I am looking at a design for a 50 foot diameter sewage digester cover (roof). It has 20ea 3x4 inch arched tubes 23-foot +/- long extending inward and upward from a 50-foot diameter tension ring and ending at a 2-foot diameter compression ring. The rings are either 3x3 tubes or 3-inch pipe. Welded to the underside of the radial beams (tubes) are 20ea pie shaped plates. This is a standard design and thousands have been made of mild steel/structural steel with a painted finish. As all of the shapes are available in 304SS, I am thinking of specifying SS for all members/plates. Could anyone hazard a guess as to the cost multiplier?
This project needs to be completed in a 90 day window (college campus) and is in an environmentally sensitive area. I am thinking that the additional cost could be justified by the elimination of blasting and painting on-site. Also, the steel plates need to be welded continuously at the bottom of the lap where SS plates need only to be welded at the top lap. I am thinking that elimination of the overhead weld would save some money. Thanks in advance !! Steve
Red Flag Submitted
Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts. The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.
Reply To This Thread
Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.
3D printing has opened new doors to rapid prototyping and even rapid production, providing users with the unprecedented ability to visualize products before mass manufacturing and create new designs that could not be made by any other method. Download Now
Ensuring that product lifecycle stakeholders throughout your organization can access the most accurate, up-to-date product information will benefit all aspects of both the product and the organization itself. Download Now
Since the IEEE 802.3bj 100 Gb/s Backplane Ethernet standard has been officially approved, Channel Operating Margin (COM) will likely become an important quality-evaluation method for SERDES links. Download Now