×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Nonhazardous liquid for hydrostatic test during winter

Nonhazardous liquid for hydrostatic test during winter

Nonhazardous liquid for hydrostatic test during winter

(OP)
Hi,

we need to do an hydrostatic test concerning a huge (internal volume more than 60,000 cu. ft.) pressure vessel manufactured outside during winter 2008-2009.

Can you give me ideas of none hazardous liquid you normally using in these cases (brainstorming)?  The liquid shall be easily re-usable because our customer (petroleum refinery) is certified ISO 14001.

Note :  the liquid flash point shall not be higher than 110F.

Thank in advance,

hcjulien

RE: Nonhazardous liquid for hydrostatic test during winter


why the limitation on flash point?

RE: Nonhazardous liquid for hydrostatic test during winter

Should that be flash point will be higher than 110F?

How about bio diesel?

RE: Nonhazardous liquid for hydrostatic test during winter



Propyleneglycol is friendly too.

 

RE: Nonhazardous liquid for hydrostatic test during winter

(OP)
Hi,

concerning the flash point request, ASME Section VIII div. 1 UG-99(h)is requesting a maximum flash point of 110F if combustible liquids is used near atmospheric temperature.

Many thanks dcasto and RCHandy for your answer.

Any others suggestions?

Regards,

Hcjulien

RE: Nonhazardous liquid for hydrostatic test during winter

Your volume is rather large for liquids other than water so some disposal or storage facility is almost a must have.

What is the minimum temperature expected around your testing schedule?  

RE: Nonhazardous liquid for hydrostatic test during winter

(OP)
Worst temperature expected during hydro test: -29C (-20F)

RE: Nonhazardous liquid for hydrostatic test during winter

As you mention a possible low temperature of -29C have you considered the chances of brittle fracture?  At hydrotest the induced stress level at some point is higher than the allowable stress (assuming you are using the full MAWP).  

I do not think that you will be able to find a non-freezing fluid similar to water that will not pose disposal problems.

EJL

RE: Nonhazardous liquid for hydrostatic test during winter

Water/glycol mixes have been used.

RE: Nonhazardous liquid for hydrostatic test during winter

It sounds like you'd be better off heating water rather than trying to find a water replacement.

Re-read that section you mentioned in UG 99.  It's not requiring a low flash point.  It says any fluid may be used, but if the flash point is below 110, it can only be used for near-ambient temperature tests.

RE: Nonhazardous liquid for hydrostatic test during winter

hcjulien,

Water added with antifreeze like methanol have been used during winter hydrotest. Check with the local environmental regulatory agency for requirements on hydrostatic testing.

What is the MDMT of the vessel? The Code "recommends" that the vessel metal temperature during hydrotest be maintained at least 30 deg F above the MDMT to minimize brittle fracture.

RE: Nonhazardous liquid for hydrostatic test during winter

It sounds like it would be cheeper to build a temporary building or tent around the vessel and keep the whole thing above freezing and use water.  Brittle failure at low temperatures is both very common and very dangerous.

David

RE: Nonhazardous liquid for hydrostatic test during winter

I would go with the water option with a pumping and heating system to keep temperature within max and min limits, then just seal off and carry out hydro test in the normal way. The temperature drop from max over the time to do the test and inspections may not be so great to course concern but a few basic calcs should confirm this.

 

RE: Nonhazardous liquid for hydrostatic test during winter

(OP)
One of our process engineer suggest me the following option:

-jet fuel
-Artic diesel

Both are with flash point below 110F (important if combustible fluid is used, see UG-99(h))
Boiling point above 110F
Freezing point below -29C (-20F)
Reusable in the raffinery
Specific gravity below 1.0 (water)

RE: Nonhazardous liquid for hydrostatic test during winter

(OP)
Oups I forgot to ask you what do you think?

Please take note that the hydrostatic test temperature will be between 50F @ 110F (MDMT = -40F).  Also the test pressure is 151 PSIG during 1 hour 10 minutes + time required for inspection.

Regards,

hcjulien

RE: Nonhazardous liquid for hydrostatic test during winter

Combustible liquid as test medium for a 60,000 cu. ft. vessel?  Hmmm...potential fire, explosion and environmental damage if the vessel fails during test. Have you determined how many fire fighters and how many cubic feet of extinguishing foam you need on standby for the test? How about the containment system (e.g. dikes) in case of leak or spill?


In what country and state/province would this hydrostatic test take place?

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources