there are in fact issues with the material. Have the bolt snugged in a skidmore and held for a few hours.  

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

ASD, 9th edition J3, 2b says "finger shims up to 1/4" may be introduced into slip critical connections...

I may be wrong, but wouldn't you want the clamping force of slip critical bolts to prevent an unwelded shim from slipping? If it is welded, that is a different situation.

Perhaps the newer AISC codes cover this more expicitly.

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

Are these bolts just being used as an erection aid?

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

Re: shims, read ASD 9th, J6.  Shims of any thickness can be added to a slip critical connection.  Up to 1/4", they can be used in bearing connections with no reductioon.  Over 1/4", up to 3/4", the bolt bearing capacity is reduced, or you have to extend the shim past the connection and develop it.

The later AISC specifications do go into this a little more.

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

How are you tightening these bolts?
Turn of nut?  Torquing?

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

I'm with the guys who suggest that they're tightening some bolts, then tightening others, and not going back and re-tightening the first few.  

I've heard of something kinda like this happening with stainless steel, but not so much that they could be removed with just fingers.   

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

Way out.
Are they using enough wrench to properly snug tighten the bolts.
I was privy to a similar situation where the iron workers were using very short handled wrenches to tighten some 1" bolts and were coming up short in the required clamp load.  

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

Unclesyd - The requirement of snug tight doesn't quantify the amount of tensioning only that it be the result of the "full effort" of an ironworker.

That said, I would be surprised if an ironworker using an ordinary spud wrench could snug up all of these bolts effectively.  Typically a spud wrench and "cheater bar" are required to get the job done.  The 'cheater bar' is simply an extension added to the spud wrench to increase the moment arm.

Are the bolts coated or are they "black" bolts with no protective coating?  Sometimes on precoated bolts and nuts the coating will fail and clog the threads between the nut and bolt.  This is enough to prevent tightening even when you have a power wrench.

Regards,
Qshake
pipe
Eng-Tips Forums:Real Solutions for Real Problems Really Quick.
 

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

(OP)
Well, as is usually the case, teh simplest thing was the problem.  The erector had not inserted the shims, and had left a gap between the beam flange and the moment plate.  Unbelieveable.  So not only did they not follow our detial, they don't understand the meaning of snug tight.  I sure wish AISC certification was an enforceable requirement.  We spec it on all our jobs, but actually getting a certified fabricator/erector is like winning the lotto.

Thanks everyone for your help on this.  Hopefully this will no longer be an issue now.

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

If it's any consolation, in my universe, clearly disjoint with yours, 'snug' means something other than 'as tight as an ironworker can get it', and 'snug tight' means nothing.

... by the way, does the AISC definition explicitly specify use of a wrench?

 

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

(OP)
Yes, AISC defines snug tight (paraphrasing) as when all plies have been brought together by the full effort of an iron worker using a spud wrench.  So "snug tight" is an actual term for us in the structural world.  



 

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

What is wrong with tensioning these bolts ie turn them
1/3 after snug tight and see if they still loosen after
4 hours?

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

(OP)
Nothing at all.  Now that we have learned that they were not installing the shims, we are going to make them put the shims in place.  This should solve the problem.  But at this point, they want to be sure, so we will have them tighten the bolts beyond snug.

I can't believe that they went around and around with the testing agency, who kept failing the bolts, and no one figured out that they didn't have the shims in place.  Makes me really question both the erector and the testing agency.  I really hate the quality of the labor here in Florida.  I swear, the guys erecting steel today must have been washing dishes yesterday, or whatever other job the labor finder place put them in that day.

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

See previous thread about staked threads.  Can the bolts be staked or tack welded on to prevent them from backing off?

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

A490 bolts shouldn't be welded because the material is brittle.  

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

Structureguy...

Depending on the amount of tightening... it may not be possible to re-use the A490 bolts.  A490's should be able to be tensioned sufficiently that they will not work their way loose.

Dik

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

I was under the impression that A490 bolts were required to be fully tensioned regardless of the connection type.

Reference AISC Steel Construction Manual, 13th Edition, Commentary 16.2-25
"With this edition of this Specification, snug-tightened joints are also permitted for statically loaded applications involving ASTM A325 bolts and ASTM F1852 twist-off-type tension-controlled bolt assemblies in direct tension. However, snug-tightened installation is not permitted for these fastener in applications involving non-static loads, nor for applications involving ASTM A490 bolts."

My understanding of the above paragraph is that the A490 bolts are not to be used in the "snug-tight" connections.

Am I misinterpreting the paragraph?  

Best regards - Al  

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

Al, that applies to A490 bolts in tension; those must be fully tensioned.  A490 bolts in the bearing condition, with just shear applied, can be snug-tight.  See page 16.1-103, which says, "Bolts are permitted to be installed to only the snug-tight condition when used in (a) bearing-type connections ..."

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

I appreciate your help.

After carefully reading that section I see my mistake. It makes sense now.

Thanks again.  

Best regards - Al  

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

(OP)
Ya, that spec can be difficult to read, and its easy to miss things.

They ought to have a summary table identifying exactly what is required for different kinds of bolts in various situations.

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

Thanks for the link.

Best regards - Al  

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

(OP)
syd:  Thanks for the link.  Those look like great references.  I am going to order a set (bolts, weld, strucutral steel) for all our junior engineers to take out to the field with them when they do inspections.

RE: Help - A490 Bolts Loosening all by themselves

i use the both when I was a little more active and able to climb around. I used the a lot and like the literature says to help settle disagreements and I'm not a real structural guy.

I had both the bolts and the welding references and both have walked away. The one on bolting is in Alabama and is supposed to be returned while the one on welding is in NYC with an inspector for the Port authority.  

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources