×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Engine starting and stopping..
5

Engine starting and stopping..

Engine starting and stopping..

(OP)
I have a basic(silly!!) doubt about it.. When an ic engine(say 4 stroke) stops, it may stop at any position. When an engine is started, fuel supply and spark is given. But how its possible that it starts to run again in the same direction(CW-CCW)??
 I mean, it should run in the same direction, but whats the mechanism which makes sure that engine runs in the same direction??

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

the starter turns the motor the way it's intended to run.  for counter rotating engines say in a boat, you need one CW starter and one CCW starter.  If you ever shutdown or lose ignition on a marine engine under load, chances are it will diesel (run on) and actually runs backwards.  This can pull in water from the exhaust mani's which isn't nice either.  probably tmi, but it's your starter that must spin the right direction to get the engine running.  

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

On modern motors the electric starter only turns one direction.
If you get old enough, like my family's 1910 Michigan, then the electric starter does not guarantee rotation direction. The starter works by filling the cylinders with an explosive gas, then you press the button and all 4 cylinders fire hopefully spinning the motor in the right direction and not melting a hole in a piston. Needless to say we use the hand crank to avoid the problems with the starting system.

Luck is a difficult thing to verify and therefore should be tested often. - Me

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

Incidentally, engines usually stop in the same approximate position each time.

Cheers

Greg Locock

SIG:Please see FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips.

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

I'm struggling to come up with an actual 4 stroke engine that would be able to run the wrong direction.  Take a conventional spark-ignited engine.  It is a self powered pump.  There is no source of chemical energy on the exhaust side, so running backward is not an option.
Now a direct injected engine, diesel or gasoline, doesn't depend on the pumping action for chemical energy, but I'm pretty sure no electronic engine is going to allow itself to run backward, even if it were capable.  That leaves mechanical diesel engines.  Well, they depend on mechanically driven mechanical pumps for their chemical energy.  I'm going to go on a limb here and say in-line and distributor pumps are not going to be delivering fuel to the injectors when turning backwards.  That leaves mechanical unit injectors.  Hmmmn, it just might work!  (injection timing would suck, though).

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

(OP)
Greg, what makes sure that the piston stops approx. in the same position. It has 50% probability to stop either on its way (upwards or downwards.. irrespective of the stroke). Suppose if it stops on its upward way motion, when its started again by an explosion, it wil run in the opposite direction to which it was running previously right?

Carnage1, id like to know more about your 1910 Michigan..

Im totally unaware of the starters and motors you guys are talking about. Please provide me with some links, so that i can understand deeply.... and we are talking about ic engines only right??

Thanks again for replying me friends..

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

Nothing 'makes sure' it stops in the same place, it is just the way the whole thing works.  

Cheers

Greg Locock

SIG:Please see FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips.

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

The diesel engines that run backward are 2 stroke super or turbo charged, they are used in ships to get a reverse gear without a gearbox.
they have two camshafts for optimal performance in each direction
when the skipper wishes to change direction, fuel feed is stopped, compressed air injected into the cylinders timed to reverse the direction of the crankshaft, meanwhile the camshaft is swapped, then fuel feed is restarted.  If the fuel is restarted before the crankshaft changes direction, the engine will continue to run forward on the backward cam, but it runs very rough.

The super chargers or turbo chargers continue to run in the same direction while the engine runs in either direction

 

Hydrae

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

what drives the supercharger?

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

The ones I have known about were turbo, but an APU could drive the supercharger.  Compressed air was also directed at the turbos for cold startup.
Hydrae

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

"what drives the supercharger?"

Easy, you just put a twist in the belt smile

- Steve

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

(OP)
That was little explaining Hemi.. thanx..
Ive voted for u.. lot many times..

Let us see guys if someone can come up with a better explanation.. So lets keep it going..

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

"I'm going to go on a limb here and say in-line and distributor pumps are not going to be delivering fuel to the injectors when turning backwards."

I think you are right.  Althought the actual HP pumping elements don't know or care which way they are going, the supply pumps (I think DPA/DPC/DPS use vane pumps) are going be running the wrong way to work.

- Steve

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

cshmech (Mechanical)      
2 Oct 08 21:23
... when its started again by an explosion ...

What engines are started by an explosion?  Everything I am familiar with has some form of electrical starter, air starter, kick starter, pull starter, spring starter or hand crank.  None of these is going to start the engine in the reverse direction.  I know of no four strokes that will run backwards.  

Lots of 2 strokes will run backwards but the spark timing will be way late so they make very little power.  Glow plug two strokes on the other hand will happily run backwards.  Some of those are most easily started by turning them backwards & the first combustion event will reverse direction & make them run forward.

Engines almost always stop as they are coming up against a compression stroke.  Almost never on an expansion stroke.  Multi cylinder engines are less consistent as the forces are more nearly balanced.

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

(OP)
dgallup..  gr8 man.. Starred u..
You explained almost everything..

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

Mazda does have a new system that starts a small 4-stroke using an explosion, I believe on a direct-injection engine.  Similar to the two-stroke in dgallup's post.

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

In the movie "Flight of the Phoenix" the engine is started by what looks like shot gun cartridges inside a revolver barrel.  The shot is fired, then a sound of a turbine whining, while the blade starts to spin, whether this is an exhaust poof depends when the bad guys are about to arrive.

Anyone know how that works?
Hydrae

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

Bombardier snowmobiles with their SDI electronically-controlled fuel-injected two-stroke engines go in reverse by reversing the rotation of the engine at a push of a button ...

When you press the button, it cuts fuel, then as the engine coasts down the ECU predicts the stroke at which the engine will fail to get over the next compression stroke, and gives that cylinder a squirt of fuel, then fires the spark plug the moment the engine comes to a stop on that compression stroke ... presto, the engine then runs backwards. Saves having to make a forward/reverse gearbox. Presumably this offsets some of the extra cost of the fuel injection and emission control apparatus.

But the normal starting mechanism is only capable of rotating the engine in the forward direction, as per standard practice.

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

hydrae
That is a Kaufman or hot gas starter, an explosion from a cartridge is turned into a stream of hot gas to spin an engine up to speed for start. Lighter ,yes, more reliable , not always.
B.E.

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

"Flight of the Phoenix" - I second the inquiry.  Of course it works dramatically by building suspense whether the engines will start before they run out of cartridges.  But how did it work mechanically??   

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

A 4 cycle diesel engine will run in reverse. I have done it.  

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

Was it a mechanical unit injector engine?

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

It won't run well, the injection is going to be way late.

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

A conventional 4 stroke engine doesn't
Explode" at random. The charge is ignited by the spark plug. If the engine starts to run backwards it will be sucking in the exhaust and blowing out the carb. You can't get any fuel that way so it stops instead of running backwards.
Old diesel powered Caterpilars would sometimes kick bak when lugged down badly. They would suck air in the exhaust and blow out the air cleaner. In those days the air cleaners were oil bath. Another scenario was backing up a hill at the end of the day and running down the hill in the morning to start the engine. If you forgot to shift out of reverse before starting the Ccat would start and run backwards. This was not good for the engine for several reasons. The operator did not enjoy the face full of oil he usually got when the exhaust started issuing from the air cleaner.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

Rolls Royce used a system called "Static Start" insome of their cars. No starter at all. I originally heard about this from an Engineer born and raised in England who came to the U.S. in the 50's. He indicated it worked well even when the engine had been off for dsys.

Static-start engine
Another way to provide for shutting off a car's engine when it is stopped, then immediately restarting it when it's time to go, is by employing a static-start engine. Such an engine requires no starter motor, but employs sensors to determine the exact position of each piston, then precisely timing the injection and ignition of fuel to turn over the engine.[2]

This was from a Google search for "Static Start Engine"

This is the only info I could find on it.
 

Bud Trinkel, Fluid Power Consultant
HYDRA-PNEU CONSULTING

RE: Engine starting and stopping..

(OP)
thanks budt and waross for the information...

<<<BREATHE  AUTOMOTIVES>>>
-Harish

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources