×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Lean Amine Cooler

Lean Amine Cooler

Lean Amine Cooler

(OP)
I'm a fairly new mechanical/process engineer, and I have just a few questions.  I'm working for an air-cooled heat exchanger manufacturer, I'll keep that one to myself, and we've recently got into the world of process cooling.  I'm using HTRI to design my coolers and I take the process data from chemical engineers, and then size the appropriate cooler for temp, heat load, phase, pressure drop, etc etc.

I just have a quick question for all of you experts here.  I've been seeing a lot of Lean Amine and Propane coolers, are there any things that I should keep in mind when designing these coolers, such as certain fluid velocity or anything that I'm not thiking of. Any advice would be greatly appreciated.

RE: Lean Amine Cooler

Lean Amine velocities should be limited to 7 ft/s in Carbon Steel.

RE: Lean Amine Cooler

make sure you have complete control of the temperature out of it.  VFD fans, louvers, heat recirculation louvers, whatever it takes.

RE: Lean Amine Cooler

Be careful on your material selection.  Pls do not quote 214 welded tubes in amine service - it's just not the way to go.  

Because of northern climate, be sure and check your cold air horsepower draw and you can option in full warm air recirc systems.

RE: Lean Amine Cooler

(OP)
Thanks, I really appreciate the help.  I notice the Maximum Velocity value, but is there is a minimum velocity for lean amine?  

Also in response to maddocks, the customer is requiring SA-214 for the tube material, should I advise against this? And I always check the cold air horsepower draw, I do a lot of designs for Siberia.

RE: Lean Amine Cooler

well, if the client wants it, the client gets it.  I would carry 214 in your base price but provide a recommendation and option price for A-179 tubes.  That way you remain competitive.

RE: Lean Amine Cooler

(OP)
Thanks, what is the reasoning behind this? Is there erosion problem with the welded tubes?

RE: Lean Amine Cooler

(OP)
Ok, another question here.  I have an engineer now asking if the materials are acceptable for amine service. Such as all materials, Carbon Steel, being killed and normalized.  Is this common?

RE: Lean Amine Cooler

Most of your carbon steel materials should be normalized; A105N flanges indicate normalized already. When I talked with our cooler guy here, he mentioned that the seams in 214 tubes can become "nucleation" spots for corrosion to start and then accelerate.  Given the lack of inspection on cooler tubes, and the amount of gas that can leak if one ruptures (I was there when it happened!), I'm happy spending a little more money on the proper tubes.

RE: Lean Amine Cooler

(OP)
Thanks maddocks.  I'm just trying to see if the tubes can be easily manufactured being killed and normalized.  The tubes will be seamless.  

I've been given an opportunity to quote a Sour (High H2S) gas cooler, which I've never done.  Is this something I should just stay away from, or does it just take a few extra precautions.

RE: Lean Amine Cooler

Go for it, you can find some real interesting stuff here.  You need to know if there's water present - if so, start looking at stainless.  if not, carbon steel, A179 tubes, normalized header boxes, stress relieved, self draining, maybe consider a heat coil for cold weather.   

RE: Lean Amine Cooler

(OP)
Just another quick question for everyone.  Would you use Carbon Steel over Stainless Steel for a lean amine cooler? Why?

RE: Lean Amine Cooler

Unless the client asked for stainless, I would stick with carbon steel.  Not many lean coolers are going stainless, however, you may see requests for stainless on the reflux cooler.  Again, go in with your base bid at carbon and option up so you can show the client the impact of this decision.

Carbon is usually adequate for lean coolers - the partial pressure is fairly low and the loading low. Given that there's no gas breakout and no acid gas attack, carbon is a pretty good choice.

RE: Lean Amine Cooler

(OP)
Thanks for the help. I'm trying to find ASTM A-515 Material though for the header design (normalized), and I've been told that it is incredibly difficult to find. Is this true? Could I just use Stainless Steel in lieu of the killed material?

RE: Lean Amine Cooler

You might find some issues with thermal stresses - most local mfr's go with A516-70N for header boxes.

RE: Lean Amine Cooler

(OP)
But isn't A516-70N non-killed material?

RE: Lean Amine Cooler

(OP)
All right, I'm getting all this figured out. Thanks, just one more question.  

Are turbulators advisable on Amine coolers, or should the coolers be bare tube only?

RE: Lean Amine Cooler

We usually save the use of turbulators for retrofit applications - using them in the original is a bit of a "cheat".  You could always offer them as an option if the buyer is interested in investigating.

RE: Lean Amine Cooler

(OP)
But technically it would pose any problems? Customer is asking for it to reduce size.

RE: Lean Amine Cooler

Well, you need to be confident in the pressure drop prediction as well as the possibility of any fouling.  There would be no problems with using them in the design.

RE: Lean Amine Cooler

(OP)
Thanks for all the help, I appreciate it.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources